Was Florida State Screwed by the Committee? | Page 4 | The Boneyard

Was Florida State Screwed by the Committee?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can understand people saying the SEC is the best conference and justifying it. However, the SEC just wasn’t that great this year. That’s the problem. They just didn’t have anything to work with to warrant leaving FSU out except an injury, that seems weak. The kids should be allowed to try and overcome that.
 
"Essentially, you have the chair of the committee that not only determines the fate of numerous programs, but also the significant monetary fate of the sport, blaming FSU’s exclusion on the injury to Jordan Travis. The committee blamed Jordan Travis for breaking his leg."

"With the reasoning given by the committee, they’ve now set the precedent that they will leave a team out of the playoffs because of a star player being injured. The financial benefits to the school? The TV exposure and recruiting benefits? The incredible experience for the players and coaches? All of that now falls on a young man, or young men, who had bad injury luck. Let’s hope that they have strong support systems around them, because this is the kind of stuff that can result in tragedy."

 
"Essentially, you have the chair of the committee that not only determines the fate of numerous programs, but also the significant monetary fate of the sport, blaming FSU’s exclusion on the injury to Jordan Travis. The committee blamed Jordan Travis for breaking his leg."
This is laugh-out-loud funny if you ask me. If the guy didn't get hurt, they would have come up with another reason. FSU not getting selected is the only good thing about this CFB season.
 
Eventually...when the big split occurs...the championship may reflect the NFL model..

No committee, no losses and you are out, no dropping a team because players are injured...none of that happens in the NFL. (and less chance of controversy like the current Corrigan's (the head of the Selection Committee) brother is the ESPN Vice President of Production. None of that...just win baby, win.

It may be played out on the field like the NFL...Divisions like the AFC and NFC...with each of those subdivided into four team pods (or subdivisions)...AFC East, West, North, South, etc.

Win your pod, win your match up with other pod winner, win your division, play for the championship.
 
"Essentially, you have the chair of the committee that not only determines the fate of numerous programs, but also the significant monetary fate of the sport, blaming FSU’s exclusion on the injury to Jordan Travis. The committee blamed Jordan Travis for breaking his leg."

"With the reasoning given by the committee, they’ve now set the precedent that they will leave a team out of the playoffs because of a star player being injured. The financial benefits to the school? The TV exposure and recruiting benefits? The incredible experience for the players and coaches? All of that now falls on a young man, or young men, who had bad injury luck. Let’s hope that they have strong support systems around them, because this is the kind of stuff that can result in tragedy."

This is ever so slightly over the top! I’m of the opinion that ESPN wanted Alabama and if FSU got in the way, they are collateral damage. Honestly, I thought Texas was out the door because they would take a 13-0 team, and other that Alabama, Texas didn’t beat anybody but I guessed wrong on that. Had things been reversed, and Alabama lost its quarterback who thinks we wouldn’t read about how brilliant Bama had been to pull off a huge win with a backup?
 
They got jobbed. They were still able to beat a ranked LCC with the 3rd stringer, and the 2nd stringer will be back by the playoffs. I can only assume that the other 21 starters on the team must be for the committee to put so much importance on that one player.
Someone up above said that it's not a playoff, it's an invitational. So name it as such and call it a day. P2 Invitational.
 
.-.
This is ever so slightly over the top! I’m of the opinion that ESPN wanted Alabama and if FSU got in the way, they are collateral damage. Honestly, I thought Texas was out the door because they would take a 13-0 team, and other that Alabama, Texas didn’t beat anybody but I guessed wrong on that. Had things been reversed, and Alabama lost its quarterback who thinks we wouldn’t read about how brilliant Bama had been to pull off a huge win with a backup?
Would have been easier for them to take the three undefeated and then Bama if not for the inconvenient head-head result... WWE level sports entertainment.
 
I can understand people saying the SEC is the best conference and justifying it. However, the SEC just wasn’t that great this year. That’s the problem. They just didn’t have anything to work with to warrant leaving FSU out except an injury, that seems weak. The kids should be allowed to try and overcome that.
SEC people can prove they are the best conference pretty easily... Schedule big games and win them in the non-conference. They did that right? Oh wait they actually lost the big matchups this year.... bama texas, miami am, lsu florida state..... There have been years that the SEC was dominant but this year they lose the big ones
 
Absolutely correct. FSU got jobbed.
If undefeated Washington’s QB Pennix, or undefeated UM’s QB JJ McIntyre broke their foot in last game would either team be left out of playoff? Not on your life.
The kid from FSU broke it 2 (or 3?) games ago. The committee knows how they did without him. That's what they judged on. The fact that it opened the door for the SEC was just a bonus.
 
Well it doesn’t look that way right now… Georgia has exposed ACC Football for what it is - Overrated and it’s 28-3 and well before halftime.

These teams are nowhere close - talent level. Florida St might have been overrated.

With Syracuse getting embarrassed by USF this is not a good look for the ACC.

With all the key players skipping these bowls makes you wonder why all the hype for these things.. back ups vs back ups.
 
.-.
FSU is getting smashed. I doubt even with the 30 something players that opted out would have made much of an impact on this.
Not sure why this surprised anyone. FSU's best game was an OT win over Clemson ... the team that needed a big comeback to beat Kentucky.
 
Not sure why this surprised anyone. FSU's best game was an OT win over Clemson ... the team that needed a big comeback to beat Kentucky.
It shouldn't be surprising to anyone because half their team and all their best players skipped the bowl game.

The bowl season is a disaster and totally meaningless these days.
 
Georgia has players out too. FSU might have won a participation trophy, if their guys played.
 
.-.
This is really men against boys. FSU was powered by portal guys, and a 6th year QB who had really put it together. Those guys are all out, and the rest of their roster just isn't anywhere near what Georgia has out there.
 
Well it doesn’t look that way right now… Georgia has exposed ACC Football for what it is - Overrated and it’s 28-3 and well before halftime.

These teams are nowhere close - talent level. Florida St might have been overrated.

With Syracuse getting embarrassed by USF this is not a good look for the ACC.

With all the key players skipping these bowls makes you wonder why all the hype for these things.. back ups vs back ups.
Hard to really say as 23 FSU players opted out. Gonna guess that had something to do with the 42 to 3 halftime score.
 
Result doesn't matter unless you are OK with play taking a back seat to TV.

Bama had and elimation gsme with Texas and lost. Texas lost to an OU team, bowl relevance aside, that just got smoked.

FSU won a P5 league and went undefeated. They earned the spot. Any other opinion misses the point of a NCG in the first place. May as well go back to the polling system, at least that is more honest as a beauty contest.

Under the old system Michigan would play UW in the Rose Bowl and that winner would be ranked No. 1 regardless of what else happened. We've done a lot of hand wringing to get no closer. Next year will be different.
 
Hard to really say as 23 FSU players opted out. Gonna guess that had something to do with the 42 to 3 halftime score.
Without Jordan Travis it’s still a slaughter house, Verse might have some sacks but wouldn’t make much of a difference. With Jordan Travis FSU wins a participation trophy.
 
.-.
FSU won a P5 league and went undefeated. They earned the spot.

The rules say that critical injuries are a factor.

Just as it is in other sports. The UConn women have had their seed lowered because of late season injuries.

FSU was not the same team w/o their QB. And I'm not convinced they were great even with him.
 
FSU is getting smashed. I doubt even with the 30 something players that opted out would have made much of an impact on this.
If they had their players and the QB who is one of the very best in college this year they may have made a game of it. UGA has a bunch of opt out too. Bowl season now sucks.
 
FSU making their point that games matter by not showing up for the game.
Thats what makes teams like UGA and Bama great programs because they don’t quit their season, because it didn’t end the way they wanted. UGA took this game more seriously and of course they’re better. UGA has guys out too they get their backups to level up.
 
Thats what makes teams like UGA and Bama great programs because they don’t quit their season, because it didn’t end the way they wanted. UGA took this game more seriously and of course they’re better. UGA has guys out too they get their backups to level up.
When's the last time Bama had a meaningless game?
 
When's the last time Bama had a meaningless game?
Bama didn’t make it into CFP last year with Bryce Young, did they feel sorry for themselves no Bryce Young played and they dominated in their bowl game. They haven’t made the CFP every season.

The year Tua got hurt Mac Jones took over and they dominated their bowl game after losing to Auburn.
 
.-.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,181
Messages
4,555,943
Members
10,441
Latest member
Virginiafan


Top Bottom