- Joined
- Mar 30, 2012
- Messages
- 8,748
- Reaction Score
- 25,861
Right. My comment was really dealing with the idea that the state should move away from defined benefits pensions. While I agree that "everyone is doing it" i also think, and there is some research backing this up, that the move away from pensions to IRAs was a bad policy, and will have negative long term consequences. Whether the state should contribute to bad policy is a legitimate subject of debate.
The pensions are going to fail also. At least when 401ks fail, the owner knows he was partly at fault; and he also knows how much he has throughout, so he can begin saving up or conserving money earlier. When pensions fail the pensioner is helpless, and surprised. The human effects of pension failures will be far worse than those of 401k failures.