why does everyone have a hard on for redshirting?....I realize that HCRE always did, but the player doesn't always require it
if you think they have the ability why not let them try and step it to the occasion instead of making them ride the bench for a year?
There are only 2 reasons to NOT redshirt a player, IMO: 1.) The player has true NFL potential, and will likely leave early as a result, or 2.) You promised him while recruiting.
Football is such a physical sport that the redshirt year really does help. But the thing that everyone sometimes forgets is that a redshirt almost forces a kid NOT to transfer. Mike Nebrich could transfer this year to UVA (if UVA wants him, of course), redshirt next year, and still have 3 years of eligibility remaining - exactly the same amount he has at UConn. Had he redshirted this year, though, he'd have to decide - 4 years at UConn vs. 3 years at UVA.
I am not crazy about the concept of doing something to essentially force kids to lose options, but you can't deny that its a potentially huge benefit.