The Boneyard Greatest Movie of All-Time Tournament Stat Dump and Bracket Reveal

[Mano]

Greatest Movie of All-Time Tournament

The raw data: Boneyard Best Movie of All-Time Tournament
​

Total Entries: 91

Total Movies: 445
​

Top 100 vote getters.

1) The Shawshank Redemption (390pts)
2) Goodfellas (298pts)
3) The Godfather (270pts)
4) Pulp Fiction (166pts)
5) Rocky (155pts)
6) The Dark Knight (151pts)
7) Jaws (140pts)
8) Casablanca (138pts)
9) Die Hard (132pts)
10) Forrest Gump (123pts)
11) Saving Private Ryan (123pts)
12) Caddyshack (120pts)
13) The Godfather: Part II (118pts)
14) The Big Lebowski (115pts)
15) The Silence of the Lambs (113)
16) The Matrix (110pts)
17) It’s a Wonderful Life (109pts)
18) Gladiator (102pts)
19) The Departed (101pts)
20) Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back (98pts)
21) My Cousin Vinny (93pts)
22) Raiders of the Lost Ark (88pts)
23) Hoosiers (85pts)
24) The Wizard of Oz (82pts)
25) Unforgiven (79pts)
26) Animal House (77pts)
27) One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (76pts)
28) To Kill a Mockingbird (73pts)
29) The Deer Hunter (68pts)
30) Blazing Saddles (65pts)
31) Schindler’s List (65pts)
32) Dazed and Confused (63pts)
33) A Few Good Men (62pts)
34) Back to the Future (62pts)
35) The Great Escape (61pts)
36) Monty Python and the Holy Grail (61pts)
37) Field of Dreams (58pts)
38) Heat (58pts)
39) The Blues Brothers (55pts)
40) Children of Men (55pts)
41) Fight Club (55pts)
42) Ferris Bueller’s Day Off (54pts)
43) Full Metal Jacket (54pts)
44) Apocalypse Now (52pts)
45) The Graduate (51pts)
46) Step Brothers (51pts)
47) There’s Something About Mary (51pts)
48) Alien (50pts)
49) Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope (50pts)
50) Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (49pts)
51) The Shining (49pts)
52) The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (48pts)
53) Good Will Hunting (48pts)
54) Old School (48pts)
55) No Country for Old Men (47pts)
56) Cool Hand Luke (44pts)
57) The Princess Bride (44pts)
58) The Usual Suspects (43pts)
59) Dumb and Dumber (42pts)
60) Man on Fire (42pts)
61) Chinatown (41pts)
62) Inception (41pts)
63) Terminator 2: Judgment Day (41pts)
64) Top Gun (41pts)

First Four Out:

65) Apollo 13 (40pts)
66) The Sting (40pts)
67) The Breakfast Club (39pts)
68) 2001: A Space Odyssey (38pts)

Next Four Out:

69) 12 Angry Men (37pts)
70) Braveheart (37pts)
71) Casino (36pts)
72) Happy Gilmore (36pts)

The Rest of the Top 100:

73) Superbad (36pts)
74) Bill Madison (35pts)
75) Platoon (35pts)
76) Slap Shot (34pts)
77) Aliens (33pts)
78) North by Northwest (33pts)
79) Office Space (33pts)
80) Almost Famours (32pts)
81) Avengers: Infinity War (31pts)
82) Coming to America (31pts)
83) Remember the Titans (31pts)
84) Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story (30pts)
85) He Got Game (30pts)
86) True Grit (30pts)
87) Young Frankenstein (30pts)
88) Rear Window (29pts)
89) Scarface (29pts)
90) Shooter (29pts)
91) Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (28pts)
92) Boogie Nights (27pts)
93) Diner (27pts)
94) Miracle (27pts)
95) Pineapple Express (27pts)
96) Reservoir Dogs (27pts)
97) Stripes (27pts)
98) Interstellar (26pts)
99) Fargo (25pts)
100) The Prestige (25pts)

By Decade: (I just eyeballed this, so its short of the total number, whatevs)

1930’s:

10

1940’s:

14

1950’s:

15

1960’s:

29

1970’s:

51

1980’s:

84

1990’s:

102

2000’s:

88

2010’s:

42

The Bracket:

 

[Doctor Hoop]

Sweet list.

 

[jayteeman]

Final - Godfather I plants a kiss of death on Godfather II

 

[auror]

Hey we did alright.

Except:

Next Four Out:

69) 12 Angry Men (37pts)

We screwed this one up fam.

 

[FriarJ]

Wow, that is a lot of work. The one that I'm most shocked about is not a single vote for The Right Stuff.

 

[Hans Sprungfeld]

The 1-16 matchup between Pulp Fiction and Chinatown is a double feature/challenge that everybody should take.

Added: Long live Los Angeles!

 

[ClifSpliffy]

whoa, noice. kudos dude.
total sausage fest. still, noice. gracias.

 

[OkaForPrez]

Classic cartel bracket forming here pitting Belushi against Belushi.

 

[OkaForPrez]

Also, I watch searching for Bobby Fischer once every few years. The older I get, the more a masterpiece it becomes. Think it might be the most underrated movie of all time.

 

[ClifSpliffy]

fight club vs. wizard of oz? gettin naaaaaasty up in here. daaang.

 

[CL82]

Well done!

There are some interesting match ups. Casablanca vs. The Princess Bride, My Cousin Vinny vs. Apocalypse Now... and my favorite Animal House vs. Blues Brothers.

 

[uconndoit]

 

[uconndoit]

 

[Minicoop69]

View attachment 41127

It's not available for purchase. That stinks

 

[Mano]

fight club vs. wizard of oz? gettin naaaaaasty up in here. daaang.

As far as 1st round upsets go, that one seems like a shoo-in. I don’t think Hoosiers should feel safe going up against Ferris. Or maybe the biggest potential upset, Jaws up against The Usual Suspects (we’ll see what the Kevin Spacey effect might be). Curious to see how The Matrix fairs against original flavor Star Wars. Pulling for Heat (my favorite movie) against Cuckoo’s Nest. I think The Shining has a chance against the Dude too.

 

[Robertelamin]

So what your saying is the 8 movies from the Fast and the Furious franchise that I submitted are in the Boneyard NIT?

 

[Mano]

So what your saying is the 8 movies from the Fast and the Furious franchise that I submitted are in the Boneyard NIT?

Yes, along with the list of exclusively pornos that someone submitted. It’s a good thing I actually know you, I would’ve felt some guilt discounting that list otherwise.

Look for my NIT bracket coming soon: FF series VS .

 

[storrsroars]

Hey we did alright.

Except:



We screwed this one up fam.

On a list of "greatest movies all time" that includes Step Brothers, Old School and Anchorman, that's what upsets you?

 

[tzznandrew]

Forrest Gump at 10? Ugh. Shouldn't be near a greatest movie list.

And here I thought my suggestion of "Catwoman," "Nukie" "Superbabies," and the like was bad.

 

[HuskyBoi]

inglorious basterds

 

[Mano]

Forrest Gump at 10? Ugh. Shouldn't be near a greatest movie list.

And here I thought my suggestion of "Catwoman," "Nukie" "Superbabies," and the like was bad.

Ah, so you’re the huckster. Was wondering who put that list in lol.

 

[Dogdeacon]

Great job, impressed with the work compiling all the results and looking forward to the voting.

These were lists of people's favorite movies, maybe "the greatest movie, in my opinion".
Shawshank is illustrative, it is definitely one of my favorites, but its not great like the Godfather is or Jaws or Apocalypse Now. It is all subjective of course, for example because I like them so much I think Unforgiven and Rocky are great movies, but true cinema-files likely disagree. And I 'm not saying this should be a classics standoff where Casablanca must compete with Citizen Kane.

It might have been accidental, but I think it great that the movies aren't categorized and broken up into dramas, comedies etc.. This makes the choices tougher and more interesting my toughest:
Die Hard vs Cool Hand Luke - I can't pick
Caddyshack vs. Good Will - two favorites in different ways, leaning Caddy
Schindler vs Back to Future - bad draw for Marty McFly
Silence of Lambs vs Anchorman - Silence should win but if there were a comedy region Anchorman is sweet 16
Gladiator vs Something About Mary - the latter was so enjoyably funny at time but doesn't hold up
Jaws vs Usual Suspects - should be no-brainer but Usual has very loyal fans
Big Lebowski vs Shining - loyal fans will likely crush possible greatest horror movie ever
Raiders vs Full Metal - can't pick, first half of full metal is so good

 

[auror]

On a list of "greatest movies all time" that includes Step Brothers, Old School and Anchorman, that's what upsets you?

Yes, I'm upset that Step Brothers, et al made it in over 12 Angry Men. That was my point.

But not about Anchorman. That was on my list. True classic. It's kind of a big deal.

 

[CL82]

@Mano so how's this going to work? Do a series of polls each day for a region?

 

[storrsroars]

Yes, I'm upset that Step Brothers, et al made it in over 12 Angry Men. That was my point.

But not about Anchorman. That was on my list. True classic. It's kind of a big deal.

Looking at that list and comparing it with what I already know about the BY, I'm coming to the conclusion that Will Ferrell is the Arby's of comedy.

 

[Mano]

@Mano so how's this going to work? Do a series of polls each day for a region?

Yea, starting tonight, going to do the first round of each region per day. So on and so forth.

 

[Mano]

Great job, impressed with the work compiling all the results and looking forward to the voting.

These were lists of people's favorite movies, maybe "the greatest movie, in my opinion".
Shawshank is illustrative, it is definitely one of my favorites, but its not great like the Godfather is or Jaws or Apocalypse Now. It is all subjective of course, for example because I like them so much I think Unforgiven and Rocky are great movies, but true cinema-files likely disagree. And I 'm not saying this should be a classics standoff where Casablanca must compete with Citizen Kane.

It might have been accidental, but I think it great that the movies aren't categorized and broken up into dramas, comedies etc.. This makes the choices tougher and more interesting my toughest:
Die Hard vs Cool Hand Luke - I can't pick
Caddyshack vs. Good Will - two favorites in different ways, leaning Caddy
Schindler vs Back to Future - bad draw for Marty McFly
Silence of Lambs vs Anchorman - Silence should win but if there were a comedy region Anchorman is sweet 16
Gladiator vs Something About Mary - the latter was so enjoyably funny at time but doesn't hold up
Jaws vs Usual Suspects - should be no-brainer but Usual has very loyal fans
Big Lebowski vs Shining - loyal fans will likely crush possible greatest horror movie ever
Raiders vs Full Metal - can't pick, first half of full metal is so good

Thanks. Yea I thought for a second about making the regions genre specific but it would have made for some really top heavy regions and a relatively weak comedy/musical one. I love a good comedy, but I’m a bit elitist when it comes to best of all time. Personally they don’t come close to my top 10. I had 40 Year Old Virgin at 16.