Huh. Because I thought there was nothing on this earth that could make Giffey into remotely the kind of player Redick was in college. He was pretty good, if you remember. Or is this some anti-Duke thing? I don't like them either, but this is one of the dumber conversations to have gone on around here.
Just a little more confidence and Giffey would be a first-team all-American. Sure.
My initial snarky response saying he was "taller, stronger and played better D" was both correct and tongue in cheek. So relax. Redick was scoring 40 points a game in HS. He has a much better handle, and can create better with the ball than Neils. He was almost certainly a better straight up shooter too and had amazing range at Duke. His D was pretty weak though, and improved a bunch in the NBA.
But I think Giffey is absolutely a 15-18 a game guy, with 5-6 boards in the right system and with the right confidence. First team AA, no. Second team all AAC, maybe. He will go back to Germany, latch on with a pro team, and be a very, very good pro in Europe.