Duke’s Joanne P. McCallie resigns | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Duke’s Joanne P. McCallie resigns

Caldwell recruited dismally at UCLA. With the exception of Markel Walker, she signed a bunch of unranked combo forwards who couldn't shoot. Had Jasmine Dixon not transferred in, there's a good chance the LSU offer would not have come. I think she's a strong Xs and Os coach but I think the place she could do best would be either the WNBA or in the commentators booth.

She wasn’t there long, but the Dixon xfer was big and she had the number 3 class in the country in 2011 before leaving for LSU. Didn’t follow them after she left, and I believe the class fell apart but I wouldn’t say that’s dismal.
 
She wasn’t there long, but the Dixon xfer was big and she had the number 3 class in the country in 2011 before leaving for LSU. Didn’t follow them after she left, and I believe the class fell apart but I wouldn’t say that’s dismal.

Her classes:

2009
#4 Markel Walker
UR Mariah Williams

2010
UR Rhema Gardner
UR Thea Lemberger
UR Corrine Costa

2011

#25 Kacy Swain
#26 Sheila Boykin
UR Moriah Faulk

Williams and Lemberger were both points but not Div 1 starters, although Lemberger would eventually acquit herself well. That left UCLA without a strong starting point. They were also consistently losing the recruiting battle to USC with players like Crook Williams, Cassie Herberts and Southall.
 
Raegan Pebley is still a bit of an unknown, but she has TCU headed in the right direction, Duke should give her a look.
 
Caldwell recruited dismally at UCLA. With the exception of Markel Walker, she signed a bunch of unranked combo forwards who couldn't shoot. Had Jasmine Dixon not transferred in, there's a good chance the LSU offer would not have come. I think she's a strong Xs and Os coach but I think the place she could do best would be either the WNBA or in the commentators booth.

bingo. Although she is so concerned with building a team around defense, she doesn’t recruit enough pure shooters to execute at a high level offensively. Which is why she will never go far or anywhere in the NCAAT

when she took over at LSU, van left quite a few top 100 recruits on roster. That was when we had most our success. As soon as it was all her players, we either didn’t make the NCAAT or we get bounced first round
 
I have an audio tape of the call between AD White and JPM so here's my translation for my fellow WCBB Brethren:
White: "Hello, AD White here, I think I have seen this phone number before but I don't have it in my contact list who is this?"
JPM: "It's Coach McCallie and well, I wanted to talk to you about my contract"
White: "What about your contract? I see in my records, you have one year left on it at $1.1 Million per year"
JPM: "Yeah but I will be a lame duck as a coach and given all that I have done for Duke, I think I am owed an extension so that we show support for the program"
White: "You know coach, with this pandemic going on and it would not be fiscally responsible for me to enter into negotiations or announce a new contract when you are already under contract and we are not even sure of when or if college athletics will be allowed to resume".
JPM: "No, seriously, we need to talk about an an extension so that we each show faith in the program and in support of the great program I have built here".
White: (crickets, no sound but mild breathing)
JPM: "No, seriously, I think we need to talk about this or I am going to resign!"
White: "Ok Great, your resigning, got it, thanks for the call...soooo DO YOU want to call the press release on your resignation or do you want me to hold a video conference call announcing our search is starting a year earlier than I expected?"
JPM: "No really, I am going to announce I am resigning...I am going to count to 3, 1....2....3...?
White: (again, crickets, no sound but mild breathing)...
:rolleyes:

BTW please tell @triaddukefan and @CamrnCrz1974 to be responsible and wear the mask while staying as socially responsible as they can at the bars tonight!
 
Last edited:
.-.
So to be clear, I guess resignation means she forfeited her last year's 1.1 million?

Why did she not stay for the final year and get the money or force Duke to fire with some buyout activated?
 
So to be clear, I guess resignation means she forfeited her last year's 1.1 million?

Why did she not stay for the final year and get the money or force Duke to fire with some buyout activated?
She said she opted "to forgo the majority of my final year of compensation to support my staff during this incredibly challenging and transitional time overall."

Um... Right!!

 
While I might have done a dance while singing "Hava Nagila" earlier (before texting @EricLA , @ucbart , and others), two things that really struck me about Joanne P. McCallie's statements in the video upon my second viewing:

  1. She appeared to infer that because Duke did not offer her a contract extension (and she was, in fact, told by Duke that she would not be receiving one now or at the end of the contract), Duke was responsible for the uncertainty that would follow a coach in her last year of the contract.
  2. She stated that because of the pandemic, the 2019-20 team “has not been fully recognized for the record-setting crescendo to the season.”
These two statements encapsulate a number of my thoughts and opinions about McCallie and her tenure at Duke.
  • Not taking responsibility for her actions and failing to acknowledge that certain events are the results of HER conduct/behavior; and
  • Attempting to glorify mediocrity and insist on praise for “not bad” achievements by referencing them as somehow historic
 
While I might have done a dance while singing "Hava Nagila" earlier (before texting @EricLA , @ucbart , and others), two things that really struck me about Joanne P. McCallie's statements in the video upon my second viewing:
  • Not taking responsibility for her actions and failing to acknowledge that certain events are the results of HER conduct/behavior; and
  • Attempting to glorify mediocrity and insist on praise for “not bad” achievements by referencing them as somehow historic
Excellent post. I especially wanted to highlight the part of your post I bolded. For your first observation, I recall her constantly blaming poor results on injuries, or other things that were "beyond her control". She was never able to play the hand she was dealt without a bunch of excuses.

But I really liked the second part of your thoughts - I do have to admit - the team REALLY surprised me the lats month or so of the season - they really came on gangbusters. perhaps it was in part due to playing more man to man instead of 100% zone defense, or perhaps it was a combo of many other things.

The only thing I really will miss about her (actually 3 things).
  1. Her continued insistence on referring to opposing players by their numbers, not their names. I don't know how many other coaches do that, but I found it annoying and really did not understand the purpose of it (or maybe I did and just found it silly)
  2. After almost EVERY loss, there were always comments about "lessons learned". You would think after 13 or so years at Duke, she would shelve that tired old phrase
  3. Her constantly referring to herself as "Coach P". Never understood the Joanne P McCallie whenever someone used her name, or why she insisted on being called Coach P. I'm sure there is a reason, I don't really care. It was dumb.
By the way Barry, I found a picture of you doing the Hava Nagila. Which one are you?! :p

1593740826847.png
 
BTW please tell @triaddukefan and @CamrnCrz1974 to be responsible and wear the mask while staying as socially responsible as they can at the bars tonight!

Well the bars are closed here in NC.... and the earliest they can open is July 17th ..... but I did have a big smile on my face this evening while I cut the backyard. :cool:


While I might have done a dance while singing "Hava Nagila" earlier (before texting @EricLA , @ucbart , and others), two things that really struck me about Joanne P. McCallie's statements in the video upon my second viewing:


I actually haven't seen the video yet. At this point think imma wait til I have something cold and refreshing to drink before I watch it
 
  1. She appeared to infer that because Duke did not offer her a contract extension (and she was, in fact, told by Duke that she would not be receiving one now or at the end of the contract), Duke was responsible for the uncertainty that would follow a coach in her last year of the contract.
  2. She stated that because of the pandemic, the 2019-20 team “has not been fully recognized for the record-setting crescendo to the season.”
The phrase "record-setting crescendo" is a first-time collocation to my ears. Not exactly sure how the "crescendo" gets measured for proper recordkeeping, but maybe she can elaborate on that in her retirement.
 
.-.
Raegan Pebley is still a bit of an unknown, but she has TCU headed in the right direction, Duke should give her a look.
I have always liked her and think she is a good coach. But she played at Colorado, and I think started the program at a school in Idaho? before heading to TCU. So I'm not sure she is east coast likely.
 
  1. Her constantly referring to herself as "Coach P". Never understood the Joanne P McCallie whenever someone used her name, or why she insisted on being called Coach P. I'm sure there is a reason, I don't really care. It was dumb.
Yeah, a bit weird. I mean, she was Coach P (Palumbo) back when she was at Maine, but once she got married, you would have thought . . . Or, if she liked it so much, she could have kept her maiden name, as many coaches do. Gail, actually, was married when she was at Duke.

Then again, over the years some don't understand the "C Vivian Stringer", either. She even went along with folks who said it stood for coach, actually, its just her first initial, Vivian is her middle name.
 
The phrase "record-setting crescendo" is a first-time collocation to my ears. Not exactly sure how the "crescendo" gets measured for proper recordkeeping, but maybe she can elaborate on that in her retirement.

Unfortunately I was there for the end of that crescendo :oops:
 
I guess declining to renew or extend a contract is slightly different from firing, but I've been pretty surprised at the level of expectation shown by Texas and Duke this year.

I guess both coaches made a lot of money and were not delivering titles, but difficult to say they weren't consistent winners.
 
From a Duke AD point of view, with the season still in question due to COVID and their budgets really tight the best fiscal decision is to name an interim HC from the existing staff. Then see how the season plays out and take the time to do a thorough search unless they've quietly been searching for a while and have their choice and just haven't told the public yet....

For instance, who really knows if say Beth Cunningham was chosen a couple months ago and Duke has made her keep it quiet while they dealt with JPM. I'm sure it cost Duke less contract wise for JPM to quit versus being fired so Duke could have been increasingly making JPM's work life more challenging.... this is business.... Another example, it appears TX had made a deal with Vic loooonngg before Aston and the public knew.
 
The phrase "record-setting crescendo" is a first-time collocation to my ears. Not exactly sure how the "crescendo" gets measured for proper recordkeeping, but maybe she can elaborate on that in her retirement.
I love this collocation and will add it to the verbal repertoire going forward. It and Dawn's Mythical National Championship are two of the (very few) good things to come out of this wretched off-non-season.
 
.-.
The 10 candidates ESPN suggests-Gail tops their list:


You can't take a list seriously that has Lindsay Gottlieb on it. Nice lady but she was practically run out of Berkeley. Her diminishing results speak for themselves. Once she left and Charmin Smith returned, recruiting immediately picked up.
 
You can't take a list seriously that has Lindsay Gottlieb on it. Nice lady but she was practically run out of Berkeley. Her diminishing results speak for themselves. Once she left and Charmin Smith returned, recruiting immediately picked up.

I just looked at that list. Gottlieb? Rizzoti? :confused:
 
.-.
I didn't know Duke had job openings for clowns.
I think that @stwainfan hasn't master the art of inserting the :rolleyes: or the :p emojji yet, give them time as Tennessee fans are still living in 2008 and emoji's weren't strong in the lexicon yet....;)

Clearly they had to be mocking Mechelle Voepel whose list really contains one viable candidate, two quasi-candidates and the rest are pure ignorant name droppings. Typical of the lazy journalism we have come to expect from Mechelle.

Duke has already stated they will not interview Gail, who frankly needs to take on a lesser program to rebuild her credentials.
Gottlieb-she's lucky to have left Cal when she did before not being retained,
Joanne Boyle-sorry @Dillon77, but Joanne was not going to be retained and UVa let her leave gracefully, she's not worthy of a P5 pristine program anymore and needs to rebuild her brand,
ANY ND assistant -no way Duke wants to hire from that tree while competing against ND in the ACC, it hurts their brand,
Curt Miller -ZERO recruiting experience and college rules and connection nuances,
Katie Meier-what has she really done at Miami to warrant a move up? Heck if she didn't get Mompremier as at Transfer, they would have been terrible.
Adia Barnes-is clearly a west coast coach with zero east coast connections plus she's building a very good program ready for national prominence year in and year out,
and even Shea Ralph-she's committed to the UConn program and is probably the heir apparent to take over and she's got her husband coaching up here and family.
These all silly names to throw out as names as they simply aren't viable for any number of the reasons and more than I gave.

The others of Langley at Rice has had a nice run but is she really elite enough and has she done enough at Rice to warrant the Duke consideration? At least she coached on the east coast.
Clark-Heard at Cincinnati has done a nice job at two significantly lesser programs but what has she really won during her career? Not thinking she's ready yet for a P5 program. Win the American next year without UConn in it and make some headway in the NCAA Tournament, then we can talk.
Joy Smith at Clemson is a nice alumni name to through out but why would Duke give the program to someone without any coaching experience let alone no assistant experience at Duke?

Jennie Baranczyk at Drake at least has head coaching experience, strong historical conference success and P5 playing experience. Whether she has the east coast connections is the only real question.

Of the names listed by anyone on this thread, Jennie is the only one that is logical.

I guess if Alana Beard wants in as a coach, Duke would have to listen but surround her with some legitimate assistants. But even Dawn Staley who was a significantly more accomplished player had to earn her bona fides at Temple before developing the monster she's creating at SC. That would be pretty big leap of faith for Duke.

Humbly submitted, DefenseBB
 
I think that @stwainfan hasn't master the art of inserting the :rolleyes: or the :p emojji yet, give them time as Tennessee fans are still living in 2008 and emoji's weren't strong in the lexicon yet....;)

Clearly they had to be mocking Mechelle Voepel whose list really contains one viable candidate, two quasi-candidates and the rest are pure ignorant name droppings. Typical of the lazy journalism we have come to expect from Mechelle.

Duke has already stated they will not interview Gail, who frankly needs to take on a lesser program to rebuild her credentials.
Gottlieb-she's lucky to have left Cal when she did before not being retained,
Joanne Boyle-sorry @Dillon77, but Joanne was not going to be retained and UVa let her leave gracefully, she's not worthy of a P5 pristine program anymore and needs to rebuild her brand,
ANY ND assistant -no way Duke wants to hire from that tree while competing against ND in the ACC, it hurts their brand,
Curt Miller -ZERO recruiting experience and college rules and connection nuances,
Katie Meier-what has she really done at Miami to warrant a move up? Heck if she didn't get Mompremier as at Transfer, they would have been terrible.
Adia Barnes-is clearly a west coast coach with zero east coast connections plus she's building a very good program ready for national prominence year in and year out,
and even Shea Ralph-she's committed to the UConn program and is probably the heir apparent to take over and she's got her husband coaching up here and family.
These all silly names to throw out as names as they simply aren't viable for any number of the reasons and more than I gave.

The others of Langley at Rice has had a nice run but is she really elite enough and has she done enough at Rice to warrant the Duke consideration? At least she coached on the east coast.
Clark-Heard at Cincinnati has done a nice job at two significantly lesser programs but what has she really won during her career? Not thinking she's ready yet for a P5 program. Win the American next year without UConn in it and make some headway in the NCAA Tournament, then we can talk.
Joy Smith at Clemson is a nice alumni name to through out but why would Duke give the program to someone without any coaching experience let alone no assistant experience at Duke?

Jennie Baranczyk at Drake at least has head coaching experience, strong historical conference success and P5 playing experience. Whether she has the east coast connections is the only real question.

Of the names listed by anyone on this thread, Jennie is the only one that is logical.

I guess if Alana Beard wants in as a coach, Duke would have to listen but surround her with some legitimate assistants. But even Dawn Staley who was a significantly more accomplished player had to earn her bona fides at Temple before developing the monster she's creating at SC. That would be pretty big leap of faith for Duke.

Humbly submitted, DefenseBB

Agree with everything you've written. It's really something that the first name mentioned by Mechelle Voepel is shot down by Duke almost immediately. Gail tells MV she's interested, MV puts Gail's name at the top of her list, Gail tells MV Duke will not consider her for the job. Ouch.
 
I think that @stwainfan hasn't master the art of inserting the :rolleyes: or the :p emojji yet, give them time as Tennessee fans are still living in 2008 and emoji's weren't strong in the lexicon yet....;)

Clearly they had to be mocking Mechelle Voepel whose list really contains one viable candidate, two quasi-candidates and the rest are pure ignorant name droppings. Typical of the lazy journalism we have come to expect from Mechelle.

Duke has already stated they will not interview Gail, who frankly needs to take on a lesser program to rebuild her credentials.
Gottlieb-she's lucky to have left Cal when she did before not being retained,
Joanne Boyle-sorry @Dillon77, but Joanne was not going to be retained and UVa let her leave gracefully, she's not worthy of a P5 pristine program anymore and needs to rebuild her brand,
ANY ND assistant -no way Duke wants to hire from that tree while competing against ND in the ACC, it hurts their brand,
Curt Miller -ZERO recruiting experience and college rules and connection nuances,
Katie Meier-what has she really done at Miami to warrant a move up? Heck if she didn't get Mompremier as at Transfer, they would have been terrible.
Adia Barnes-is clearly a west coast coach with zero east coast connections plus she's building a very good program ready for national prominence year in and year out,
and even Shea Ralph-she's committed to the UConn program and is probably the heir apparent to take over and she's got her husband coaching up here and family.
These all silly names to throw out as names as they simply aren't viable for any number of the reasons and more than I gave.

The others of Langley at Rice has had a nice run but is she really elite enough and has she done enough at Rice to warrant the Duke consideration? At least she coached on the east coast.
Clark-Heard at Cincinnati has done a nice job at two significantly lesser programs but what has she really won during her career? Not thinking she's ready yet for a P5 program. Win the American next year without UConn in it and make some headway in the NCAA Tournament, then we can talk.
Joy Smith at Clemson is a nice alumni name to through out but why would Duke give the program to someone without any coaching experience let alone no assistant experience at Duke?

Jennie Baranczyk at Drake at least has head coaching experience, strong historical conference success and P5 playing experience. Whether she has the east coast connections is the only real question.

Of the names listed by anyone on this thread, Jennie is the only one that is logical.

I guess if Alana Beard wants in as a coach, Duke would have to listen but surround her with some legitimate assistants. But even Dawn Staley who was a significantly more accomplished player had to earn her bona fides at Temple before developing the monster she's creating at SC. That would be pretty big leap of faith for Duke.

Humbly submitted, DefenseBB


A few corrections..... Curt Miller coached at Bowling Green.... led them to the sweet 16 in 2007. But Duke aint hiring a male WBB coach. Joy Smith was an assistant at Duke from 2011-13. I floated the Drake coach on here before... and on another site. She's an Iowa woman... and perhaps she has her eyes on the Iowa job when it opens.
 
A few corrections..... Curt Miller coached at Bowling Green.... led them to the sweet 16 in 2007. But Duke aint hiring a male WBB coach. Joy Smith was an assistant at Duke from 2011-13. I floated the Drake coach on here before... and on another site. She's an Iowa woman... and perhaps she has her eyes on the Iowa job when it opens.
Thanks, I was going to bring up Bowling Green. Saw them play in the NCAA's - I think they were in the "other pod" during that period where they did the 8 team thing, in any case they didn't play Rutgers if they were in the same group. And yes, I agree, I think the Drake coach may have her eyes on Iowa, following (literally) in Bluder's footsteps.
 
.-.

Forum statistics

Threads
167,930
Messages
4,545,423
Members
10,426
Latest member
kmbazz15


Top Bottom