Does Geno get very talented players, some of the truly elite? Absolutely.
Does he make them even better players? Absolutely.
If you really want to see how great of a coach Geno is, look to players who either were not ranked in the top ten or who were ranked in the top 25 in a weaker high school class, in terms of talent and depth (e.g., 2005). Think about players like Jessica Moore and Kalana Greene.
Moore was ranked 43rd by Blue Star coming out of high school. She was in the elite high school class of 2000/college class of 2004. Yet she played NINE seasons in the WNBA.
Look at the list of players below, many of whom had incredible college careers. How many of them have played in the WNBA nearly as long as Jessica?
- Ashley Robinson
- Diana Taurasi
- Ebony Hoffman
- Cherisse Graham
- Nicole Powell
- Iciss Tillis
- Chandi Jones
- Ebony Felder
- Shereka Wright
- Aminata Yanni
- Monique Coker
- Tasha Butts
- Anne O'Neil
Remember, Moore was ranked 43rd on this list. But because of the development under Geno Auriemma, she has had a much longer career than most of the names on this list.
Kalana Greene was a top 20/25 player in the Class of 2005, generally regarded as not particularly deep or as talented as many in the last decade. She was part of the 2010 WNBA draft. If you look at her fellow draftees from 2009 (which would have been her high school class), no one in the second or third rounds is still in the WNBA...and there are a few first round picks who no longer are. If you look at 2010, when she was drafted, only five players in the first round still remain in the league. Kalana is the only non-first round selection from 2009 and 2010 still in the WNBA after five years.
Moore and Greene were talented, but they were not as naturally gifted as many other players among their contemporaries. Yet they have had much longer and more successful professional careers. The reasons for this were expertly highlighted in Kate Fagan's piece - hard work, intensity, swagger, mental toughness, etc. And that all starts from Geno Auriemma.