Elijah Allen is the classic one... Still probably the best performance I've ever seen a college player have.
Others...
Novak dropped 41 on us
Darius Rice consistently killed us
Brian Tolbert who dropped 36 on us for Eastern Michigan in the tourney in 96.
I feel like Toby Bailey murdered us in 95 when he was a freshmen
Every undersized "4" in the 90s... Danya Abrams, Craig Smith, Da Meat Hook, Chevy Troutman
The entire Providence team that year when they dunked on us every, single possession of the 2nd half.
Ryan Gomes
His numbers weren't that impressive, but Royce White dunking on Drummond on the opening tip for Iowa St. previewed the absolute drubbing we would take in that half
Kittles had 36 against us in a blowout at home
Brandin Knight and that whole Pitt team (Blair, etc.)