UConn had several marks against it that all conspired at various times to thwart a move. As a partner with Rutgers, it would have made sense if the B10 had looked at y’all. But I think Delaney had eyes for Tobacco Road and thought Maryland was a better tool to forcing the ACC to open. He gambled and lost.
The Syracuse/Pittsburgh move by the ACC was likely where BC could have roused anti-UConn feelings over the lawsuit. Subbing in Pitt for UConn to not make waves seemed acceptable.
That addition of course opened up Clemson and FSU being able to claim Tobacco Road was too basketball-centric. So with the next expansion of one, they hijacked the process and forced Louisville over UConn despite UConn making more sense. Louisville is one of the great college-crazed metros in the country, and they were willing to open up their wallets to make a good product.
And that gets to the heart of the matter. UConn made the Fiesta Bowl in 2011. But if you asked a normal college fan about that game, and they’ll remember one thing. That UConn sold almost none of their allotted tickets. UConn wasn’t the first or last school to not sell enough, and the storyline is often trotted out when football heavyweights play nouvea-riche. It’s an easy story to write and confirms biases that some programs are better than others. UConn had the misfortune of doing it the same year as realignment hit overdrive. So the last thought many people had of UConn football wasn’t that they made a BCS bowl, but that the fanbase wasn’t there even when they did.
So yes, on some level, moving football to independent status to save basketball while earning less in conference money does have a way of reinforcing the point that UConn is not serious about college football. It may have been the prudent financial move, I don’t know. But sports fans just say “oh, well that makes sense they sacrifice football for basketball.” Its not fair, I mean Wake Forest and Vandy are just kinda grandfathered in without anyone paying much mind. But UConn on the outside had a higher bar to hit. And others just hit it higher.