I would 1995-96 was maybe #1, then 98-99, 2005-06, 2003-04, and then 2010-11.
Those were the only 5 years I went into the season thinking anything less then a title was a disappointment. So 2 of the teams met my lofty expectations and three did not.
Going into the 96 and 06 tourneys there was not a doubt in mind we would be cutting the nets down
How can anyone say that about 2006? We lost a 1-8 game to Cuse in the BET after limping into the postseason with a few soft wins in a row. I had doubts that we would get out of the first weekend.
There was never a point I had any confidence in that team. We jumped out to a 17-0 lead on a 7-24 South Florida team in the last week of the regular season, and I told myself, "this isn't over, we'll find a way to piss this away." Sure enough, USF cut it to one midway through the second half, before we won by 10. We followed that up by being tied in the final minute at home with a sub-.500 Louisville team (up 3, give up easy dribble penetration, leave guy open for a kickout, tying 3 - something we were really good at allowing). I genuinely feared the Albany game, since they had a 20 ppg guy at the two, and we couldn't defend two guards.
We did put it all together for a nice home win over Nova, and a game against Seton Hall that we won by 30, but that was it for "a" game department. Maybe one of the regular season games against Cuse too. In 1999, perhaps we didn't destroy weaker teams as often as we should, but the Stanford game without Rip, the two St. John's games, the last two Cuse games, Michigan State, etc., were all evidence of what we could do when we were on. We were tasting it after the BET (once we got the SH game out of our system). In 2004, I think going in, we were worried about Emeka's health holding up, but were optimistic after Ben and Boone stepped up without him in the BET. It wasn't until the steamroller got going that we knew we might be on our way to the stepladder.
1996, I certainly had hope of a Final Four, but that was Kentucky's best team under Pitino that won it and they were prohibitive favorites. After the first weekend, I just wanted to get through and hope to get Ricky back at the Final Four and give it our best shot.