I like Girardi a lot but he is looking like an idiot now. Either that, or he looks like a guy that threw a game. I don't really think that is the case but his rush to "rest" his best players is costing a game that actually means something to someone. I wouldn't be surprised if he gets a call from Selig. We will never hear about it but I would be surprised if it doesn't come. He was pulling his best position players left and right when he had that "comfortable" lead. He was also pulling pitchers that were looking good. It was almost like he was looking for a pitcher that was "off" today. I can see not using key pitchers and even limiting pitches for non-key guys. But there is no excuse for pulling his best position players. Would a few innings of extra rest really make THAT much of a difference?
He had NO obligation to play his regulars longer. NONE.I like Girardi a lot but he is looking like an idiot now. Either that, or he looks like a guy that threw a game. I don't really think that is the case but his rush to "rest" his best players is costing a game that actually means something to someone. I wouldn't be surprised if he gets a call from Selig. We will never hear about it but I would be surprised if it doesn't come. He was pulling his best position players left and right when he had that "comfortable" lead. He was also pulling pitchers that were looking good. It was almost like he was looking for a pitcher that was "off" today. I can see not using key pitchers and even limiting pitches for non-key guys. But there is no excuse for pulling his best position players. Would a few innings of extra rest really make THAT much of a difference ?
He had NO obligation to play his regulars longer. NONE.
His only obligation was to get his team ready for the playoffs.
Sox had it all in their hands and they blew it. Win tonight, win tomorrow.
Talk about rolling over and playing dead, Sinkhole...
He had NO obligation to play his regulars longer. NONE.
His only obligation was to get his team ready for the playoffs.
Sox had it all in their hands and they blew it. Win tonight, win tomorrow.
Girardi's pitching plan and execution was just embarrassing. He didn't take the game seriously and fortunately for the Rays the Yanks were running on fumes.
Amazing night.
And Carl Crawford...what a signing Theo!!
In your rush to disagree in your usual condescending way, you have again failed to comprehend what was actually said. In fact, you injected what you wanted so as to enable you to go on a rant. First of all, why shouldn't he play his regular position players? They have a day off. Playing 1B or CF or SS is not the same as pitching. The guys don't need three or four days of rest. Second, if you start a player, why should you only play them a half game? What's the point in that? Would those extra few innings of rest really have caused their bumps and bruises heal more quickly? In fact, forget about obligation all together. Sure, I bet Selig will have an issue with it due to the integrity of the game. But what about his own team? Do you really want to end on a note like that? Blowing a 7 run lead and losing in an extra inning walk off? Do you have ANY CLUE WHATSOEVER about the mental aspect of sports?!?!?! If you don't think there is at least a chance that the way that last game ended could carry over, mentally, to the playoffs, you really don't have a clue. That is why a team should always play to win. Consistency in one's mental approach is crucial. I think Girardi is a great manager and he was my first choice to replace Torre. But his approach in this last game was foolish.
I don't think last night's loss will have any effect on NY in the postseason. But Girardi proved himself to be a hypocrite. All week long he talked about trying to win these games without overtaxing his pitching staff or key regulars but then he goes out and sets a ML record for number of pitchers used. He managed last night's game much differently than any other game of the last week. Why?
Girardi said on Tuesday that he wasn't going to use any of his pitching regulars.
DONT.
BLOW LEADS.
IN BALTIMORE.
I have nothing but respect for the Rays. They showed a level of fortitude that the Sox really never could muster all year. And while one can criticize how Girardi managed the game, the reality is that even on bad pitches, the Rays didn’t miss them. Even in a home run derby guys usually make outs more than hit HRs, and to do it in game conditions even on a meatball with 2 outs and the season on the line is nothing but admirable. Nor did the Rays stop playing defense when down 7 runs, and held the line, which gave them a chance. I don’t really know if the Sox could have done the same this year in that same situation.
As a Red Sox fan, you have to be used to a certain level of drama, which seems like over the long-haul it goes both ways. They are dramatic in how they win and dramatic in how they lose, and that’s just the way it is. It’s seriously disappointing they couldn’t do better. Even with the injuries, 90 wins is simply not enough for the team they put on the field. But that’s baseball, and there’s always next year.
I tend not to believe in too many baseball superstitions – a few here and there – but it really does seem like baseball is more susceptible to amazing stuff than other sports. We’ll see, but helping the Rays punch their ticket is something that really might come back at the Yankees.
Talk about rolling over and playing dead, Sinkhole...