MilfordHusky
Voice of Reason
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 37,522
- Reaction Score
- 128,428
I'm thinking the starters are:
Really, really good!![Big Grin :D :D](/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/biggrin.png)
Really, really good!
![Big Grin :D :D](/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/biggrin.png)
Some think that; some think she starts the season as the 2 guard, with Kia playing point. Then Crystal works her way in and things shift around. Of course, that keeps Saniya on the bench, and she certainly has her fans. I guess it comes down to how well Lou can help Kia break a potential press in the very hard early season.Why are you labeling KLS as guard when there's two guards already? She would be a forward in this scenario, no?
I was at that game- and those slashers were killing us. I think it was Shea's idea to make that substitution- it was not Geno's. A minute longer and we may not win that game. We were going down in that game- no qst about it,I was at that game in Philly. Dolson was a young pup and got schooled accordingly.
Vowel guy- did you start martinis early today??? You lucky dog! If you think Napheesa Collier won't start and play a minimum of 38-40 minutes per game, like Nurse, Gabby and KLS - you've lost it!!!! There isn't even a qst as to the starting 4 of the 5- there is one spot left. And I think by Feb it will be CD. She has to mature quickly for us to have a shot the following season!!!!November
Nurse, Chong, KLS, Gabby, Butler
w/ Collier & CD
Ditto to Joe's post! I hope Saniya and Butler can become integral- I really do. My feeling is CD will start by Feb- for our Tmt run!Well, of course, it all depends on: (a) injuries; (b) what the freshmen show in practice; (c) what the veterans show in practice.
But my guess with all of those caveats is that Natalie will NOT start, and that one of the triumvirate of [Saniya / Crystal / Molly] will. Most likely that would be Saniya. In other words, Geno will decide to go smaller and faster, somewhat like the Georgetown team of a few years ago that made it to the Sweet 16 (where they lost a very close game to UConn who had Stef and Maya). That Georgetown team didn't have a player over 6-0, but Geno only won the game when he took Stef out and put in Lorin Dixon to have a team that could match Georgetown's pace.
And yes, that does mean that Lou and Napheesa would be playing in the paint on defense next year.
In the year just ended, South Florida had quite a successful season without any post player nearly as effective as either Lou or Napheesa would be in that role.
I got a lot of grief for saying this last month, but what the heck, any excuse for a martini:Vowel guy- did you start martinis early today??? You lucky dog! If you think Napheesa Collier won't start and play a minimum of 38-40 minutes per game, like Nurse, Gabby and KLS - you've lost it!!!! There isn't even a qst as to the starting 4 of the 5- there is one spot left. And I think by Feb it will be CD. She has to mature quickly for us to have a shot the following season!!!!
Vowel guy- did you start martinis early today??? You lucky dog! If you think Napheesa Collier won't start and play a minimum of 38-40 minutes per game, like Nurse, Gabby and KLS - you've lost it!!!! There isn't even a qst as to the starting 4 of the 5- there is one spot left. And I think by Feb it will be CD. She has to mature quickly for us to have a shot the following season!!!!
Not sure how anyone could not see the talent, instinct, determination and athleticism in that young lady. She is prolific! Next year she'll be stronger and with even more confidence!!!! Boom chuka Lukah!!!!I got a lot of grief for saying this last month, but what the heck, any excuse for a martini:
Barring injury, Napheesa will start every game for the next 3 years.
You may be right. And I know Geno likes a burst off the bench. But these are desperate times- which call for desperate measures. He'll have to play his best athletes and we don't have the luxury of having a Gabby or Napheesa off the bench next year. So to your point- Butler or Saniya prob start the season- with Danger being the spark off the bench.Collier may be my favorite player on the team so there's no disrespect in my statement. Nor is starting perfectly correlated with playing time.
Was just a guess, and wanted to go slightly against the grain.
My thought was that Geno might want to try Butler in a Dolson-type role. If that works, then he can bring Pheesa off the bench for a burst of energy.
Collier will get her minutes either way.
197 days 1 hour 22 minutes
Looks about right, with Gabby and KLS doing the occassional flip clop.Now that tax day has come and gone, we can officially start the debate regarding next Season's Starters.
The usual caveats apply such as baring injury and to be clear we are talking about the 1st regular season game only.
Starters:
G Kia Nurse
G Katie Lou Samuelson
F Napheesa Collier
F Gabby Williams
C Natalie Butler
That's my starting lineup too. Except for the dilemma of when/if Dangerfield can no longer be kept on the bench, who does she replace in the starting lineup?
If it's Butler, then you have to change the whole offense. I don't see her replacing any of the others. If freshman Dangerfield is strictly a sub at PG, then I don't see Nurse ever sitting long enough for her to get many minutes. I guess subbing for both Nurse at PG and KLS (with Nurse sliding over to the 2) could give her a few minutes at PG. There are no seniors in this scheme, so same issue the following year. So maybe Butler never starts?
An interesting observation Kicker. It does provide some food for thought.![]()
Wait a sec...CD has eligibility left?!?!?November
Nurse, Chong, KLS, Gabby, Butler
w/ Collier & CD
Now that tax day has come and gone, we can officially start the debate regarding next Season's Starters.
The usual caveats apply such as baring injury and to be clear we are talking about the 1st regular season game only.
Starte
G Kia Nurse
G Katie Lou Samuelson
F Napheesa Collier
F Gabby Williams
C Natalie Butler
Who is Tommy?The discussion on these two points is futile:
My ideas, all things remaining equal:
- There is no requirement for G-G-F-F-C, or any such designations. Geno doesn't work that way. Paraphrasing him, if a kid is a 3, and he needs a 4 in the game and sees her on the bench, she doesn't play. It just doesn't work in his system.
- KLS is a guard. Height is immaterial; Magic was one of the best PGs in history at 6'9". She has a guard's game.
First game:
Situationally off the bench: Butler or Dangerfield
- Tommy
- Nurse
- KLS
- Gabbulous
- Pheese
6th man: Irwin
Last game:
Situationally off the bench: Tommy/Dangerfield, Pheese/Butler
- Tommy/Dangerfield (Situational Platoon)
- Nurse
- KLS
- Gabbulous
- Pheese/Butler (Situational Platoon)
6th man: Irwin
Very little change. Geno likes a Senior lead guard, so barring Dangerfield becoming the Next Coming of Cousey during the season, the job is Tommy's to lose. I don't see Butler totally displacing Pheese (or visa-versa), but there will be situations where the bigger body will be needed more, and Pheese will platoon with Gabby or give Butler a breather.
There aren't many lineups in WCBB that are better than this one. Every player could start for every other team, and be a superstar on 99% of them. I don't get the doom-and-gloom; we will be VERY competitive next season.
Who is Tommy?
No way is KLS a natural guard. And playing her as one of two guards will hurt us. We need post presence ala Stewie and rebounding ability from her next year.The discussion on these two points is futile:
My ideas, all things remaining equal:
- There is no requirement for G-G-F-F-C, or any such designations. Geno doesn't work that way. Paraphrasing him, if a kid is a 3, and he needs a 4 in the game and sees her on the bench, she doesn't play. It just doesn't work in his system.
- KLS is a guard. Height is immaterial; Magic was one of the best PGs in history at 6'9". She has a guard's game.
First game:
Situationally off the bench: Butler or Dangerfield
- Tommy
- Nurse
- KLS
- Gabbulous
- Pheese
6th man: Irwin
Last game:
Situationally off the bench: Tommy/Dangerfield, Pheese/Butler
- Tommy/Dangerfield (Situational Platoon)
- Nurse
- KLS
- Gabbulous
- Pheese/Butler (Situational Platoon)
6th man: Irwin
Very little change. Geno likes a Senior lead guard, so barring Dangerfield becoming the Next Coming of Cousey during the season, the job is Tommy's to lose. I don't see Butler totally displacing Pheese (or visa-versa), but there will be situations where the bigger body will be needed more, and Pheese will platoon with Gabby or give Butler a breather.
There aren't many lineups in WCBB that are better than this one. Every player could start for every other team, and be a superstar on 99% of them. I don't get the doom-and-gloom; we will be VERY competitive next season.
I totally agree that, unless Butler has a complete transformation, she will not start. Maybe against the nothing teams, but not against the good ones. She is not as good as as Heather Buck, and Heather was a "garbage minutes " player. Though a delightful human being, deserving of all our respect.Well, of course, it all depends on: (a) injuries; (b) what the freshmen show in practice; (c) what the veterans show in practice.
But my guess with all of those caveats is that Natalie will NOT start, and that one of the triumvirate of [Saniya / Crystal / Molly] will. Most likely that would be Saniya. In other words, Geno will decide to go smaller and faster, somewhat like the Georgetown team of a few years ago that made it to the Sweet 16 (where they lost a very close game to UConn who had Stef and Maya). That Georgetown team didn't have a player over 6-0, but Geno only won the game when he took Stef out and put in Lorin Dixon to have a team that could match Georgetown's pace.
And yes, that does mean that Lou and Napheesa would be playing in the paint on defense next year.
In the year just ended, South Florida had quite a successful season without any post player nearly as effective as either Lou or Napheesa would be in that role.
If that is a straight-forward question, I'll give what I think is as straight an answer as I can give you, given the person in question.
Me thinks Tommy on UConn Bball is Saniya Chong, but the Tommy being cross-referenced is none other than
Tommy Chong, of "Cheech and Chong," who just passed away in December. If we've forgotten the man and/or his act, here are some highlights from their "Up in Smoke" feature, which followed "Reefer Madness"in a double bill at the Engineering Auditorium at Notre Dame in winter of 1974 (I think)
BTW, I agree with your initial starting lineup and also agree with the point that Butler's biggest challenge will be to stay out of foul trouble, an issue we have with Coco Nelson when she comes into spell Brianna Turner.