I thought it was a good discussion, and a valid debate, and no one said it was 'wrong' they just chose two people to propose the two runners up and defend their credentials and Peck clearly stated at the end if she were a coach, she would take Stewart.
The debate rages on between most valuable to your team and best player - in every sport every year. No question that Uconn would have done better this year without Stewart than Baylor without Sims or Stanford whiteout Chiney so they were 'more valuable', but the voters in a more lopsided vote than I expected decided that Stewart was the best player.
They both sort of down played defensive effort by Stewart at first, though Peck corrected that at the end.