CFP Final 4 | Page 4 | The Boneyard

CFP Final 4

Two things...

1...Matching FSU to maybe the best team (Georgia) is one way to prove the Committee right when the Dawgs roll.

2...Oregon playing Liberty has to sting those Duck fans. Even Mizzou and Ole Miss got P5 opponents in the NY6.
 
Two things...

1...Matching FSU to maybe the best team (Georgia) is one way to prove the Committee right when the Dawgs roll.

2...Oregon playing Liberty has to sting those Duck fans. Even Mizzou and Ole Miss got P5 opponents in the NY6.

I dunno, I think the opportunity to stomp the wackadoodles from Lynchburg would have some appeal.
 
FSU and Alabama should have a one game playoff for the final spot. Refuse to play and the other team gets the spot. Be great for ratings. And fair.
 
UGA and FSU should both decline the invite. Bowers and others shouldn’t play an exhibition. Decline this one and wait for next season.
In my humble opinion, quitting should never be an option. I understand that certain individuals will choose not to play to protect their health before the NFL Draft, but an institution with a stated mission of higher education should never choose this path.
 
FSU should not play in that game
I agree. Instead they should all pile into the

1701636781013.jpeg
 
.-.
.-.
If I happened to be drinking a beer while reading the FSU coach bleating, "What happened today goes against everything that is true and right about college football"; the whole thing would have came out my nose.

New NIL from FSU:

Free crab legs … and a BMW for every player!
 
Don't think of it as Pac 12, Big 12, SEC, Big 10. think of it for what its truly meant to be ...big10 vs SEC. Get use to it even with 12 teams
Based on today's crime. Don't be surprised to see a 12 team playoff with 8 SEC teams (even if they have to pick a 5 win team to do it. lol
 
FSU won't leave the ACC just because they got left out today. With the playoff expanding, they will have a much easier path making the playoff in the ACC than in the SEC or Big 10. They are also going to get destroyed by Georgia so all this crying will become a distant memory.
 
Imagine rooting for an undefeated conference champion that does NOT make the CFP. Simply could not be me. The AAC was a better league than the ACC.
Pleased Season 3 GIF by Martin
Dawg, other than Oklahoma and Texas, the highest rated B12 team was ok state at 20. Without the top 2 dogs to prop you up, that's going to be the B12 new reality
 
.-.
No one else has beaten Clemson at Clemson in six years.

LSU, on the road, with their O'Brien Award winning QB, is tough.

FSU played more P5 bowl eligible teams than those picked.

But....I have really no problems with the picks being maybe the best four if the Committee believes that...a lot of talk was about missing a star QB...I can see that.

And...I think that TCU getting massacred last year might have played in.
O.K., I know you’re a reasonable, calm guy but how can you not be outraged by this. I dislike FSU but I’m outraged. In my mind, it’s very simple. The Committee opted for the 4 teams that Vegas would make the heaviest betting favorites rather than the four teams that accomplished the most in the regular season. That’s outrageous, because to take it to an absurd extreme what would have stopped them from taking a team that’s 8-4, with the 4 losses early without a few star players and then undefeated dominating performances when they come back healthy? Because if that’s what you’re doing, the entire regular season is nothing more than an exhibition season to convince a committee you are, at the end, really good. Who wants that? Who wants to pay for tickets and give up days to watch games that don’t actually count for anything? Why does the NFL, clearly the US’s most popular sport, bother with standings based on wins and losses instead of just deciding who is “best” at the end of the regular season?

What a sham. You should be working with other alum thinking about how to seek an injunction or move to a P-2 conference next year.
 
This isn't UCF though. FSU won a P5 league undefeated.
True, but I don’t care about FSU & the ACC. I get they think they’re entitled because they’re P5 but it’s really the same criteria at play. Now suddenly FSU thinks we should ignore conferences & focus only their record. No - their schedule & conference clearly isn’t as good as Alabama’s.
 
FSU won't leave the ACC just because they got left out today. With the playoff expanding, they will have a much easier path making the playoff in the ACC than in the SEC or Big 10. They are also going to get destroyed by Georgia so all this crying will become a distant memory.
I am not so sure about that. The statement today is that the ACC is not part of the P2. The last time FSU went undefeated it won the whole nut in 2013. The time before that, 1999. This year, undefeated and it doesn't even get an invite. SEC and B1G programs will now get a loss or 2 cushion over the ACC when it comes time for selections and I really don't see how long FSU or Clemson will tolerate this new pecking order.
 
I am not so sure about that. The statement today is that the ACC is not part of the P2. The last time FSU went undefeated it won the whole nut in 2013. The time before that, 1999. This year, undefeated and it doesn't even get an invite. SEC and B1G programs will now get a loss or 2 cushion over the ACC when it comes time for selections and I really don't see how long FSU or Clemson will tolerate this new pecking order.
There will be no Revolution because they would make the 12 team format that starts next year
 
Not sure if anyone else has already said this but I believe if Georgia wins then FSU doesn't get screwed. Why? Because the golden goose, aka as the SEC, would be in as the #1 seed and it would've come down to FSU and Texas for the #4:spot.
The committee wouldn't be as hellbent about getting Texas in as getting the SEC in so would have likely picked FSU as #4 in that scenario.
With Bama winning, the only way they knew they could justify getting the SEC in was putting Texas and Bama both in because Texas had the head-to-head tiebreaker on Bama so they more or less had to put them in as package deal so to speak.
If Georgia won, your top 4 would have been Georgia, Michign Wasington, and FSU. The committee was willing to deal with the backlash of leaving unbeaten FSU out in order to make sure they put the SEC in but if the were already in they wouldn't have done the same to get Texas in.
 
Last edited:
.-.
FSU got screwed.
I believe if Georgia wins then FSU doesn't get screwed.
You’re probably right but FSU got robbed. What if any of the other QB’s broke their leg yesterday—Penix? JJ McCarthy? Would that have disqualified their teams? FSU’s defense was awesome and teams often rally to play better than expected. It was a convenient excuse to appease the SEC.
 
I am not so sure about that. The statement today is that the ACC is not part of the P2. The last time FSU went undefeated it won the whole nut in 2013. The time before that, 1999. This year, undefeated and it doesn't even get an invite. SEC and B1G programs will now get a loss or 2 cushion over the ACC when it comes time for selections and I really don't see how long FSU or Clemson will tolerate this new pecking order.
But this whole thing would be moot in a 12 team playoff. If FSU or Clemson go 13-0 or 12-1 and win the ACC they will be one of the top 4 seeds and get bye every year.
 
If Florida State wins its bowl game, will there be controversy over who is the national champion.
No controversy. If FSU, Washington or Michigan win out. They will be National Champs. Texas and Alabama each lost a game so they are out.
 
Massey had Alabama SOS #2 and FSU #64. Liberty was at #132 (that had to be some weak schedule as UConn's was #112). That's almost the same difference Liberty to FSU as FSU is to Alabama, that's a big difference in difficulty of schedule. I can see going with Alabama with their one loss being to a CFP team and a victory over one of top 6 CFP teams.
 
.-.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,215
Messages
4,557,559
Members
10,442
Latest member
StatsMan


Top Bottom