jbdphi
Aussie Aussie Aussie!
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 1,514
- Reaction Score
- 2,954
No discussion of dog sounds, post game press conferences or tailgating complaints - just sticking to the football. I'm sure BL will do a better job of summarizing in fewer words.
Offensive Line:
- Had a much worse game today than they did against BYU in my opinion overall against what I would think was inferior talent.
- Didn't sustain blocks and made a lot of bad reads at the line letting guys come in unblocked to make plays, especially on the edges.
- Only one False Start but against an FCS team I would have hoped that we would get far better push here.
Tight Ends:
- Bad game for McQuillan - gave up on one deep pass play which he could have caught and let another ball go right off his hands and I'm assuming he didn't do much special on blocking either
- Didn't notice Bloom or Myers out there? I'm sure they played but I didn't see a target anything else notable
Running Back:
- Didn't help the OL or the QB with their blitz pickup - I saw Max completely miss one assignment which lead to a sack and another complete miss by Walsh which led to another negative play.
- Newsome had one great run but also had a few right into the line for no gain or loss - similar to last week's observation by BL, it seemed like the guys had the wrong cleats on? A lot of slipping and sliding out there.
- Overall forgettable performance by a unit that I thought would be pretty exciting given they were all outrushed by the QB (who isn't a runner).
- Our two big non-QB rushes of the day came on what I thought were delayed runs / draws - maybe we should have tried that a few more times?
Quarterback:
- Obviously not a good game for CW in terms of accuracy - had at least three bad overthrows on deep balls that showed very little touch / didn't put any air underneath the balls and also missed a few intermediate routes
- He did have a few real nice ones though - his first completion of the game to Davis was an incredible throw, the TD was also a nice ball and he had a few other good intermediate balls to Davis - completed two screens as well
- There were some positives though and Jim Fuller said it well - "The good news about Whitmer is he did not take unnecessary sacks or force throws into double coverage which is something he has been known to do. It is obvious that he has been instructed to tuck the ball and go if the protection is breaking down."
- One other thing I noticed is that CW did step up into the pocket several times and sometimes got a decent result out of it. He didn't get happy feet, run backwards and take a horrible sack (almost did in the first quarter but threw the ball away).
Wide Receivers:
- Davis was great and did what I would hope all of our players could do against an FCS team- got open, made catches and moved the sticks
- No other WR did anything good that I could see - Abrams came so close to making a great catch at the end of the 1st half. He did a great job of moving to the ball and getting his hands out there but couldn't reel it in. I still have hope for him.
Defensive Line:
- Far improved game as compared to BYU in my opinion (which has a lot to do with T Hill and BYU's OL).
- Campenni and Myers were both really good in the middle, disrupting all sorts of action.
- The ends made some plays as well but the stars were in the middle.
- Frank had at least two or three where he was unabated to the QB and wasn't able to finish and he needs to take advantage of those situations in the future.
Linebackers:
- A better game as well (once again, T Hill wasn't running the ball).
- A few bad pursuit angles taken on scrambles / running plays would be exploited by a better team
- Junior Joseph is making a case for more time and Vann had a good game statistically with 2 TFL's
Defensive Backs:
- I thought Obi had another pretty bad game - he seemed to be involved in most of the positive yardage plays given up - I know he has the height and the supposed speed but I'm not seeing it.
- Adams played pretty well and supported the run.
- Big completion given up by Jones should have been reversed in my opinion - Jones also got badly juked on one run but overall not too many complaints on the CBs.
Special Teams:
- This is where the game was won which is a bit sad but at least we won. Puyol kicked well and I don't put a block XP on the kicker but rather on the OL. Had a few KO's through the end zone - he's got a decent leg.
- Wain, called back shank aside, averaged almost 42 yards on 9 (yes 9) kicks of which 6 were inside the 20 - that's a pretty good game for a punter and while it isn't something to get too excited about for your team, it is an important positive
- Foxx had a great runback on the TD obviously (and had a lucky bounce to pick the ball up behind him) but also made some questionable decisions on other PR - calling a fair catch on one where he had a lot of room and not doing so when he was crowded. Our PR return team doesn't seem to do much blocking? The coverage team always seems to be unblocked and close to the returner on an average length punt.
- KO return thankfully didn't need much action and I noticed that Foxx was not there this week and Arkeel had one nice one. After Marriner got hurt they had Max back there with him?
- Kick coverage in general was decent - nothing to complain about and we definitely had better field position throughout the game.
A win is a win but this one was pretty tough to swallow. If our OL can't handle an FCS squad then I'm pretty worried how the rest of the year will go. I hope CC is healthy next week because I think he might have been able to make a few of those throws that CW missed but if he isn't, I'm fine continuing with CW. If you put Boyle behind that blocking I think you end up doing more damage to his development than positives which is what we saw last year.
Offensive Line:
- Had a much worse game today than they did against BYU in my opinion overall against what I would think was inferior talent.
- Didn't sustain blocks and made a lot of bad reads at the line letting guys come in unblocked to make plays, especially on the edges.
- Only one False Start but against an FCS team I would have hoped that we would get far better push here.
Tight Ends:
- Bad game for McQuillan - gave up on one deep pass play which he could have caught and let another ball go right off his hands and I'm assuming he didn't do much special on blocking either
- Didn't notice Bloom or Myers out there? I'm sure they played but I didn't see a target anything else notable
Running Back:
- Didn't help the OL or the QB with their blitz pickup - I saw Max completely miss one assignment which lead to a sack and another complete miss by Walsh which led to another negative play.
- Newsome had one great run but also had a few right into the line for no gain or loss - similar to last week's observation by BL, it seemed like the guys had the wrong cleats on? A lot of slipping and sliding out there.
- Overall forgettable performance by a unit that I thought would be pretty exciting given they were all outrushed by the QB (who isn't a runner).
- Our two big non-QB rushes of the day came on what I thought were delayed runs / draws - maybe we should have tried that a few more times?
Quarterback:
- Obviously not a good game for CW in terms of accuracy - had at least three bad overthrows on deep balls that showed very little touch / didn't put any air underneath the balls and also missed a few intermediate routes
- He did have a few real nice ones though - his first completion of the game to Davis was an incredible throw, the TD was also a nice ball and he had a few other good intermediate balls to Davis - completed two screens as well
- There were some positives though and Jim Fuller said it well - "The good news about Whitmer is he did not take unnecessary sacks or force throws into double coverage which is something he has been known to do. It is obvious that he has been instructed to tuck the ball and go if the protection is breaking down."
- One other thing I noticed is that CW did step up into the pocket several times and sometimes got a decent result out of it. He didn't get happy feet, run backwards and take a horrible sack (almost did in the first quarter but threw the ball away).
Wide Receivers:
- Davis was great and did what I would hope all of our players could do against an FCS team- got open, made catches and moved the sticks
- No other WR did anything good that I could see - Abrams came so close to making a great catch at the end of the 1st half. He did a great job of moving to the ball and getting his hands out there but couldn't reel it in. I still have hope for him.
Defensive Line:
- Far improved game as compared to BYU in my opinion (which has a lot to do with T Hill and BYU's OL).
- Campenni and Myers were both really good in the middle, disrupting all sorts of action.
- The ends made some plays as well but the stars were in the middle.
- Frank had at least two or three where he was unabated to the QB and wasn't able to finish and he needs to take advantage of those situations in the future.
Linebackers:
- A better game as well (once again, T Hill wasn't running the ball).
- A few bad pursuit angles taken on scrambles / running plays would be exploited by a better team
- Junior Joseph is making a case for more time and Vann had a good game statistically with 2 TFL's
Defensive Backs:
- I thought Obi had another pretty bad game - he seemed to be involved in most of the positive yardage plays given up - I know he has the height and the supposed speed but I'm not seeing it.
- Adams played pretty well and supported the run.
- Big completion given up by Jones should have been reversed in my opinion - Jones also got badly juked on one run but overall not too many complaints on the CBs.
Special Teams:
- This is where the game was won which is a bit sad but at least we won. Puyol kicked well and I don't put a block XP on the kicker but rather on the OL. Had a few KO's through the end zone - he's got a decent leg.
- Wain, called back shank aside, averaged almost 42 yards on 9 (yes 9) kicks of which 6 were inside the 20 - that's a pretty good game for a punter and while it isn't something to get too excited about for your team, it is an important positive
- Foxx had a great runback on the TD obviously (and had a lucky bounce to pick the ball up behind him) but also made some questionable decisions on other PR - calling a fair catch on one where he had a lot of room and not doing so when he was crowded. Our PR return team doesn't seem to do much blocking? The coverage team always seems to be unblocked and close to the returner on an average length punt.
- KO return thankfully didn't need much action and I noticed that Foxx was not there this week and Arkeel had one nice one. After Marriner got hurt they had Max back there with him?
- Kick coverage in general was decent - nothing to complain about and we definitely had better field position throughout the game.
A win is a win but this one was pretty tough to swallow. If our OL can't handle an FCS squad then I'm pretty worried how the rest of the year will go. I hope CC is healthy next week because I think he might have been able to make a few of those throws that CW missed but if he isn't, I'm fine continuing with CW. If you put Boyle behind that blocking I think you end up doing more damage to his development than positives which is what we saw last year.