Your Top 10 Dramatic Series | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Your Top 10 Dramatic Series

intlzncster said:
Never understood why BB was ranked so high in general. I mean, it's a good show for sure, but it struggled plot-wise for a bit, fell into the annoying trope of twists-for-twists sake*, and had too many annoying characters (Hi Skylar).

*on the one hand, I hate when writers/producers do this, on the other, it was an interesting metaphor for the show, given that this writing style is like a drug, rather than a deeper richer story-line.

All that said, I did enjoy the show. Just probably not Top 5 for me.
Expand ...
If the twists and drama were supposed to be mataphoic for the cheapening of a high and the lengths to which addicts will go to achieve any kind of high, then yeah, I'll put it equal to The Wire. Perhaps Jesse's relationship to WW in the fight-"breakup"-realign cycle they go through multiple times is metaphoric for that as well.

Because that's my one massive issue with the show besides being bored by S3 knowing that whatever "ohhh SH----------T what's gonna happen?!" situation the writers would leave you in, you knew WW had some brilliant out. Got kinda boring. The plot was grossly unchanged throughout the series, just with ramping up of the diabolical-ness of each new villain until the last villain left was WW himself.
 
Rocktheworld said:
If the twists and drama were supposed to be mataphoic for the cheapening of a high and the lengths to which addicts will go to achieve any kind of high, then yeah, I'll put it equal to The Wire. Perhaps Jesse's relationship to WW in the fight-"breakup"-realign cycle they go through multiple times is metaphoric for that as well.

Because that's my one massive issue with the show besides being bored by S3 knowing that whatever "ohhh SH----------T what's gonna happen?!" situation the writers would leave you in, you knew WW had some brilliant out. Got kinda boring. The plot was grossly unchanged throughout the series, just with ramping up of the diabolical-ness of each new villain until the last villain left was WW himself.
Expand ...

I'm not saying that was the case, just that it wouldn't totally surprise me, as Vince Gilligan was pretty thorough.

But more than likely, it was a function of needing/wanting to extend the show. BB was a 3 season show that was pushed to 5 due to popularity/profitability. The 'Lost' model.
 
intlzncster said:
I'm not saying that was the case, just that it wouldn't totally surprise me, as Vince Gilligan was pretty thorough.
Expand ...
Absolutely

But more than likely, it was a function of needing/wanting to extend the show. BB was a 3 season show that was pushed to 5 due to popularity/profitability. The 'Lost' model.
Expand ...
Oh really? I thought all 5 seasons were written ahead of time. So was more plot just tacked on to the 3, or was the 3 seasons of content pulled out to 5? I have a hard time believing that the series was supposed to end with Jesse killing Gale. Though I could see that being a different "end" that had to be worked in when the show was extended, and perhaps the series was supposed to end with WW in Gale's place; IIRC writers have said they initially had Jesse killing WW
 
Last edited:
Rocktheworld said:
Absolutely


Oh really? I thought all 5 seasons were written ahead of time. So was more plot just tacked on to the 3, or was the 3 seasons of content pulled out to 5? I have a hard time believing that the series was supposed to end with Jesse killing Gale. Though I could see that being a different "end" that had to be worked in when the show was extended, and perhaps the series was supposed to end with WW in Gale's place; IIRC writers have said they initially had Jesse killing WW
Expand ...

Misunderstanding. I wasn't at all clear there. I was saying that the content and feel of the show would have been best suited to 3 seasons. At it's heart BB was a 3 season show. So they could have written it to be a far tighter show had they compressed the 5 seasons into 3. The Lost metaphor doesn't quite work in that sense.

Had no idea when/how it was written.
 
nelsonmuntz said:
There was a thread about this a year ago, but I am game.

1) Mad Men - if you don't have it at in your top 5, I recommend you watch it.
Expand ...

Have to agree. This was on our watchlist for a long time and I pushed it off for a couple years, anyhow. Was concerned with how much dry drama the show would have, but boy was I wrong. Really great stuff. We're halfway through season 4 or 5 and it really is awesome.
 
.-.
nelsonmuntz said:
I don't think Quantum Leap or Cagney and Lacey have aged well.
Expand ...

Same with Wiseguy. I loved the 1st season of that show. I tried to watch it recently and couldn't get through it. I used to love St. Elsewhere, I wonder how that one holds up?
 
intlzncster said:
I'm not gonna do best ever, because that's always changing.
Expand ...

Ain't that the truth. Right now I have to say that my three favorite shows are Justified, Foyle's War and Veronica Mars.
 
Glad to see Justified getting some love. I always thought that show deserved a lot more attention than it got. Also cool to see Orphan Black and Veronica Mars mentioned (although VM went way downhill by season 3). A show I haven't seen mentioned, it was a one off, I think it got cancelled before the season was over but you can watch the full season on DVD--Day Break. Kind of a Groundhog Day setup, where everything keeps repeating, except it's a drama about a detective.
 
Deadrody said:
Have to agree. This was on our watchlist for a long time and I pushed it off for a couple years, anyhow. Was concerned with how much dry drama the show would have, but boy was I wrong. Really great stuff. We're halfway through season 4 or 5 and it really is awesome.
Expand ...

Almost a perfect show that wasn't dry at all. One of the things that separated it from other dramas is that it could be very funny at times. Roger has some great lines, like the time when the secretary ran over the guy's foot with a tractor at an office party, and Roger said "believe me, somewhere in this business, this has happened before."
 
intlzncster said:
I'm not saying that was the case, just that it wouldn't totally surprise me, as Vince Gilligan was pretty thorough.

But more than likely, it was a function of needing/wanting to extend the show. BB was a 3 season show that was pushed to 5 due to popularity/profitability. The 'Lost' model.
Expand ...
I can see some of the big picture criticism of BB, but comparing it to Lost is not apt. Lost had lots of mystery dead ends and survived on myth and speculation versus actual plot developments. I thought the BB arc was very supportable and only its the final season did they lengthen the series a bit (once Jessie & Walt split), I simply enjoyed the story telling style and art of it, great flourishes combined with action & twists.
 
The Wire
The Wire
The Wire
The Wire
The Sopranos
Breaking Bad
Lost
Game of Thrones
Mad Men
 
.-.
August_West said:
The Wire
The Wire
The Wire
The Wire
The Sopranos
Breaking Bad
Lost
Game of Thrones
Mad Men
Expand ...


Actually...

Sopranos
The Wire
The Wire
The Wire
GOT
Breaking Bad
The West Wing
Banshee - more popcorn TV than drama but it was darn entertaining

I watched the first season of Mad Men, didn't care enough about the characters.

The reason for Sopranos over the Wire is because the Sopranos came first making the Wire a derivative and the Sopranos went deeper that the main storyline than the Wire did. There was also a lot more varied plot lines. Top to bottom the Wire had a better cast but Gandolfini was the best performance. Breaking Bad decided to turn the Sopranos Janice character into an entire family of annoying sots, otherwise it would be higher.
 
SubbaBub said:
Actually...

Sopranos
The Wire
The Wire
The Wire
GOT
Breaking Bad
The West Wing
Banshee - more popcorn TV than drama but it was darn entertaining

I watched the first season of Mad Men, didn't care enough about the characters.

The reason for Sopranos over the Wire is because the Sopranos came first making the Wire a derivative and the Sopranos went deeper that the main storyline than the Wire did. There was also a lot more varied plot lines. Top to bottom the Wire had a better cast but Gandolfini was the best performance. Breaking Bad decided to turn the Sopranos Janice character into an entire family of annoying sots, otherwise it would be higher.
Expand ...

I didn't love the waterfront or newspaper seasons of the Wire. They weren't bad, but the competition is pretty strong at the top and the wire doesn't make my Top 5 because of those two seasons.

I could be talked into putting the West Wing above Narcos. I am expecting big things out of Narcos season 3 though.

Westworld has True Detective and Bloodline potential to completely face plant in season 2.
 
SubbaBub said:
Actually...

Sopranos
The Wire
The Wire
The Wire
GOT
Breaking Bad
The West Wing
Banshee - more popcorn TV than drama but it was darn entertaining

I watched the first season of Mad Men, didn't care enough about the characters.

The reason for Sopranos over the Wire is because the Sopranos came first making the Wire a derivative and the Sopranos went deeper that the main storyline than the Wire did. There was also a lot more varied plot lines. Top to bottom the Wire had a better cast but Gandolfini was the best performance. Breaking Bad decided to turn the Sopranos Janice character into an entire family of annoying sots, otherwise it would be higher.
Expand ...

West Wing definitely belongs.

Wire better than Sopranos but its a razor thin margin. I dont get mad at people for liking sopranos more, as long as they recognize that the wire is right there. At that point its personal preference. Sopranos IS that good. so is the Wire.

Where I get the Lolz is people who rank breaking bad up with those two. Breaking Bad is Awesome and the 3rd best show in TV history. It is not anywhere near the Wire or Sopranos. The absolute brilliance of Cranston nonwithstanding.

By the way. Lost is a new addition to my list.
I watched it live week to week throughout the series and was kinda put off by the ending. I loved it and hated it.

I never did a a rewatch ....................... until recently. Wife and I just finished the 6 season rewatch just a few days ago. It was WAY better 2nd time through.

I have a theory on that. First time through (especially if you watched it week to week in real time) it seemed to be a plot driven show. A bunch of questions. What is the hatch? What are the numbers? What is the black smoke? The polar bear? etc...etc..... those kept you coming back for answers.

All that is wiped away on rewatch. On rewatch you realize that Lost is actually intended to be character driven. And really well done. it was like watching a different show the 2nd time through. I really, really enjoyed it.
 
August_West said:
West Wing definitely belongs.

Wire better than Sopranos but its a razor thin margin. I dont get mad at people for liking sopranos more, as long as they recognize that the wire is right there. At that point its personal preference. Sopranos IS that good. so is the Wire.

Where I get the Lolz is people who rank breaking bad up with those two. Breaking Bad is Awesome and the 3rd best show in TV history. It is not anywhere near the Wire or Sopranos. The absolute brilliance of Cranston nonwithstanding.

By the way. Lost is a new addition to my list.
I watched it live week to week throughout the series and was kinda put off by the ending. I loved it and hated it.

I never did a a rewatch ........ until recently. Wife and I just finished the 6 season rewatch just a few days ago. It was WAY better 2nd time through.

I have a theory on that. First time through (especially if you watched it week to week in real time) it seemed to be a plot driven show. A bunch of questions. What is the hatch? What are the numbers? What is the black smoke? The polar bear? etc...etc..... those kept you coming back for answers.

All that is wiped away on rewatch. On rewatch you realize that Lost is actually intended to be character driven. And really well done. it was like watching a different show the 2nd time through. I really, really enjoyed it.
Expand ...
I did a rewatch of The Wire earlier this year and just finished a rewatch of The Sopranos the other night. I used to have them neck and neck but The Wire is a better show.
 
nelsonmuntz said:
Almost a perfect show that wasn't dry at all. One of the things that separated it from other dramas is that it could be very funny at times. Roger has some great lines, like the time when the secretary ran over the guy's foot with a tractor at an office party, and Roger said "believe me, somewhere in this business, this has happened before."
Expand ...

Just saw this episode last night. The timing and delivery were impeccable.
 
August_West said:
West Wing definitely belongs.

Wire better than Sopranos but its a razor thin margin. I dont get mad at people for liking sopranos more, as long as they recognize that the wire is right there. At that point its personal preference. Sopranos IS that good. so is the Wire.

Where I get the Lolz is people who rank breaking bad up with those two. Breaking Bad is Awesome and the 3rd best show in TV history. It is not anywhere near the Wire or Sopranos. The absolute brilliance of Cranston nonwithstanding.

By the way. Lost is a new addition to my list.
I watched it live week to week throughout the series and was kinda put off by the ending. I loved it and hated it.

I never did a a rewatch ........ until recently. Wife and I just finished the 6 season rewatch just a few days ago. It was WAY better 2nd time through.

I have a theory on that. First time through (especially if you watched it week to week in real time) it seemed to be a plot driven show. A bunch of questions. What is the hatch? What are the numbers? What is the black smoke? The polar bear? etc...etc..... those kept you coming back for answers.

All that is wiped away on rewatch. On rewatch you realize that Lost is actually intended to be character driven. And really well done. it was like watching a different show the 2nd time through. I really, really enjoyed it.
Expand ...


Mike Ehrmantraut and Gus Fring are two of the best characters in TV history. Saul is pretty good. Walter was really good and Jessie came on later, but the family...ugh. I literally started fast forwarding anytime the wife, her sister, or his son was on screen without Walt. While necessary to the plot Hank was the dumbest FBI agent of all time.

I thought Lost was fascinating at the time, but doubt I'd have the energy to do a full rewatch. The ending didn't bother me. Once the man in black showed up it was pretty clear that they were all dead (if it wasn't already) and the ending was going to be some afterlife scene.
 
.-.
SubbaBub said:
Once the man in black showed up it was pretty clear that they were all dead (if it wasn't already) and the ending was going to be some afterlife scene.
Expand ...

Ah but they weren't all dead! Everything that happened on the island including the man in black and jack and then Hurley becoming guardians of the island at the very end happened. The " flash sideways" in LA the last season, they were "dead" but the island was alive. All other flashes in all other seasons happened as well. Including the oceanic 6 getting off the island at the end of season 4 and back on at end of season 5 .

Worth a rewatch
 
1. Sons of Anarchy
2. Game of Thrones
3. Breaking Bad
4. Better Call Saul
5. The Americans
6. The Sopranos
7. Entourage
8. Dexter
9. Homeland
10. The Walking Dead
10A. Stranger Things

Need to see: Mad Men, House of Cards, Vikings, Fargo, The Wire
 
My barometer for a dramatic series is whether I would re-watch it:

1) The Wire - must have watched it 4-5 times all the way through
2) The West Wing - have been through it all 3 times
3) Boss - with Kelsey Grammar - sadly only 2 seasons
4) Banshee - Cinemax - going through it now for the 3rd time
5) Strike Back - Cinemax - have watched it twice
6) Person of Interest - twice
7) Prison Break - the first iteration - twice
8) Murder One - the first season - have watched multiple times - one of the best seasons of TV ever IMHO
9) Fringe - huge fan - haven't watched again but on my list to start over from the beginning
10) Homeland - especially the early seasons

Lots of other great stuff in progress:

1) Better Call Saul
2) GoT
3) Ray Donovan
4) Billions

and more...

But as much as I enjoy Walking Dead, and feel invested enough that I'll watch every episode for as long as it runs, I don't find it a top show, because a lot of it would be unwatchable a 2nd time.
 
J187Money said:
My barometer for a dramatic series is whether I would re-watch it:

1) The Wire - must have watched it 4-5 times all the way through
2) The West Wing - have been through it all 3 times
3) Boss - with Kelsey Grammar - sadly only 2 seasons
4) Banshee - Cinemax - going through it now for the 3rd time
5) Strike Back - Cinemax - have watched it twice
6) Person of Interest - twice
7) Prison Break - the first iteration - twice
8) Murder One - the first season - have watched multiple times - one of the best seasons of TV ever IMHO
9) Fringe - huge fan - haven't watched again but on my list to start over from the beginning
10) Homeland - especially the early seasons

Lots of other great stuff in progress:

1) Better Call Saul
2) GoT
3) Ray Donovan
4) Billions

and more...

But as much as I enjoy Walking Dead, and feel invested enough that I'll watch every episode for as long as it runs, I don't find it a top show, because a lot of it would be unwatchable a 2nd time.
Expand ...

Good standard. I re-watch the Sopranos quite a bit. Same with the first episode of Boss.

I do not do that with Boardwalk Empire that much. I have two issues with BE: 1) Steve Buscemi is a perfectly serviceable actor, but wasn't exactly the right actor for that part. 2) Related to #1, the show killed off Jimmy Darmody too quickly. Buscemi was not strong enough to carry the show by himself, and without William Pitt as a c0-lead, something was missing. I liked some of the later seasons, but that was the difference between good and great.
 
.-.
nelsonmuntz said:
Good standard. I re-watch the Sopranos quite a bit. Same with the first episode of Boss.

I do not do that with Boardwalk Empire that much. I have two issues with BE: 1) Steve Buscemi is a perfectly serviceable actor, but wasn't exactly the right actor for that part. 2) Related to #1, the show killed off Jimmy Darmody too quickly. Buscemi was not strong enough to carry the show by himself, and without William Pitt as a c0-lead, something was missing. I liked some of the later seasons, but that was the difference between good and great.
Expand ...

I haven't been able to get through the first season of BE. I've tried several times - perhaps have to give it another run.
 
J187Money said:
My barometer for a dramatic series is whether I would re-watch it:

1) The Wire - must have watched it 4-5 times all the way through
2) The West Wing - have been through it all 3 times
3) Boss - with Kelsey Grammar - sadly only 2 seasons
4) Banshee - Cinemax - going through it now for the 3rd time
5) Strike Back - Cinemax - have watched it twice
6) Person of Interest - twice
7) Prison Break - the first iteration - twice
8) Murder One - the first season - have watched multiple times - one of the best seasons of TV ever IMHO
9) Fringe - huge fan - haven't watched again but on my list to start over from the beginning
10) Homeland - especially the early seasons

Lots of other great stuff in progress:

1) Better Call Saul
2) GoT
3) Ray Donovan
4) Billions

and more...

But as much as I enjoy Walking Dead, and feel invested enough that I'll watch every episode for as long as it runs, I don't find it a top show, because a lot of it would be unwatchable a 2nd time.
Expand ...
I watch too much TV, but that is too much TV watching! ;)
If re-watch-ability is #1 criteria my favorite show is probably* M*A*S*H or Star Trek as I've seen those episodes at least 3-4 times each.

*Brady Bunch might be up there too, can I get a waiver for pre-12yrs old views?
 
Dogdeacon said:
I watch too much TV, but that is too much TV watching! ;)
If re-watch-ability is #1 criteria my favorite show is probably* M*A*S*H or Star Trek as I've seen those episodes at least 3-4 times each.

*Brady Bunch might be up there too, can I get a waiver for pre-12yrs old views?
Expand ...

I travel a ton for work, and I commute to the city every day. Most of the above I've purchased via iTunes so watched without streaming. No way I could ever watch that much TV sitting in front of a TV.
 
Bumping this thread. Game of Thrones stumbled across the finish line, Westworld's season 2 felt like a calculus exam. Has anyone changed their opinion?
 
I can't keep up. . .

The Sopranos - watched it after the fact and loved it. Drama and comedy. Tried watching Westworld and gave up in season 2. I like Billions and I am into season two of GOT. I am admittedly missing out on a lot of good TV mostly because we don't pay for the extras. Got suckered into This Is Us but the stories are repetitive and I'm finding the kids to be whiners.
er, West Wing, Columbo, Hawaii Five-0, Ellery Queen, Mannix, Hart to Hart, Quincy, Mission Impossible
I don't see 24 on here, thank God. I watched 1 season and regretted it.
 
Dove said:
No order and just off the top of my head...

Fargo
Better Call Saul
Peaky Blinders
Bates Motel
The Walking Dead
Dexter


ER
Law and Order


Hill Street Blues
Quantum Leap
Cagney and Lacey


Going waaaaay back when I was a kid:

How The West Was Won
Emergency
The Rookies
Adam 12
Land of the Giants
Expand ...
KMG365

Charlie's Angels
Fantasy Island
The Love Boat
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,632
Messages
4,587,005
Members
10,497
Latest member
Orlando Fos


Top Bottom