I think the tag line for this week’s win comes down to this: we caught a big break in that Rice had to play without its starting QB, and Rice caught a big break that we were able to play with ours. Is that harsh on Evers? Well, yes for being trite. But against a lousy G-5 team, he went 9 for 24 throwing (37.5%), for a mere 128 yards (just over 5 yards a throw), with a pick, and 11 carries for minus three yards. Is JF a cure for cancer? Absolutely not. But it boggled my mind we didn’t make a change at halftime, even knowing how clear Mora is in his own mind that Evers is the clear #1. Whether you blamed it on Evers or not, the offense was so unbelievably pitiful (more on that in a moment) that is was shocking to me we didn’t do something. (In fairness to Mora, his goal is to win football games and we did. But sheesh. The first half of that game was as unwatchable a competitive football game as I think I’ve ever seen. No criticism from me for anyone who bailed. To me, the story that our QB play was that unbelievably bad is the lead — not that we managed a 7 point win that came down to the end against a really bad team, playing without its QB, at home. (Please don’t think that means I don’t care that we won — I was there through the last attempt at a pass and 30 laterals.)
O.K., let’s get to the day and game in more detail. One thing I learned is that controlling a tailgate with 11 people is far more than 3 times the work as doing my normal work for 2-4. Everyone wants to help, damn them. We didn’t get out of the parking lot until the game was already 15 minutes underway, and it wasn’t until I unpacked the car last night that I had any idea whether anything that was supposed to come back home with me did. Luckily, being 15 minutes late meant I missed absolutely nothing except seeing an extra 15 minutes of unwatchable football.
I’m sure the Defense caught a break with their QB being out, but you can’t be more dominant than they were. Less than 200 yards of total offense allowed, 2/17 on combined third and fourth downs and a shutout but for the offense giving the ball away in FG range and a special teams TD. Price Yates played most of the game and had a large impact. He started playing for Barton but finished playing for Gourdine, who I assume got hurt at some point. Tui and McDonald were outstanding, as always. Chadwick and Jordan Wright both played corner, sending Malcolm Bell back to the bench (after a number of games here he filled in more than adequately). Just a great team performance up and down the lineup.
Not a good game for special team. Yes, the wind was a huge factor but we lose yardage every week in the punting game. The KR return TD we gave up followed about a 50 yard return on the kick before. (By the way, on both of those we kicked into the wind and to Freeman’s credit the kicks reached the goal line). Freeman had another really good game, missing the 53 or so yarder notwithstanding (on a day that was so windy, even with the wind at his back that was a low percentage attempt). Sheffield did a very good job in the wind deciding which punts to try to get to and which not to, and getting some return yards.
The offense was beyond pitiful the first half — we would not have scored on Merrimack the way we played in the first half — and but for two huge individual efforts was only slightly better in the second. But Durrell Robinson turning what should have been a 6-8 yard gain into a 68 yard TD, and then Skyler Bell catching the heave into the wind into the red zone, which was a spectacular play that reflected on the pass not at all (other than credit for someone giving him a chance to make a play for the first time in weeks), was enough to win. Barely. I talked about the QB above, and won’t do so again, but we went for a fifth straight half unable to run the ball a lick. And then, even beyond the one that Robinson broke, the second half was a bit better. But if we’re going to get to 8-4 we have to be better than we were yesterday.
So there we are. 5-3, with nowhere near a halfway decent win to our name, but 5-3 nonetheless. The way we are playing offense winning in Southern Ontario is a pipe dream, but we’ll be favored in the other 3 and should be able to win. Of course, that requires winning twice on the road, where I’m not sure that we’ve won more than twice combined in 5 years or so, but UMass and UAB are both terrible football teams. But get it done, and find a bowl stuck with taking us, and being 8-4 with a chance to beat at least a decent G-5 team in a bowl game is more than most of us would have asked for at the beginning of the season. Certainly more than I would have asked for. Despite knowing how far we have to go, and not being sure being an independent with de minimus TV money leaves us much of.a chance of getting there. But doing what we can requires being ready on Friday night to get to 5-1 on this bizarre six game homestand, and 6-1 at home for the year.