Best Ice Cream in Connecticut | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Best Ice Cream in Connecticut

Dzen's Garden in Ellington has a unique take by only selling soft serve. They have like 30 flavors.
 
Waquoit said:
Bad service is the Friendly's way. It's built into their business plan.
Expand ...

Yep pretty much every time I go there, I had to wait once 45 minutes for an ice cream then I decided to leave.
 
Buttonwood Farm in Griswold. End of debate. If you haven't been, go.

Rich Farm, Sweet Claude's, The UConn Dairy bar are in the next tier.

Shady Glen and Wentworth's below that. Anyone who says that Wentworth's is better than Sweet Claude's is lying.
 
Excalibur said:
Buttonwood Farm in Griswold. End of debate. If you haven't been, go.

Rich Farm, Sweet Claude's, The UConn Dairy bar are in the next tier.

Shady Glen and Wentworth's below that. Anyone who says that Wentworth's is better than Sweet Claude's is lying.
Expand ...
Guess I'm a liar, but Wentworth's is my preference.
 
.-.
UConn Dairy Bar is the best, unless it has somehow changed since the last time I ate there (about ten years ago.) UDB is the ONLY ice cream that doesn't have air pumped into it to expand the volume. UDB is hand packed.
In case you don't believe me, watch this:

 
I like Wentworth's as well. Haven't been to some of the places I used to go as a kid in ages - AC Peterson's in West Hartford was the main one, I also remember stopping at Salem valley farms on the way to Rhode Island. I remember them being good but I was a kid so I don't know if I'd still find them to be special as an adult.
 
I can almost fall out of bed into Wentworth's. Takes all of my will power to drive past. Haven't been to the Dairy Bar in years, but great stuff. Claude's once (a pain to take a left out of). There's a pretty good place on RT 69 in Prospect called Big Dipper. I think Ashley's is a cut below. But it's hard to get terrible ice-cream.
 
CL82 said:
I haven't had one in decades but they were great, far to superior to the "Dilly bar". If not the Buster Bar, then I'd go with the Mister Misty.
Expand ...
The Mister Misty was what I grew up on. Loved that Lemon/Lime.
 
Les's east side of Meriden was always very good.......not sure about these days!!
 
.-.
Dove said:
The Mister Misty was what I grew up on. Loved that Lemon/Lime.
Expand ...
I think they call them artic rush now, a far weaker product. Have to go with Rita's now.
 
CTBasketball said:
I've spent a lot of time eating ice cream in Connecticut. My favorites are as follows:

1. Rich Farm - Oxford
2. Claude's - Cheshire
3. Wentworth's (literally right down the road from Claude's) - Hamden

Rich Farm is light-years above the rest. Without a doubt.
Expand ...

I love Sweet Claude's it's my favorite. I went to Wentworth's and couldn't make it past all the neon artificial coloring. Mint chocolate chip ice cream should not look like a cycling jersey or a GoDaddy race car.
 
HuskyFan16 said:
Dzen's Garden in Ellington has a unique take by only selling soft serve. They have like 30 flavors.
Expand ...
Place is great. Burke Ridge Farm down the road in South Windsor is really good too. Also, both had really cute girls when I was in high school.
 
The best ice cream I've ever had was in Ann Arbor MI called Kilwins. They were never in the East. Now there is one in Newport RI and Portsmouth NH. If you go, try the toasted coconut and then try and tell me that's not the best ever.
 
Nostical said:
The best ice cream I've ever had was in Ann Arbor MI called Kilwins. They were never in the East. Now there is one in Newport RI and Portsmouth NH. If you go, try the toasted coconut and then try and tell me that's not the best ever.
Expand ...
I'n an ice cream and pizza snob.
I just returned from Ct
Three Pepe's visit with a shared cannoli from libby's
One visit to Rich's farm
Mocha almond fudge I'm still thinking of
Never heard of Kilwins in AZ but we certainly could use a good store out here. We will drive to Tucson if the ice creams that good.
Cold-Stone hardly qualifies as Ice Cream
I will look around for them.
Any favorite flavors?


Sent from my Kindle Fire using Tapatalk 2
 
CL82 said:
I haven't had one in decades but they were great, far to superior to the "Dilly bar". If not the Buster Bar, then I'd go with the Mister Misty.
Expand ...
Mister Misty=instant brain freeze
 
.-.
Excalibur said:
Buttonwood Farm in Griswold. End of debate. If you haven't been, go.

Rich Farm, Sweet Claude's, The UConn Dairy bar are in the next tier.

Shady Glen and Wentworth's below that. Anyone who says that Wentworth's is better than Sweet Claude's is lying.
Expand ...
Finally a vote for something east of the river.

Buttonwood Farms is excellent-Check out the Sunflower display in June ( I guess any day now)
Salem Valley Farms- 5 minutes from my house so maybe it tastes better without a long drive, they have butter crunch which I don't see much anymore
Uconn Dairy Bar
 
When we lived in Norwich, we would drive by Buttonwood on our way to Rhode Island and Fall River to visit my wife's family, and every time we drove by we would see 30-50 people waiting in line for ice cream. We thought "it can't be that good, it must be that there's just nothing else around". We finally decided to stop on an afternoon in March right after they opened since the line wasn't quite as long as usual. We were wrong. It is that good.
 
From the ages of 3-14 I'd have voted for this and it wouldn't have been close:

bomb+pops.jpg


Catch me on a hot day now and this is still in my Top 3.
 
Dove said:
The Mister Misty was what I grew up on. Loved that Lemon/Lime.
Expand ...
I actually went to Dq yesterday and ordered this and they gave me a confused look,they are called arctic breeze now!
 
AZHuskiePop said:
I'n an ice cream and pizza snob.
I just returned from Ct
Three Pepe's visit with a shared cannoli from libby's
One visit to Rich's farm
Mocha almond fudge I'm still thinking of
Never heard of Kilwins in AZ but we certainly could use a good store out here. We will drive to Tucson if the ice creams that good.
Cold-Stone hardly qualifies as Ice Cream
I will look around for them.
Any favorite flavors?
Expand ...

Is that a Haiku?
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,632
Messages
4,587,005
Members
10,497
Latest member
Orlando Fos


Top Bottom