So, your reasoning is that he only had ONE dominant year? Good grief. Look, people might not like him. They might not think much of his abilities. But the bottom line is that there is no doubt he was a top 10 UConn back of all time. Maybe that's more of an indictment of UConn football history; I don't know. But there are not 10 guys better than him.
Let me also state that I'm NOT saying he's top 5, okay? Here's my list:
1)
Brown - I don't need to provide a reason for this spot, do I?
1a)
Todman - So close to the top spot for me, but if I'm going to give the nod, it has to go to The Donald
3)
Dixon - A complete package. Probably would have had much greater numbers if he didn't have to share with both Brown and Todman.
4)
Brockington - Cornell was awesome, and he put together one hell of a 2004 season.
5)
Caulley - Man o' man, what would his UConn career have been if it wasn't for the injury?
6)
Gilliard - Wilbur is probably the most overlooked 1-AA player we had. He gained 1,100 yards one season and had a career total of over 2,600. He battled injuries too.
7)
Frey - See the note about Dixon having to share with the great ones, and place that note here too.
8)
McCombs - Fourth in yards over a 3-year career, and did it while everyone knew it was coming (
for more on that, see "Johnny Mac").
9)
Tory Taylor - Had some real talent. Over 1,200 yards in a season. Didn't play all 4 years either (
don't remember where he transferred, though).
10)
Clements - So that Husky68 won't yell at me. Tough to compare the backs of that era with the backs of today, though. So much has changed since 1970.
So there you have it. We can argue about the relative positions, but there really is no reasonable argument against McCombs in the top 10. Now, if Longi comes to UConn and helps nudge him out,
I won't be upset...