- Joined
- Nov 2, 2011
- Messages
- 2,586
- Reaction Score
- 7,724
My son just completed the college recruiting process (baseball). Visits are about getting to know the player. Covid and the Portal have college coaches being much more selective with offers, for a number of reasons.If that's what happened I don't think it's right. What other programs do shouldn't come into the equation. That said, I'm not at all sure this offer was pulled because of the roster. It makes no sense that they have this kid in for an OV and then pull the offer......none!
Every recruit has “talent”, but offers are not legally binding. Coaches are looking for fit with these visits. What’s the kid’s personality? How is his character? Is he coachable? Is he a great teammate? Does he get along with other recruits? How does he talk to his parents/guardian/coaches? What are his expectations in this program? Do those expectations align with the staffs? What are his other interests outside of sports? What’s his [insert sport] IQ?
These are some of the things my son was being evaluated on during his visits. Fit matters, for all parties. Rosters are backed up and spots are limited. Coaches don’t want a kid that doesn’t check all the boxes. Furthermore, coaches (except Edsall) would rather grab an experienced/physically ready player from the portal for a year or two, over an 18-yr old kid who’s not and won’t clear your roster for four/five years.
It’s unfair to the kid, but it’s not the coach’s fault. These are the cards they were dealt. This is an NCAA problem.