If KK & Ash are starting next year, then I think we will not win a championship. Neither one of them can shoot very well. They are very good defenders but offensively weak.… I know that I am in a minority but start K9. She has more natural & better instincts at the point guard than KK.
I see this a little differently.
I think it is unfair to call KK offensively weak. She is a natural true point guard, not a score-first point guard like Hannah Hidalgo, and she is excellent in that role. She finished the season with 174 assists and just 43 turnovers, a 4.05 assist-turnover ratio, which was the second-best mark in Division I and the best single-season mark in UConn history. In the Elite Eight against Hidalgo, the National Defensive Player of the Year, she played 31 minutes and had zero turnovers.
She is not an elite scorer, and that is fair to say, but offense is about more than individual scoring. Facilitating, organizing, and making the right reads are a huge part of offense, too. In my opinion, when you factor all of that in, KK and Sarah are UConn’s best returning offensive players. Bart Torvik’s numbers reflect that too, with KK ranked seventh nationally in Offensive Rating and Sarah 12th, though Sarah carries a higher usage rate.
And I love Kayleigh, so this is not a knock on her at all, but I do not really agree that she has more natural point-guard instincts than KK. Looking at their per-40 numbers, Kayleigh scores 3.3 more points, but KK gives you 1.6 more assists, 0.5 fewer turnovers, 1.4 more steals, and 0.9 fewer fouls. Kayleigh’s Offensive Rating is 53rd, which is still very good, but it does not support the idea that KK is somehow lacking offensively.
To me, Geno used both of them exactly the right way: start KK as the steadier organizer, the better pure table-setter, and the safer low-mistake option to open games, then use Kayleigh a lot as a change-of-pace guard who is disruptive, fast, aggressive, and capable of changing the game with her energy.