Clearly it depends who they are...
Maybe true freshman can play QB.
Stars matter for programs that can get 4* and 5* guys. They're meaningless to a program like ours simply because we will never sign them. There are so many football players that all of them can't possibly be evaluatedIt matters who you put around them. When you have a 4 & 5 Star O Line to go with 4 & 5 Star skill players they can not only play, they can exceed expectations. Those who want to argue that stars don't matter are watching a different game than the rest of us. Stars 100% matter. When you add elite coaching to the mix you get Alabama. People don't need to like this for it to be true.