He's made incredible strides with this team, but I'm not ready to anoint him our savior just yet.
Couple of things that have impressed me about HCBD:
He's continued our tradition of a dominant defense. I know this one is kind of a no kidding one, because he's got a strong defensive coaching pedigree, but it's important. Any time you transition at the head coach position you never know what you're going to get. Plenty of Offensive or defensive genius's have taken over as head coaches and that end of the ball has suffered inexplicably.
The offense is improving. I know that's a tough one to believe given last weekend in NOLA, but the offense is developing this year. We've got a true No. 1 QB and legitimate threats at the skill positions. He lost his starting center before the season even began and the O-Line is nearly all underclassmen. He's also working with a first-year offensive coordinator. Things are moving in the right direction here.
He's beating inferior competition at home and on the road. Nova, Army, UCF and Tulane. All teams we should be beating and we have taken care of them this year. You couldn't say that about the last two seasons. (USF I considered a toss-up and given their body of work thus far I would say they are about even with us talent-wise).
Couple of things that leave me wondering about HCBD:
His teams have been undisciplined at times during the year and it's cost us. Andrew Adams kicking the ball into the stands. BS's miserable clock management against USF. Costly personal fouls during the season. For all the talk of how tough HCBD, his disciplinarian chops seem to be lacking. You can excuse mistakes in execution on a young team, but you cannot excuse personal fouls and lapses in judgement.
He hasn't been able to close against tough teams. UConn had second-half leads against Mizzou and BYU. Especially in the Mizzou game with that fake FG play at the end, UConn had it's chances for a marquee win and they choked it away.
Overall the progress is outweighing the negatives in my opinion, but you measure success in winning seasons and bowl victories. So until we see some of those, I don't think you can say he's the man for the job so far.