Waquoit
Mr. Positive
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2011
- Messages
- 36,402
- Reaction Score
- 101,776
Oriakhi was drafted by the Suns.
Dana O'Neil on UConn post season chances
- Thread starter Matt1010
- Start date
- Status
Oriakhi was drafted by the Suns.
This will be an interesting thread to revisit in April.
That said, both team's success was predicated on the fact that we had the best player on the court. 2011 has the edge in rebounding and sixth man, 2014 has the edge in the number of playmakers outside of pg and depth off of the bench. They're not identical teams but they're fairly comparable.
At the end of the day you have to ask yourself - who are you taking between senior bazz and junior kemba?
Also interesting to think about that if they played one another today, freshman bazz would likely guard senior bazz for long stretches. By default I think senior Bazz would guard Kemba. As much as I like LK defensively (though I think Giffey's defensive prowess, especially this year, has been way underrated because LK came out of nowhere) there's no chance he can stay in front of kemba.
That said, both team's success was predicated on the fact that we had the best player on the court. 2011 has the edge in rebounding and sixth man, 2014 has the edge in the number of playmakers outside of pg and depth off of the bench. They're not identical teams but they're fairly comparable.
At the end of the day you have to ask yourself - who are you taking between senior bazz and junior kemba?
Also interesting to think about that if they played one another today, freshman bazz would likely guard senior bazz for long stretches. By default I think senior Bazz would guard Kemba. As much as I like LK defensively (though I think Giffey's defensive prowess, especially this year, has been way underrated because LK came out of nowhere) there's no chance he can stay in front of kemba.
I think the 2014 team is better and deeper. Lamb v Kromah is a toss up. Giffey is better now. Daniels is better than Roscoe. Brimah/Nolan are as good or better than Oriakhi. Kemba is better than Bazz but not by a huge margin. The freshman Olander was probably better than the senior Olander, which defies logic. Boatright as a Junior is better than Shabazz as a freshman. Play 10 times, Kemba wills out 6 wins. The only time that 2011 team was unbeatable was in a tournament. They struggled at times in the regular season.
It would be a great game. This 2014 against that same 2011 field in the NCAAT would probably win the championship too. That team was offensively challenged after Kemba, this team isn't.
I think O'Neill is overlooking the supporting cast. I would like our opponents to, but they watch film and they know better.
It would be a great game. This 2014 against that same 2011 field in the NCAAT would probably win the championship too. That team was offensively challenged after Kemba, this team isn't.
I think O'Neill is overlooking the supporting cast. I would like our opponents to, but they watch film and they know better.
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 13,475
- Reaction Score
- 36,040
Brimah and Nolan average a combined 8 and 5. AO averaged 9.6 and 8.7. He is clearly a better player than them. And Jeremy Lamb started getting consistent minutes mid-January. Once that happened, he averaged 13.5 and 4.5. So, I'm just going to say that Lamb vs. Kromah is not a toss up.
And that they were not offensively challenged--at least not any moreso than this team. I mean, according to Pomeroy, that was the 18th most efficient offense through the course of the season in 2011. This years edition, thus far, is only the 31st.
I'm also not sure this team has the defense to stop Kawli Leonard or Derrick Williams. That was Roscoe. His interior defense was unreal.
Waquoit
Mr. Positive
- Joined
- Aug 24, 2011
- Messages
- 36,402
- Reaction Score
- 101,776
Not sure which sentence is less accurate.
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 13,475
- Reaction Score
- 36,040
People are really underrating that 2011 team. That team was 9-8 against the RPI Top 50 going into the BET. They had 4 Top 25 RPI wins then (ended with 11--Pitt, Syracuse, Georgetown, Louisville, San Diego St., Arizona, UK to end the year), and all their losses, except to Marquette in OT (a sweet 16 team) were to RPI Top 25 teams.
This years team is 3-4 vs. the RPI top 50. If they win out, and beat Cincy and Louisville in the AAC tournament, they would end up with 5 Top 50 RPI wins, and 3 Top 25 (maybe 5, if Louisville climbs back up).
.-.
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 927
- Reaction Score
- 400
Dana O'Neil is a bitter woman who unraveled when her beloved Penn State could no longer were white. Somehow this was channeled into her deranged mind against UConn whom she believed got away with murder and a National Championship in 2011. She's a sick person who really needs a good therapist.
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2014
- Messages
- 570
- Reaction Score
- 1,668
So her saying UConn would win the rest of their regular season games and the AAC tourny is being "against UConn?" The point we are arguing is whether this years team is as deep as the 2011 team. I agree with her that it's not. Others believe it is deeper. I don't think her view is so crazy it makes her "against UConn." I wouldn't call her "deranged" and don't think she has anything against UConn.
Nolan/Brimah combine for 8.1 points, and 5.3 rebounds. Oriakhi got 1.6 blocks per game, Nolan and Brimah combine for 3.1. The PPG is close. He's a better rebounder, Brimah a far better shot blocker. The two combine for the same minutes he played. You can argue on his behalf, he isn't "clearly" a better player. He was a better rebounder, but not a better defender, and the scoring is very close.
Numbers don't tell the whole story. But what I was saying is that head to head it's a toss up for Kromah/Lamb. If there's someone on our team who could keep Lamb to 8-10 it's Kromah. He has the size and ability to play Lamb. Lamb was the number two option because he had to be. Kromah is the number 3 or 4 option because we have Bazz, Daniels, and Boatright who can all create their own shot. Kromah can too, and has shown the ability to take over when needed. Kromah could easily average 13 if Daniels and Boatright didn't deserve the shots they get. You can't just look at a stat sheet and make a decision. All things are not equal, they aren't playing on the same team against the same teams.
Again, numbers don't tell the whole story, but this year's team averages more points per game than 2011.
This year's top 6 scorers are
18, 13.2, 12.4, 7.9 and 7.4, and 5.5
2011
23.5, 11.1, 9.6, 7.8, 6.3 and 5.6
The scoring is more balanced this year. I don't care about the offensive efficiency stat, I'm guessing that's just how good Kemba was. We have more options on offense this year than 2011, that's obvious.
Stunning analysis, thank you for your contribution. I suppose you missed where I said the 2011 team would win 6 out of 10 because of Kemba. Admittedly it was worded poorly, I meant to say the 2014 team has more options offensively and is more balanced. "Better"? Probably not, but this team could win that 2011 tournament, it was a relatively weak field.
Last edited:
That "team" was incredible because Kemba was incredible. I'm not devaluing that entire team, I'm putting most of the success for that team on Kemba. You can point to the team achievements, but you can't do so without acknowledging Kemba was the best player in the country. As good as Shabazz is, it won't be a travesty if he doesn't win POY (unless he does something to mimic what Kemba did). Kemba's numbers went down in the tourney because teams were really focusing on him, but despite that he still averaged 5+ more points per game than Bazz. Cause he had to, not cause Bazz couldn't drop 23 a game.
Take away the best player from 2011 and the best player from 2014 and who wins the game? I think 2014 does, and while a reasonable person can disagree, I don't think it's a crazy opinion. The numbers are not overwhelmingly onesided.
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2011
- Messages
- 56,136
- Reaction Score
- 213,047
I completely agree, you take the best player off of 2011 and the best player off of 2014 and '14 wins, the team this year just has more shot makers. Without Kemba on the floor the 2011 team was completely lost on offense, don't think I've ever seen a College player who was that important to his team.
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 13,475
- Reaction Score
- 36,040
Even if that statement were true (and I tend to agree with you), it's irrelevant. 2011 was the better team largely because teams don't get to eliminate the opposing teams best player.
On to your earlier point about there being more balance. Part of that is that this has played a much easier schedule. They average 76 ppg, compared to 72 in 2011. But, remember that despite the numbers looking better this year, that team played an absurdly difficult schedule. They played 12 RPI Top 25 games, and 17 RPI top 50 games...all before the BET. Those PPGs and efficiency numbers come when you add 7 more RPI Top 25 teams, and 1 more RPI top 50. This team has played 2 and 7 respectively. How do those numbers look going against a tougher schedule? I don't know, but according to Pomeroy, the 2011 team was more efficient relative to teams in 2011 than 2014 is to its peers.
.-.
I think this is why you're missing my point. (or disagreeing with it)
Dana O'Neill is basically saying we can't make a deep run unless Shabazz turns into Kemba, and I don't agree with that. We need him to be very good, we don't need him to be the best player in the country every night because we have more options.
If you tend to agree with that sentiment, then you also disagree with O'Neill, you agree with me, and the confusion is because I did a terrible job of explaining it.
2014 isn't "better" than 2011, but I believe they are deeper, and the points distribution backs that up.
- Joined
- Aug 27, 2011
- Messages
- 1,536
- Reaction Score
- 1,060
One thing you really need to look at when discussing Lamb, and what separates him from Kromah (by a fairly large margin at this point) was how amazing he was in really, really big moments.
I had to go back and check the play by play for reference, but they supported my memory of him. Take a look at what he did in all of these elimination games:
Big East Semifinal vs Syracuse- Two minutes to go and the game tied at 70, he hits a jumper to make it 72-70. After Joseph hits 1 of 2 free throws to make it 72-71, Lamb makes another jumper with 26 seconds left to push it to 74-71. Kemba seals it at the line after Jardine misses a 3.
Big East Final vs Louisville- Lamb's layup with 30 seconds to go puts Uconn ahead for good after UL took the lead.
Sweet 16 vs SDSU- You can watch it here
Elite 8 vs Arizona- Uconn was leading the entire 2nd half and after they pushed it to 9, Arizona went on a 14-2 run to take a 3 point lead, seemingly taking control of the game with about 6 minutes to go and had the crowd behind them. Lamb then silences the crowd with two gorgeous baseline jumpers for Uconn to regain the lead, of which they never (phew) gave up again.
He also had some huge plays against Butler in the NC game.
It's not really fair to Kromah to compare him to Lamb yet, since the season is still ongoing and he's never had the opportunities that Lamb did, but that's the whole thing with 'greatness.' Lamb was in those situations and he was great in them.
We know what Shabazz can do now, but the 2011 team had two guys who were going to make clutch shots when 'winning time' arrived.
I've tried to clarify that comment, you can read my other posts, but I'm not going to rehash them. I wasn't knocking Lamb, without his improvement we wouldn't have won the championship.
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2014
- Messages
- 1,090
- Reaction Score
- 6,183
This team has a chip on their shoulder, I KNOW boat and the gang will show up in this tournament. I just know it.
- Status