well, we've expanded from songs directly aboot work on the water to songs aboot girls dancing the polka, so i'll widen it further to songs aboot being on the water. lol.
the Lakes are big water too.
one of my alltime favorites. living near the sub base and the Coast Guard will do that to ya.
nightmarishly haunting. great tune.
'does anyone know where the love of God goes,
when the waves turn the minutes to hours?'
that's a great explanation.But the song about the girls dancing the polka IS a sea shanty. Shanties aren't necessarily about working , they're songs FOR working. The rhythms are designed for specific tasks, probably half of them for pulling ropes. Fast ones like New York Girls for hand-over-hand pulls (light lines), slower ones like Spanish Ladies for two-handed rope pulls. The lyrics are often nonsense or about what they'll do on shore. The lyrics to New York Girls can be quite bawdy; Steeleye's version is heavily sanitized.
There's an album of sea shanties on YouTube called "Roast Beef of Old England" that has a great version of the shanty "Spanish Ladies." The song was partly sung by the sailors in "Master and Commander." Unfortunately II'm too computer illiterate to download it to the Boneyard. Sorry.
It's a real shame that they didn't follow up with one or more sequels to "Master and Commander" from the 20 books of the Aubrey-Maturin series by Patrick O'Brian. I read that Russell Crowe was more than eager to do another one. One of my all-time favorite movies. I rewatch it at least once a year.Don Sineti, who I mentioned before is a staff chantey man at Mystic Seaport and a regular performer at its Sea Music Festival, served as a consultant on the film Master and Commander", where they requested his input on the traditional songs used in the film.
For me, the song that's fits this description is this: ( Seagulls and all!)Don't know if it's a sea shanty, but to me the song that's most evocative of the sea is Procol Harem's "A Salty Dog." With the seagulls squawking, you can almost smell low tide!!!
Another favorite sea chanty of mine, this one is a Capstan chantey, used for raising or lowering anchor. David Coffin is another guy who has appeared at the Mystic Seaport Sea Music Festival.