Beginning to get annoyed with the Sox

Joined
Aug 31, 2011
Messages
1,186
Likes
406
#1
I know it is just spring training, but come on. They are dead last in the grape fruit league and have lost 7 in a row. There are only 3 teams with worse team ERA's. The guys who were candidates to replace Kimbrel have been absolutely terrible. Alex, you need to wake them up.
 

the Q

BY Misanthrope
Joined
Mar 28, 2017
Messages
3,497
Likes
2,606
#3
Spring training is mostly meaningless.

I would’ve liked sipp and romo for the pen as cheap as they went.
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
16,828
Likes
15,303
#4
I know it is just spring training, but come on. They are dead last in the grape fruit league and have lost 7 in a row. There are only 3 teams with worse team ERA's. The guys who were candidates to replace Kimbrel have been absolutely terrible. Alex, you need to wake them up.
Not this again. Clearly you didn't learn anything last year.
 
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
6,306
Likes
3,847
#7
As a Yankees fan, trying to stay as neutral on this as possible. But, if I was a Sox fan, I would have no worries about the Sox's field, batting order and starting rotation.

Their biggest concern, and this is where they seem to be arrogant/laissez-faire is their closer. Kimbrel's demands are out of alignment with the market right now; but, its a key role and I don't see anyone of their staff who can be a reliable, lights-out closer for the entire season. That was their biggest concern in the playoffs after Kimbrel had a few shaky outings and it almost cost them. Afterall, they can't use Price as a closer on a regular basis.
 

the Q

BY Misanthrope
Joined
Mar 28, 2017
Messages
3,497
Likes
2,606
#8
As a Yankees fan, trying to stay as neutral on this as possible. But, if I was a Sox fan, I would have no worries about the Sox's field, batting order and starting rotation.

Their biggest concern, and this is where they seem to be arrogant/laissez-faire is their closer. Kimbrel's demands are out of alignment with the market right now; but, its a key role and I don't see anyone of their staff who can be a reliable, lights-out closer for the entire season. That was their biggest concern in the playoffs after Kimbrel had a few shaky outings and it almost cost them. Afterall, they can't use Price as a closer on a regular basis.
It’s a long season.

I expect Dombrowski to make a move for some pieces.

My gusss is SF with those power lefties out there.
 
Joined
Aug 31, 2011
Messages
1,186
Likes
406
#11
Declining sure. Doubt he’s completely toast yet
If I were Dombrowski I'd offer Kimbrell a contract for 2 to 3 years with a team option to get out of it after the first year. He does not turn 31 until late May. Unless he has an injury that we are not hearing about, it would be worth the gamble. I think he liked playing for the Sox. Still not sold on Barnes or Brazier and Thornburg looks like he might be done.
 

the Q

BY Misanthrope
Joined
Mar 28, 2017
Messages
3,497
Likes
2,606
#12
If I were Dombrowski I'd offer Kimbrell a contract for 2 to 3 years with a team option to get out of it after the first year. He does not turn 31 until late May. Unless he has an injury that we are not hearing about, it would be worth the gamble. I think he liked playing for the Sox. Still not sold on Barnes or Brazier and Thornburg looks like he might be done.
I agree with all of that.

2 years would be ideal.

They seem to be trying to avoiding the super tax again.

Cherington’s baffling stupidity strikes again with panda taking a ton of worthless space up on their cbt ledger
 

HuskyHawk

Hoping to see something that looks like basketball
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
12,355
Likes
13,003
#13
I agree with all of that.

2 years would be ideal.

They seem to be trying to avoiding the super tax again.

Cherington’s baffling stupidity strikes again with panda taking a ton of worthless space up on their cbt ledger
Agreed, but I doubt he would take it. Closer is the most over-priced and valued position in the game. The Sox know it. The problem is they lost Kelly too. I expect them to swing a trade. They are suddenly flush with young 3B prospects. One will move to 1B eventually, but something has to give. A C will end up being moved as well.
 

the Q

BY Misanthrope
Joined
Mar 28, 2017
Messages
3,497
Likes
2,606
#14
Agreed, but I doubt he would take it. Closer is the most over-priced and valued position in the game. The Sox know it. The problem is they lost Kelly too. I expect them to swing a trade. They are suddenly flush with young 3B prospects. One will move to 1B eventually, but something has to give. A C will end up being moved as well.
Devers is a 1B. Period. Full stop.

He’s awful over there.

Kelly wasn’t that good all year until October. He’s replaceable.

The problem is the 2 really good arms they got have been consistently hurt. (Thornburg and Carson Smith)
 

HuskyHawk

Hoping to see something that looks like basketball
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
12,355
Likes
13,003
#15
Devers is a 1B. Period. Full stop.

He’s awful over there.

Kelly wasn’t that good all year until October. He’s replaceable.

The problem is the 2 really good arms they got have been consistently hurt. (Thornburg and Carson Smith)
He’s just a kid. Younger than the guys behind him who are making noise. He’s got athleticism and can learn the position. But one of those 3 guys is a trade asset.

Agreed on the injured relievers, which is part of why spending on others seems unwise. It’s the position where the seasonal variability in performance is highest according to metrics. Guys good one year not the next. So the smart approach is to have 15 of them, including arms in the minors. And swing guys. I am convinced that ERod can close and be a stud at it. But unfortunately we need him in the rotation.
 

the Q

BY Misanthrope
Joined
Mar 28, 2017
Messages
3,497
Likes
2,606
#16
He’s just a kid. Younger than the guys behind him who are making noise. He’s got athleticism and can learn the position. But one of those 3 guys is a trade asset.

Agreed on the injured relievers, which is part of why spending on others seems unwise. It’s the position where the seasonal variability in performance is highest according to metrics. Guys good one year not the next. So the smart approach is to have 15 of them, including arms in the minors. And swing guys. I am convinced that ERod can close and be a stud at it. But unfortunately we need him in the rotation.
Oh I think he’ll hit.

But his body is already going the wrong way. I’m not bullish on him sticking at 3b long term
 

Top