not a counter, great discussion
love the %gains, can you share every expense as well (from grass seed, to paint, to property taxes & insurance paid, to other admin costs, to labor, to attys & real estate fees, to inconvenience of mulching all wknd while us renters were partying in Ibiza), and deduct both the financial and emotional costs, including the time value of money (and time), from the headlines?
I asked ChatGPT:
Here's a breakdown of the financial comparison over the 10 years you rented:
🏠 Homeowner (Paying $2,300/month)
- Total Paid: $276,000
- Principal Paid (Equity): $205,052.16
- Interest Paid: $70,947.84
- Net Cost (Total Paid - Equity): $70,947.84
🏢 Renter (Paying $3,000/month)
- Total Rent Paid: $360,000
- Equity Gained: $0
📊 Conclusion
✅ Financially, the homeowner made out better over 10 years.
Is there a scenario where renting for $3,000 a month would make more sense financially?
Yes, there are several scenarios where
renting for $3,000/month could make more financial sense than buying a home—even if the monthly mortgage payment is lower. Here are some key factors that could tilt the balance in favor of renting:
🧠
If a renter invests the difference between the cost of renting and the cost of owning (including down payment, maintenance, insurance, taxes), and earns a solid return, they could outperform the equity gained from homeownership.
- Example: If the homeowner puts $60,000 down and the renter invests that at 7% annual return, the investment could grow to over $118,000 in 10 years.
🛠️
Homeowners are responsible for all repairs and maintenance. If the home requires major work (roof, HVAC, plumbing), those costs can add up quickly.
- Renting avoids surprise expenses like a $10,000 roof replacement or $5,000 HVAC system.
📉
If the housing market stagnates or declines, the homeowner may not build much equity—or could even lose money.
- Renting avoids the risk of being “underwater” on a mortgage.
🧳
Renting offers more flexibility. If you need to move for work, family, or lifestyle, you can do so without selling a home.
- Selling a home involves agent fees (~6%), closing costs, and market timing risks.
🧾
In some areas, property taxes or HOA fees can be very high, adding significantly to the cost of ownership.
- Renters don’t pay these directly.