I think many thought Ollie would have sizable learning curve coming into Uconn. Winning the NC was a HUGE bonus and I think maybe set Ollie up for higher expectations from us fans. Especially the way in which he coached some of those games and put the right lineups on the court and seemed to outmatch the likes of Izzo and Calipari. Not taking that away from Ollie, but those were Calhoun's players and very much a Calhoun system. What we've seen since is a struggle by Ollie's program to field a complete team. Whether it's injuries, transfers, or lack of development this has been a huge issue as of late and created big holes in the line-up. It's also part of what being a coach entails and it's where Ollie has struggled.
Yes, it took Calhoun 13 seasons before getting his first NC. But it was a positive ride the entire way and I think as we fans loved it. And in many cases spoiled by it. Yes, there were some devastating blows along the way but anyone could see the trend and it was exciting. Right or wrong, Ollie is taking over at the absolute pinnacle. Maintaining that level is awfully difficult for any coach, let alone one that is relatively new with little coaching experience.
I like Ollie as coach. I like that he is a former Uconn player and extends the Uconn family. I want him to succeed in this role as I think that is a great storyline and would be great for both Uconn and Ollie. BUT, from what I'm seeing, I don't think Ollie is going to get us there anytime soon.
The only reason I think our conference affiliation hurts us in this matter is we no longer have the opportunity to languish with an under-performing coach. If we were in the ACC or BIG, Ollie might have a longer leash. We are now in a game of musical chairs, so to speak and when the next round of realignment happens, we need to be in the best shape possible. I think 5-6 seasons is long enough to develop a trend with which you can say it's working or it's not. Unless Ollie shows an uptick this year (and it needs to be more than a positive record)
like beating a ranked team, going on a long winni streak, or or making the NCAA's I think it's time for a change.
Turning this into a conference affiliation debate is a red herring.