I’m biased, but I’d definitely put Edwards on the 10 person AA team.
For sure. Manning the post alone against some of the top teams in the Country is no small feat, and Aaliyah made it look damn good.
I’m biased, but I’d definitely put Edwards on the 10 person AA team.
It happens to ALL of us!Kitley, darn spell check.
She looked pretty darn good against us..
As for Hidalgo, she’s had her share of less than efficient offensive games too. But she is far and away the most dangerous defensive player in the country.
They got it right.ESPN leads off the season’s AA teams, POY, etc. with their selections by Creme, Voepel & Philippou as follows:
AA team
Clark
Brink
Watkins
Hidalgo
Bueckers
POY - Clark
FOY - Watkins
COY - Staley
Lots of great players out there, but I have to say that I think ESPN got it right. I have no doubt there will be some grumbling in Baton Rouge….
Rickea Jackson - should be no worse than the second player picked in the upcoming WNBA draft.It will be interesting to see the 10 player WBCA AA team when it’s announced. The ESPN 5 + Cardoso? Reese? Paopao? Osborne? Edwards? TBD?
Stats are a big part fo the story, but the key is that they both make their teams better and have proven that in a one and done scenario, they are dangerous.Watkins
Hidalgo
I just check their stat. Emm...not so good.
Wrong era, Kittle played for Villanova 20 years ago. Maybe you meant Liz Kitley?Based on what I’ve seen, the biggest grumble would be for omitting Kittle in favor of Hidalgo.
Could be, VAU, but I suspect Clark ad Brink will be picked ahead of Rickea.Rickea Jackson - should be no worse than the second player picked in the upcoming WNBA draft.
Pretty solid list. With any picks, especially when picking such a limited number, there will always be some grumblings about a player being left off the "select" few. I think the ESPN AA teams looks pretty solid. Great job, ESPN crew.ESPN leads off the season’s AA teams, POY, etc. with their selections by Creme, Voepel & Philippou as follows:
AA team
Clark
Brink
Watkins
Hidalgo
Bueckers
POY - Clark
FOY - Watkins
COY - Staley
Lots of great players out there, but I have to say that I think ESPN got it right. I have no doubt there will be some grumbling in Baton Rouge….
By having a greater impact. Have you seen her play? She does everything, including rebounding and doesn’t need anybody else to make a difference. The ACC, IMO, picked the wrong POY; apparently, ESPN agreed.And how does Hidalgo make the team over ACC player of the year Kitley?
YupWrong era, Kittle played for Villanova 20 years ago. Maybe you meant Liz Kitley?
I agree that JuJu passes the eye test. She & Madison Booker possess a unique skill set and will help continue to revolutionize the women's game. However, it does appear that the season is taking the sting out of her game. Ironically, of the 5 listed as ESPN's All-Americans, only Paige produced higher than average statistical numbers.When it comes to JuJu, she completely passes the eye test for me. Her size, athleticism and skill set is pretty unique to the women’s game. She’s also made USC relevant again. However over the last 10 games of the season, she has shot 80/226 35% and 16/58 from 3 28%. To me, she’s run out of steam down the stretch. When your reputation is being a scorer, I personally value having some efficiency. She’s was only a few more missed shots away from averaging under 40% for the year. What she’s accomplished is incredible, and she’ll likely only get better and more efficient with age. But the efficiency makes me stop and pause. It’s weird how she’s a consensus AA, when the same TO and efficiency issues cost Clark first team as a freshman.
Hidalgo lit UConn up, but she scored a lot of those points with Nika sitting on the bench in foul trouble. Would she have scored all those points with Nika in the game? Who knows. Not that it matters, she scored the points.She looked pretty darn good against us.
Aaliya Edwards COULD be chosen ahead of Rickea too. I like them both pretty equally. If both were in the board, the question for me would be whose personality fits my team the best.Could be, VAU, but I suspect Clark ad Brink will be picked ahead of Rickea.
"Efficiency issues" Clark's freshman year? I have seen this take elsewhere as well, and can't figure it out. Guess it's just part of the anti-Clark sentiment. Not sure how an effective field goal percentage of 57.4% (ranking in the 96th percentile) can count as having efficiency issues, let alone the same efficiency issues as Watkins, with her 44.9% effective field goal percentage (ranking in the 48th percentile)... . . It’s weird how she’s [Watkins] a consensus AA, when the same TO and efficiency issues cost Clark first team as a freshman.
SEASON | PLAYER | TEAM | PTS | EFG% | AST/TOV | AST | TOV |
2020-21 | Paige Bueckers | UConn | 20 | 59.9% | 2.3 | 5.8 | 2.5 |
2020-21 | Caitlin Clark | Iowa | 26.6 | 57.4% | 1.49 | 7.1 | 4.8 |
2023-24 | Hannah Hidalgo | Notre Dame | 23.3 | 49.5% | 1.61 | 5.5 | 3.4 |
2023-24 | JuJu Watkins | Southern Cal | 27.0 | 44.9% | 0.77 | 3.2 | 4.2 |
Thank you for this. I was going off memory, and recall Clark not being on the AP first team. In the comparison with Bueckers, I just remember efficiency and turnovers being topics of conversation. It’s illuminating to see how high Clark’s EFG was. Maybe her snub was more related to team performance."Efficiency issues" Clark's freshman year? I have seen this take elsewhere as well, and can't figure it out. Guess it's just part of the anti-Clark sentiment. Not sure how an effective field goal percentage of 57.4% (ranking in the 96th percentile) can count as having efficiency issues, let alone the same efficiency issues as Watkins, with her 44.9% effective field goal percentage (ranking in the 48th percentile)..
Clark's a high-volume turnover player, but the Watkins turnover comparison seems incomplete. Clark had a 1.49 assist-to-turnover ratio her freshman. A solid, not great figure, and not too far south of Hidalgo at 1.61. Watkins is at .77, meaning more turnovers than assists. That is a pitiful figure for a guard with high utilization, and not comparable to either Clark or Hidalgo, let alone Paige at well over 2.
SEASON PLAYER TEAM PTS EFG% AST/TOV AST TOV 2020-21 Paige Bueckers UConn 20 59.9% 2.3 5.8 2.5 2020-21 Caitlin Clark Iowa 26.6 57.4% 1.49 7.1 4.8 2023-24 Hannah Hidalgo Notre Dame 23.3 49.5% 1.61 5.5 3.4 2023-24 JuJu Watkins Southern Cal 27.0 44.9% 0.77 3.2 4.2
Also, her freshman year, Clark was 1st Team AA by USBWA (5 player) and WBCA AA (10 player). She was also 2nd Team AA by AP (5 player). Those are the three AA teams the NCAA uses to determine unanimous AA. So if WBB had a consensus 1st-Team AA, Clark would have made it, but not unanimous AA.
JuJu passes the eye test for sure, except for her decision making. I saw JuJu in person, courtside vs Oregon State. JuJu was 6 for 34 in that game. USC won the game, but OSU didn't have Raegan Beers for that game. JuJu has great physical capabilities, supreme confidence, and is going to be #1 pick in WNBA at some point in the future. JuJu was also 11 for 33 in the USC's first game vs Oregon State back in January. What's the point? JuJu would be on my 1st Team AA team but for her decision making. I think it is getting better, knowing when to shoot vs pass, as demonstrated in their last game vs Stanford, but based upon the entire season, JuJu would be in my TOP 10-15 but not TOP 5.When it comes to JuJu, she completely passes the eye test for me. Her size, athleticism and skill set is pretty unique to the women’s game. She’s also made USC relevant again. However over the last 10 games of the season, she has shot 80/226 35% and 16/58 from 3 28%. To me, she’s run out of steam down the stretch. When your reputation is being a scorer, I personally value having some efficiency. She’s was only a few more missed shots away from averaging under 40% for the year. What she’s accomplished is incredible, and she’ll likely only get better and more efficient with age. But the efficiency makes me stop and pause. It’s weird how she’s a consensus AA, when the same TO and efficiency issues cost Clark first team as a freshman.
Watkins
Hidalgo
I just check their stat. Emm...not so good.
Hidalgo makes ND run, Kitley kinda overrated… runs off Georgia A..And how does Hidalgo make the team over ACC player of the year Kitley?