David Benedict is a coward | Page 3 | The Boneyard

David Benedict is a coward

Status
Not open for further replies.
Pudge said:
Do not take Edsall going into next year as a Benedict white flag. DB will be further into the fb program ... and the word is the edge is sharp.
Expand ...

Your lips to G-d’s ears.
 
06029 said:
There can be no one worse than this


And don’t forget how poorly he recruited. The team still lacks depth because of him.
Expand ...


I know Diaco's recruiting has been discussed endlessly in numerous threads on this board, but I'm still puzzled as to why he was not able to get better recruits than he did. He was young, energetic, enthusiastic about the program and charismatic in his own Diacoesque way, all traits that recruits like in a coach. By all accounts the players liked playing for him, and played hard, at least up until the disaster in Annapolis. He seemed to be turning the program around in his second season. Yet the recruiting was woefully deficient.

Why so bad? Was it primarily the fault of assistant coaches who didn't perform on the recruiting trail? Did he just not go after enough FBS caliber players? Was it a misguided recruiting philosophy that favored kids with "big frames" but not necessarily speed, agility and quickness? Lack of well-developed connections with high school coaches? All of the above? Something else? Just hard for me to fathom how he missed so badly, given the things that he did have going for himself.
 
Move to the Big East is the right move.
Football independence can work with the right coach and schedule.

That being said, Randy Edsall 2.0 was absolutely one of the worst hires. There is a reason why he was available for cheap the second time around. He might win with Alabama players where he has a huge athletic advantage over his opponents. He won't win here. He plays to lose, and his offense stinks.

David Benedict needs to fire Edsall now. If not, we need to get rid of David Benedict.
 
.-.
Hogoff said:
I was wait and see on Edsall for next year. Now that all these transfers are leaving, I’m on the fire Edsall bandwagon. The only reason I saw to retain him was to minimize the transfers. These kids, for the most part, that are leaving aren’t even thanking Edsall. I don’t see how it could possibly get worse. I know he’s not getting fired, so I hope I am dead wrong about this. Come on UConn!
Expand ...
have you taken a deep dive to see who these xfers out really are?
 
gampelcrazies said:
Because since DB has come to the program things have gone in the right direction within the Atheltic Department.

He got rid of Diaco.
He got Hurley for the MBB team.
He got the basketball team in the NBE.
He put together a solid Independent schedule.
Donations/season ticket purchases have become more transparent.

The big mess up he's had is the hiring of Edsall. However, most people were happy with the hire at the time.

So if he went out a fired Randy and got a young new coach I can't see how people could really hate the guy. He truly cares about this program and wants to get it back to a high level. 1
Expand ...
Diaco- No Brainer
Hurley- No Brainer and only "big name" at the time who would come into the AAC mess
NBE - had been in the works for some time but he did have a hand in it
Schedule - not only him
Donations/season tickets - mediocre at best

DB is a db and he has to go- he cares zilch about UConn - his eyes are on the SEC ONLY
 
gopher2 said:
Why so bad? Was it primarily the fault of assistant coaches who didn't perform on the recruiting trail? Did he just not go after enough FBS caliber players? Was it a misguided recruiting philosophy that favored kids with "big frames" but not necessarily speed, agility and quickness? Lack of well-developed connections with high school coaches? All of the above? Something else? Just hard for me to fathom how he missed so badly, given the things that he did have going for himself.
Expand ...

I don't follow recruiting as much as some, but i believe he did go after a lot of highly rated guys. Many were guys we had no shot at but the idea was to build relationships with big programs. Some have posted that he favored intangibles way too much over athleticism. Which makes the fact that Edsall doesn't seem to like the character of a lot of his guys more confusing. Besides that, size over speed, and I think that while on paper he's a young charismatic coach, he's so freaking weird that guys didn't fall for it.
 
DB has made some good moves. Once he expended his personal capital on Lashlee and Edsall (and the admin) screwed him, I think he washed his hands of the mess. It’s clear he has no juice to move football forward because the admin simply doesn’t care.
 
Pudge said:
Do not take Edsall going into next year as a Benedict white flag. DB will be further into the fb program ... and the word is the edge is sharp.
Expand ...

the edge is sharp. That’s a good one. Did you see what Incompetent DB said about edsall when asked if he would be fired? Guy has zero clue. Further into the football program - yeah sure.
 
UConnDan97 said:
So you support the players, but you call the 8 players leaving "corrosive"?? And your evidence of that is what exactly? And your evidence of us being stronger next year while losing multiple starters to defection is what exactly?
Expand ...
Depends who is handing him hot dogs on Saturdays.
 
.-.
uconnbill said:
not going to happen.
You cannot change coaches every three years, you can't.

He will get one more year unless he leaves on his own. People have short memories of what was here before. #MoreVitaminD #CrazyPressConferences #RecruitedSlowTallPlayers #ThankGodHeIsGone
Expand ...
You change coaches when you know that it’s time. It’s time! Has nothing to do with what was here before.
 
Nostical said:
We're lucky to have Benedict. And Edsall is not being fired. He's already putting together a stronger group for next year. Disgruntled players (like disgruntled employees) are corrosive. Let them go, and wish them well, but I'm supporting the players we have and those who will be stepping up.
Expand ...

Losing and lack of self-awareness and support by poor bosses and poor coaches lead to disgruntled employees. When the situation becomes unhealthy and or untenable (read hopeless) you come to a tipping point. We have reached that point.
 
I think continuity would do the program well.
If Edsall is staying, I hope the OC and DC are staying too. I think the revolving door on the coaches has had a big impact on lack of development for some players. Someone different evaluating, coaching, guiding and teaching every year has to be tough on players.

In most situations, Edsells lack of performance would be enough to show him the door. All things considered, including the disastrous 6 years prior to HCRE 2.0, the weak assistant packages leading to revolving coaches, new independent status, RE's prior success, yada yada, he's getting another year. I think another coach and another staff rebuild is more certain to remain at 2-10 or even 1-10. DB is betting the odss are more likely RE can finally get some momentum and get to 5-6 wins and maybe a bowl vs another coach.

Not saying I agree, just my belief on what DB is doing.

Ultimately, I think the odds are, next year will see moderate improvement. But this time there won't be any more runway. Edsell has to play for wins next season. No more playing for 'next season'.
 
Nostical said:
We're lucky to have Benedict. And Edsall is not being fired. He's already putting together a stronger group for next year. Disgruntled players (like disgruntled employees) are corrosive. Let them go, and wish them well, but I'm supporting the players we have and those who will be stepping up.
Expand ...
Time for a reality check. He’s putting together a group of FCS caliber players. His recruiting is abysmal! Every year he keeps digging a deeper and deeper hole.
How about disgruntled fans? Are they too corrosive?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,263
Messages
4,560,481
Members
10,452
Latest member
WashingtonH


Top Bottom