- Joined
- Apr 25, 2014
- Messages
- 5,290
- Reaction Score
- 19,770
I always thought Chauncey billups was the best player on that team. Hell, billups actually turned Carmelo into a winner for a few seasons with Denver. Loved rip on that team though. Def second best.
In the playoffs, Rip led the team in PER (19.6), though Billups and Ben Wallace edged him out in win shares. That was a very balanced team, so it's difficult to pick a "best player," but Rip was the leading scorer, so he's definitely in the conversation.
That being said, Ray has been a much better NBA player than Rip was. More prolific AND more efficient scorer, Ray kills Rip in all of the advanced metrics: PER (18.6 to 16.5), WS (145.1[!] to 62.8), ORTG (114 to 105), etc. I love Rip, but Ray is definitely top-10, and maybe top-5 all time at shooting guard. I'm not sure that Rip was, even at his best, a top 5 SG. If you look at his best 5 season stretch (statistically, 03-04 through 07-08), he'd have to rank behind Kobe, Ray, Iverson, Carter, Wade, and Ginobili. In Ray's best season (statistically, 2000-01), he rated as the best SG in the game, with only Shaq and Dirk rating as more valuable. Looking at Ray's best 5-year stretch (this is a little harder because Rip's 5 best seasons were in 5 consecutive years, while Ray's best seasons were spread out, but whatever I'm going with 2000-01 to 2004-05), he rated as the 2nd best SG in the NBA over that stretch, behind only Kobe, who is, at worst, third-best all-time (but probably second).
So, a lot of nerdery there, I apologize. The point is that, while Rip was a great pro, I don't think he was ever on Ray's level.