I feel this way about Graves at Oregon. He loses people yearly and many of them were excellent contributors on a successful program. However, the Ducks were back in the tournament this year and gave Duke a game in the 2nd round with a piecemeal team so something worked for them. The same could happen for Indiana.
Fair enough, but ...
A coaching staff goes through a boatload of resources in the pursuit of high school talent. And I'm not just talking NIL: time, countless phone calls, texts, trips to all sorts of people beyond the intended prospect. Retention, as any good employer will tell you, requires a different set of talents, but is equally important.
Now, coaches like Graves, Brenda Frees and, increasing, Walz at Louisville have gotten used to the turnstile effect. (In fact, almost thrive).
But in the case of Graves, he's almost got to start from scratch again....and there go those resources again; unless they're just upping the NIL ante to get Deja Kelly's to come out. Besides, think how a balance of HS players and key transfers would do, as opposed to (re)shuffling the deck chairs in Eugene every year?
Moren --up to now -- doesn't lose that many key players, but she's certainly augmented her roster with key transfers, starting with Ali Patberg and continuing with Sydney Parrish. But she's balanced this with key HS recruits and retention: McKenzie Holmes, Grace Berger, Chloe Moore-McNeil. If these folks leave, it's worth a chat: was this planned (go for more athletic players, as one poster suggested? What's up?)
Could just the price of admission into today's D-1 machinations.