Who has the most talent on the DL Yanks, Sox or Rays?

[sinkhole]

C'mon, the Sox are missing almost 3 teams worth of OFs.

We are talking quality not quanity. List the Sox guys and i will give you my opinion.

 

[jmp33]

Ellsbury = Longo
Crawford > Fuld
Ross > Jennings (jennings may have bright future, but present is .253 career)
Sweeny > Allen
Kalish = both your catchers since only one backup at a time behind the great molina
Bailey >= Farnsworth
Youk > Keppinger (Youk was back, but on DL when this thread started. Kep playing when thread started)
#5 starter (Dice or Lak) = #5 starter Niemann. but don't want to go through that crap, so just take this one.

 

[sinkhole]

Ellsbury = Longo
Crawford > Fuld
Ross > Jennings (jennings may have bright future, but present is .253 career)
Sweeny > Allen
Kalish = both your catchers since only one backup at a time behind the great molina
Bailey >= Farnsworth
Youk > Keppinger (Youk was back, but on DL when this thread started. Kep playing when thread started)
#5 starter (Dice or Lak) = #5 starter Niemann. but don't want to go through that crap, so just take this one.

We are not gonna agree on this my friend.

 

[jmp33]

Thats fair...

 

[The Viking]

We are not gonna agree on this my friend.

The bottom line is this and it's really this simple. If anyone thinks Crawford will return anywhere close to the player he was his whole career before 2011, than there's no discussion to be had. An Ellsbury/Crawford/Bailey trio can't be matched by any team, let alone the other injuries the Sox have had this year.

 

[sinkhole]

The bottom line is this and it's really this simple. If anyone thinks Crawford will return anywhere close to the player he was his whole career before 2011, than there's no discussion to be had. An Ellsbury/Crawford/Bailey trio can't be matched by any team, let alone the other injuries the Sox have had this year.

Longo-Farnsworth-Jennings