Here is the answer you are asking for. Geno is allowed 15 scholarships but if he would just find 6 "A" players and 5 or 6 "B" players that would allow him to make mistakes and still have a very competitive team. You don't always have everyone playing their best each game but you can replace them with someone less talented but anxious to give you 100%.I'm not sure what point you and others are making with this line of argument. Is it that Geno should succeed with every recruiting pitch? As we all know, he recruited both Brown and Cox, and more recently Boston, and was not successful -- but not for lack of effort. So what is your point -- that we need a coach who can be more persuasive with those kinds of recruits?
Or are you saying that he should be less selective and just get a big body? He has tried that also, successfully (a long time ago) with Kara Wolters and more recently with Natalie Butler and (yes) Kyla Irwin. But then you say that isn't the answer.
So, what (in your opinion) is the answer? What should Geno and CD doing that they aren't already doing?
Seriously, what is the problem with carrying a few extra players? Muffet figures for every good player she recruits, that is one less player Geno can use against her team. Makes sense to me too.