Best Golf Courses Played | Page 3 | The Boneyard

Best Golf Courses Played

Joined
Jan 29, 2021
Messages
885
Reaction Score
3,105
I was planning to make a snarky comment…what no one’s played Pine Valley…and then this post. Lol. Was it as fabulous as it’s reported? I’d just like to see it.
Yes, Pine Valley is a bear, unseen pot bunkers everywhere along with barren pines, much like Pinehurst. Speaking of #2, I'd take the Fazzio #6 as much fairer, away from the main club with great terrain. A friend, who formerly worked at the Courant, acquired two condos at Pinehurst with money he had received in a buyout. We were able to play several of these fine courses including nearby Foxfire.
Also love Taconic, the home course of Williams College in Williamstown, MA. I played some high school golf on that course. It has beautiful terrain. Nickolus won the US Amateur there which I witnessed back in the 50's.
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
4,438
Reaction Score
7,851
Agree played it quite a few times it’s nothing great at all, history is all it has Idaho!
The neighbors would rather it turn into a nature reserve. Heard they are taking down a lot of trees aligning with the original design intent, stretching it out... Hope you get to play it after the restoration takes hold and let people know what you think.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
33,749
Reaction Score
97,784
Yes, Pine Valley is a bear, unseen pot bunkers everywhere along with barren pines, much like Pinehurst. Speaking of #2, I'd take the Fazzio #6 as much fairer, away from the main club with great terrain. A friend, who formerly worked at the Courant, acquired two condos at Pinehurst with money he had received in a buyout. We were able to play several of these fine courses including nearby Foxfire.
Also love Taconic, the home course of Williams College in Williamstown, MA. I played some high school golf on that course. It has beautiful terrain. Nickolus won the US Amateur there which I witnessed back in the 50's.

Taconic good call. Only played it once and left it off my list in error. It’s a wonderful track I’d suggest anyone who has a chance to play there make sure to get it done.
 
Joined
Dec 25, 2022
Messages
79
Reaction Score
403
Yes, Pine Valley is a bear, unseen pot bunkers everywhere along with barren pines, much like Pinehurst. Speaking of #2, I'd take the Fazzio #6 as much fairer, away from the main club with great terrain. A friend, who formerly worked at the Courant, acquired two condos at Pinehurst with money he had received in a buyout. We were able to play several of these fine courses including nearby Foxfire.
Also love Taconic, the home course of Williams College in Williamstown, MA. I played some high school golf on that course. It has beautiful terrain. Nickolus won the US Amateur there which I witnessed back in the 50's.
Pinehurst No. 6 is a lot of fun but a bit remote from the main club so not as well known. My in-laws used to live in the house behind the 14th green but thankfully it was across the street so no airmailed shots hit the house lol.
 
Joined
Oct 7, 2011
Messages
5,158
Reaction Score
18,731
Pine Valley
Shinnecock
National Golf Links
Atlantic
Maidstone
Bethpage Black
Winged Foot
Quaker Ridge
Stanwich
Yale
Fisher Island
Wannemoisett
Myopia
Country Club
Wollaston
Belmont
Winchester
Baltusrol
Ridgewood
Essex
Ocean Course at Kiawah
Pinehurst #2
Pebble Beach
Pasatiempo
Olympic
California Golf Club
Sawgrass
Whistling Straits
New Seabury
Knickerbocker
Piping Rock
Deepdale
Garden City Men’s Club
Dallas National
Old Memorial
Copperhead
East Lake
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2016
Messages
286
Reaction Score
1,342
My top 10 (Best) are:

Royal County Down
Pine Valley
Cypress Point
Shinnecock
Merion
Augusta
National
Muirfield
Old Course
Oakmont

My top 10 (Faviorite) are:

National
Merion
Cypress Point
Fishers
Portmarnock
Old Sandwich
Somerset Hills
Cal Club
Old Course
Sankaty Head
Augusta
 

storrsroars

Exiled in Pittsburgh
Joined
Mar 23, 2012
Messages
20,638
Reaction Score
43,229
My top 10 (Best) are:

Royal County Down
Pine Valley
Cypress Point
Shinnecock
Merion
Augusta
National
Muirfield
Old Course
Oakmont

My top 10 (Faviorite) are:

National
Merion
Cypress Point
Fishers
Portmarnock
Old Sandwich
Somerset Hills
Cal Club
Old Course
Sankaty Head
Augusta
Pine Valley
Shinnecock
National Golf Links
Atlantic
Maidstone
Bethpage Black
Winged Foot
Quaker Ridge
Stanwich
Yale
Fisher Island
Wannemoisett
Myopia
Country Club
Wollaston
Belmont
Winchester
Baltusrol
Ridgewood
Essex
Ocean Course at Kiawah
Pinehurst #2
Pebble Beach
Pasatiempo
Olympic
California Golf Club
Sawgrass
Whistling Straits
New Seabury
Knickerbocker
Piping Rock
Deepdale
Garden City Men’s Club
Dallas National
Old Memorial
Copperhead
East Lake
Well, now we know who here can afford a mil or two in NIL!
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
35,835
Reaction Score
32,825
Taconic good call. Only played it once and left it off my list in error. It’s a wonderful track I’d suggest anyone who has a chance to play there make sure to get it done.
Played it last year on a beautiful late October day around 70*. Glad I didn’t walk it.
 
Joined
Sep 7, 2012
Messages
215
Reaction Score
891
Played all of these.

Old Head visually is my #1 but wasn’t the most challenging test.

Ballybunion was amazing. That first tee ball you’re hoping you don’t cut/slice one into the cemetery.
Yup, all I wanted was to make sure that I wasn’t in there. Ended up getting a birdie on that hole.

Totally agree with Old Head, but it’s just quite a feeling being on that property and making that walk.

Ballybunion was my favorite course that I’ve played in Ireland, I’m excited to go back at some point, but my Scotland trip starts today.
 
Joined
Mar 15, 2024
Messages
34
Reaction Score
148
A question for any older Ct. natives. The best 9 hole course that I have ever played wasn't really very far from Storrs - Pomfret CC run by the French family. Right now a bird sanctuary. My grandfather was a multiple club champion in the '30s.
 
Joined
Mar 15, 2024
Messages
34
Reaction Score
148
A question for any older Ct. natives. The best 9 hole course that I have ever played wasn't really very far from Storrs - Pomfret CC run by the French family. Right now a bird sanctuary. My grandfather was a multiple club champion in the '30s.
The question was supposed to be if anyone can remember it?
 
Joined
Jul 1, 2013
Messages
1,598
Reaction Score
8,311
Pine Valley
Shinnecock
National Golf Links
Atlantic
Maidstone
Bethpage Black
Winged Foot
Quaker Ridge
Stanwich
Yale
Fisher Island
Wannemoisett
Myopia
Country Club
Wollaston
Belmont
Winchester
Baltusrol
Ridgewood
Essex
Ocean Course at Kiawah
Pinehurst #2
Pebble Beach
Pasatiempo
Olympic
California Golf Club
Sawgrass
Whistling Straits
New Seabury
Knickerbocker
Piping Rock
Deepdale
Garden City Men’s Club
Dallas National
Old Memorial
Copperhead
East Lake
Holy crap
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
517
Reaction Score
1,000
In no particular order….

Valderrama
Sotogrande
Ardglass
Portrush
Portstewart
Balleyliffin
St. Patricks
Old Sandwich
Wampanoag post-restoration
Floridian
River Highlands
Dunes Golf & Beach
Weed 9 at Hilton Head National
 

CTBasketball

Former Owner of the Pizza Thread
Joined
Aug 27, 2012
Messages
9,859
Reaction Score
32,484
Fishers Island? I need new friends. A dream to play there

My best of list, no particular order:
Atlantic
Streamsong Red
Pine Needles
Tobacco Road
Pasatiempo
Bandon Dunes (all)
Riviera
Bel Air
Bethpage Black & Red
Floridian

Caddied at Piping Rock for a summer while in HS. Never played
A drunk guy at my marina plays at Fishers Island. Every Friday, Saturday, and Sunday him and his friends put down a 30 and scoot over there. Sometimes they come back, sometimes they don’t.

Still waiting for my invite I heard it’s an awesome course.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
708
Reaction Score
1,800
I haven’t played anywhere too special.

TPC Craig Ranch where they currently play the Byron Nelson is the only one
 
Joined
Mar 3, 2020
Messages
96
Reaction Score
408
Golden Horseshoe GC
Kingsmill
Country Club of Virginia - Richmond
Fishers Island
Hartford GC
Taconic
Paraparaumu Beach Club - New Zealand
Kinloch Club - New Zealand
Singapore Island Country Club - best clubhouse and food
 

prankster

Twister Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Messages
4,395
Reaction Score
5,549
As I said in the Duke 99 thread I played the Ocean course in Kiawah. Caddy said it is rated the toughest course in the country. Certainly the best course I have played. For the golfers here, which course is your favorite?
Kenney Park a d Quarry Ridge.

But it must be noted that they represent the only two courses I have ever played on. Each time being a BYC tournament.

IIMHO, Quarry Ridge was the nicer of the two.
 

Online statistics

Members online
149
Guests online
1,544
Total visitors
1,693

Forum statistics

Threads
158,724
Messages
4,166,034
Members
10,038
Latest member
jfreeds


.
Top Bottom