Just so long as you admit that the Pac12 had to leave Earth's orbit in their last round of additions. Now you can drop the academic pretense...
Academics matters at some level. There are places the major conferences just won't go, places they will as long as there is enough cover. I mean Louisville is 160 but made all sorts of noise that they were investing to move up. On the other hand, no matter how much noise you make, Boise State is never going to gain admission to some conferences. From the Big East perspective, historically, academics have really never been much of an identifier. The league always had a pretty wide range from Georgetown to what are really regional schools of varying quality like Providence, Villanova and Seton Hall. Some, UConn and BC are good examples, really changed their relative status over the years. In the early years of the Big East BC was something like 90% Catholic, 75% from New England and much of that from Greater Boston. Syracuse was probably somewhere in the middle. After the 2003 ACC raid, the Big East went after the best athletic programs available, not the best academic entities. The big East in that sense was always more like the SEC or th eB-12 than the B-10 or the ACC.