No way Rudy Gay gets anywhere near the all-time team. Heck, he was never the leader of any team he played on and by his final season he more and more found himself on the bench come crunch time. Someone else was always taking the critical shot...Rashad Anderson or someone. All in all he was the one guy who got his laurels because of the name on the front of his shirt, not the name on the back.
My All time team would be: Guards, Gordon, Kemba, Doron Sheffer Ricky Moore
Forwards: Donyell Marshall, Ray Allen, Rip Hamilton, Caron Butler Bialasuknia, Tony Hanson, Freeman
Centers: Emeka Okafor, Toby Kimball, John Thomas, Thabeet (almost forgot him)
I was going to list small forwards and power forwards separately, but too many guys really played both. Only Freeman on my list was a "pure" power forward. Caron played like one in college, Marshall was a "hybrid" of sorts at UConn, so I decided to just list them all. Tony Hanson was Caron in an earlier incarnation.