He was griping about VT getting selected over both Boise and KSU, but thought Michigan made sense b/c of the name and their history. Hey Kirk, VT was actually ranked higher than Michigan. Neither of the 2 should have gotten in over KSU or Boise.
He was proposing his preferred Plus 1 system of mathing 1 v. 4 and 2 v. 3 in a semi-final as the solution to the OSU or Bama debate, but was speachless when Davis reminded him that would have kept Oregon out and let Stanford in, even though Oregon shallacked Stanford and were P12 champs. Was speachless when the other guy questioned why should LSU hav eto play in to a championship game when they ran the table. Herbie insists his 4 team playoff (a Plus 1) is the answer, but claims an 8 or 16 team playoff could never work. He reminded me of the guy from "There's Something About Mary" who came up wit the "7 minute ab" idea to compete with the 8 minute ab, when Ben Stiller says "what if someone comse out with a 6 minute ab", "No, No, you can't have a 6 minute ab, that would never work."
The guy continually contradicts himself. But hey, he's got the look, and he can BS all day long.