Don't think there is a debate - any of the main All-American teams does it - it is just the WBCA 10 person first team is easier to get onto than the 5 player first teams so it is the one most often cited, and the only one some players make. I think I remember one year a player made a 5 person team, but not the 10 person WBCA team - don't remember who or whether it was even a Uconn player, but it did stand out.
ucmiami, good memory. The records show that making one of these two First Teams but not the other does, indeed, happen every once in a while - probably more often than most fans would guess.
Here's that happenstance going back to 1994-95 (the first year of AP WBB All-American teams. The WBCA has been producing their 10-person AA teams since 1975):
Making the AP First Team but not making WBCA First Team. Happened eight times in the past 30 years:
2020 - Rhyne Howard, Kentucky
2017 -
Briana Jones, Maryland
2016 -
Rachel Banham, Minnesota
2011 -
Jeanette Pohlen, Stanford
2000 - Ruth Riley, Notre Dame
1999 - Dominique Canty, Alabama
1996 - Latasha Byears, DePaul
1996 - Kara Wolters, UConn
Bold font indicates this is the only time they made any AP AA team during their college careers.
(Additionally, there have been 42 occurrences of AP Second Team players not making the WCBA First Team. The most recent are TaNiya Latson (LSU) and Olivia Miles (Notre Dame) last year.)
Here's the flip-side of this dynamic - making the 10 player WCBA First Team, but not making
ANY of the AP AA Teams that year (i.e., not making First Team, Second Team or Third Team). As one can see, it happened 13 times in the past 30 years:
2024 - Aaliyah Edwards, UConn
2017 - Kalani Brown, Baylor
2016 -
Courtney Williams, South Florida
2012 - Bria Hartley, UConn
2012 -
Glory Johnson, Tennessee
2004 - Janel McCarville, Minnesota
2003 -
Iciss Tillis, Duke
2000 - LaToya Thomas, Mississippi St
1999 - Kelly Miller, Georgia
1998 -
Allison Feaster, Harvard
1998 -
Chasity Melvin, NC State
1997 -
Tajama Abraham, George Washington
1995 -
Stacey Lovelace, Purdue
Italicized font indicates that they never made any other WCBA or AP AA team during their college careers.
Good stuff. Congrats to all First Team AAs!