Even someone as great as Eli Manning can throw an air ball now and again. Nobody was comparing Tyler Davis to Eli Manning.
Mariota didn't start on his high school team until his senior year, was redshirted and the rest is history. That was the only comparison.
Jorden Speith- every now and again a youngster can come along and blow the field away.
For THIS UCONN team, regardless of how good Tyler Davis may or may not be is not the right team to have a freshman start off the bat. I agree with Spackler that we have to stock pile some of these guys. Starting any freshman QB right now would not be good because there are too many unproven commodities on this team and a very unsteady ship needs to be stabilized. For now, I am hoping that Sheriffs can get it done. I understand that. Once things settle down there may be an opportunity.
Let's keep this simple. I believe Tyler Davis, barring injury will become a star Quarterback for UCONN. I believe he will be REALLY good but I'm not anointing anybody yet. Tyler Davis has to earn my respect and everyone else's. You, elevator neck, Whaler and Spackler don't. No big deal. Just a difference of opinion. Some guys want UCONN to go back to the Big East in Basketball and go back to playing FCS football and I don't agree with that.
If I was starting a football team from scratch and I had to pick from the 4 QB's for the long term, I would go with Tyler Davis. He would be my long term choice. If I had to pick for next year only, it would probably be Brandon Sheriffs.
Most of you guys believe Diaco will be a flop too, so what else is new.