CFP Final 4 | Page 2 | The Boneyard

CFP Final 4

It is a legitimate question though. If FSU plays Georgia and wins, and Texas or Alabama wins the title?
 
CTBasketball said:
Bring back the BCS.
Expand ...
Which version? They were changing the damn formula every year back then. They always should have made this playoff an 8 team affair. 5 P5 conference champions and 3 wild cards. It made too much sense, and just maybe would have slowed down all this realignment.
 
This is bizarre because the only argument they are using against FSU is that their QB got hurt. If anything, the fact they finished undefeated shows even more reason they deserve a shot.

Would the selection committee in bball knock a team down a seed line or two because they lost their star in their Conference Tournament? I don't think so. When did an injury, that didn't effect a teams final record, impact their seeding in a post season?!?
 
.-.
UCFBfan said:
This is bizarre because the only argument they are using against FSU is that their QB got hurt. If anything, the fact they finished undefeated shows even more reason they deserve a shot.

Would the selection committee in bball knock a team down a seed.line or two because they lost their star in their Conference Tournament? I don't think so. When did an injury, that didn't effect a teams final record, impact their seeding in a spot season?!?
Expand ...

Where u been?
Major injuries are ALWAYS a factor in NCAA seeding.
Has happened to the UConn women a couple of times in fact.
It’s literally in the seeding guidelines.
 
Vowelguy said:
Where u been?
Major injuries are ALWAYS a factor in NCAA seeding.
Has happened to the UConn women a couple of times in fact.
It’s literally in the seeding guidelines.
Expand ...
Must have missed it
 
Travesty that an undefeated P-5 team does not get in the CFP. But, this is the narrative of college football today - it's all about the TV networks and the $$$.
 
Imagine rooting for an undefeated conference champion that does NOT make the CFP. Simply could not be me. The AAC was a better league than the ACC.
Pleased Season 3 GIF by Martin
 
kobe said:
Imagine rooting for an undefeated conference champion that does NOT make the CFP. Simply could not be me. The AAC was a better league than the ACC.
Pleased Season 3 GIF by Martin
Expand ...
LOL.
 
.-.
UCFBfan said:
This is bizarre because the only argument they are using against FSU is that their QB got hurt. If anything, the fact they finished undefeated shows even more reason they deserve a shot.

Would the selection committee in bball knock a team down a seed line or two because they lost their star in their Conference Tournament? I don't think so. When did an injury, that didn't effect a teams final record, impact their seeding in a post season?!?
Expand ...
There may be more examples that I can't remember, but didn't Cincinnati get knocked off of the one seed line when Kenyon martin broke his leg? A long time ago, but the only one I can remember.
 
UCFBfan said:
This is bizarre because the only argument they are using against FSU is that their QB got hurt. If anything, the fact they finished undefeated shows even more reason they deserve a shot.

Would the selection committee in bball knock a team down a seed line or two because they lost their star in their Conference Tournament? I don't think so. When did an injury, that didn't effect a teams final record, impact their seeding in a post season?!?
Expand ...
Uhhh… yes, they would and have.
 
.-.
UCFBfan said:
This is bizarre because the only argument they are using against FSU is that their QB got hurt. If anything, the fact they finished undefeated shows even more reason they deserve a shot.

Would the selection committee in bball knock a team down a seed line or two because they lost their star in their Conference Tournament? I don't think so. When did an injury, that didn't effect a teams final record, impact their seeding in a post season?!?
Expand ...
It's all a bunch of BS. If FSU won 42-31 yesterday, they get in. People want to watch offense and that wasn't FSU.
 
shizzle787 said:
Harbaugh basically just said FSU got screwed.
Expand ...
I think he knows that FSU was a far better matchup for them. FSU can rush the passer and cover people, but you can move them off the ball. Michigan would be able to just grind them down, especially since the FSU offense is dead without Travis in there. Neither one of their backups can generate the offense needed to win a game like that.
 
traitor71 said:
I think he knows that FSU was a far better matchup for them. FSU can rush the passer and cover people, but you can move them off the ball. Michigan would be able to just grind them down, especially since the FSU offense is dead without Travis in there. Neither one of their backups can generate the offense needed to win a game like that.
Expand ...
If the committee had gotten it right, FSU would have been #3. They would have played Texas.
 
Oh looking like Ga vs FSU.
If GA is pissed about losing and everyone plays, FSU dreams will end in a blood bath.
Like 55-10.

Only shot is if Dawgs are uninterested and lots of guys opt out for the draft.
 
.-.
I had this one figured....ESPN has been banging their narrative. It was predictable.

And the fact that FSU, with a 3rd string True Freshman QB, still throttled down Louisville (who scored 30 or more in 8 games) to 6 points becomes a negative.

And no one has talked about FSU's 4 year experienced QB Rodemaker who will be back from concussion protocol.

Yep...precursor...Big Two gonna roll.
 
No one else has beaten Clemson at Clemson in six years.

LSU, on the road, with their O'Brien Award winning QB, is tough.

FSU played more P5 bowl eligible teams than those picked.

But....I have really no problems with the picks being maybe the best four if the Committee believes that...a lot of talk was about missing a star QB...I can see that.

And...I think that TCU getting massacred last year might have played in.
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,219
Messages
4,557,706
Members
10,442
Latest member
StatsMan


Top Bottom