It's not a talent issue--it's a production issue. Lay didn't produce at the level that would've made Latson a luxury instead of a necessity. Having the "run of the floor" works both ways, as it also makes it easier for defenses to key in on you. Despite being on the first page of every scouting report against FSU, Ta'Niya was able to lead the nation in scoring and did so with higher shooting splits than Lay.
There are better shooters in the country than Tessa, but that doesn't mean that Tessa isn't a good shooter. She's an INCONSISTENT shooter, which was the problem this year. People see "47% from the field and 43% from three" and are convinced that this alone is indicative of her impact. But a 43% 3-point shooter can shoot 6-7 from three one night and 0-7 from three the next. That's why context is important. It's important to actually watch the games.
Back to Fulwiley: If Lay plays on another team, she likely could put up Hannah Hidalgo numbers. However, if she's not actually leading her team to conference championships and Sweet 16s (like Hannah has done), does it really matter? That would mean that she's not having a Hannah Hidalgo-like impact. Numbers don't mean squat if they're not impactful. We'll see what Lay does--she does have a lot of ground to make up if she's going to challenge the likes of Hannah and JuJu for individual honors.
I agree that it takes a certain type of player to excel coming off the bench, which is why I thought, at that time, that Joyce was more deserving of Sixth Woman of the Year than Lay. I disagree with the second part of this. Despite not having a dominant scorer on the roster, Dawn Michelle Staley was able to guide the team to a Top 2 finish nationally. Not starting Tessa or Lay didn't cause South Carolina to lose the championship. Those extra 3-5 minutes per game played by our seniors were not the difference between a title and a title game loss. The inability of the sophomore guards to step up and present a near-impossible challenge to CDS is the reason why this year's team didn't win it all. Again, Dawn's not mining the portal for the NCAA's leading scorer if she knows that Tessa and Lay could produce at that level.