Saint Mary's Scouting Report | The Boneyard

Saint Mary's Scouting Report

Joined
Jan 6, 2015
Messages
8,427
Reaction Score
72,833
Saint Mary's: 27-7
KenPom Rating: 12
NET ranking: 11

2-3 vs Q1 ; 7-2 vs Q2
Best Win
  • 2/4/23 78-70 over Gonzaga in OT
    • Mahaney, 18 points, 7-11 from 2, 1-8 from 3
    • Team shot 59.5 2p%, 25.0 3p%

Worst Loss:
  • 3/7/23 77-51 to Gonzaga
    • Mahaney, 7 points, 2-8 from the field
    • Team shot 37.8 2p%, 25.0 3p%

OFFENSE: 42nd in efficiency
  • 3rd slowest tempo in the nation (20.4 seconds/possession)
  • 10th in preventing steals
  • 45th in offensive rebounding rate
  • 64th with a 36.3 3p%
    • 198th in 3PA/FGA (36.9%)
  • 148th with a 51.0 2p%
  • 167th in FTA/FGA (31.8%)
    • 277th with a 69.3 ft%
  • 225th in A/FGM (49.0%)
  • 293th in preventing blocks (10.2%)

DEFENSE: 8th in efficiency
  • 2nd in defensive rebounding rate
  • 3rd lowest A/FGM (36.6%)
  • 18th in opp. 2p% (45.4%)
  • 27th in 3PA/FGA (31.7%)
    • 103rd in opp. 3p% (32.8%)
  • 72nd in steal rate (10.6%)
  • 102nd in block rate (10.2%)
  • 140th in quickest opp. Avg length of possession (17.5 sec)
  • 159th in FTA/FGA (30.3)
    • 324th in opp. ft% (74.8%)

Mark Few and Gonzaga get all the national buzz, but Randy Bennett has been quietly doing his thing at Saint Mary’s for 21 years, leading the Gaels, go figure after playing Iona, to nine tournament selections and four in the last six seasons.

Aside from a 9 point loss and a 26 point loss to Gonzaga, part of the reason of the Gaels’ strong KP and NET rankings is that all of Saint Mary’s losses have been by 5 points or less, highlighted by a 53-48 loss to Houston.

Over the last decade or so, Randy Bennett coached Saint Mary’s teams shoot well, but don’t really attack the basket, limit turnovers and play very slowly: case in point, since the 2013-14 season, the Gaels’ highest ranking in offensive tempo was 324th. This has resulting in low scoring games, with opponents scoring 70 or more points in just five games, two of which were in OT.

On defense, typical Bennett coach teams are elite at defensive rebounding, preventing three-point attempts and make it really hard for teams to move the ball smoothly, ranking within the top-four in forcing ISO attempts in each of the last four seasons and top-six in fourteen seasons of Bennett’s tenure.

What makes Bennett such a good coach is that while he has his signatures, he is flexible in other ways. For example, between the 2010-11 and 2016-17 seasons, the Gaels had a low-ISO, three-point heavy offensive attack, which looks very different than his teams since then.
Screen Shot 2023-03-18 at 10.09.17 AM.png


The buzziest player on the Gaels is freshman guard Aidan Mahaney. He’s a flashy, wiry guard with an impressive handle, smooth stroke and offensive creativity to make mind-boggling passes. Between 11/24 and 2/8, Mahaney averaged 15.4 ppg at 47 FG% and scored single digits in only one game, but he’s in the middle of a five game slump, scoring nine points or less in four of the last five games, shooting a frigid 24.1% from inside the arc.

During that stretch, the Gaels have played three quality teams (Gonzaga twice, BYU and VCU), so I’m curious whether this slump is a freshman succumbing to the pressure of the big moment or whether it’s the result of playing better, older teams. No matter how it shakes, he’s been doo doo with the nadir being last night where foul trouble kept him scoreless and on the bench for the majority of the game.

Soaking up all of Mahaney’s minutes last night was sophomore guard Augustas Marciulionis, a bigger guard who plays a very different game: better defender, longer, stronger and focuses his offensive game away from the perimeter with the team’s highest FTA rate and second highest fouls drawn/40 rate (4.9). He’s a high-floor, lower ceiling guard than the mercurial Mahaney, subbing Marciulionis in for Mahaney leaves the Gaels with just two efficient three-point shooters (Ducas and Bowen).

Even though all of Saint Mary’s regulars have good vision, pass well and limit TOs, the de facto point guard is fifth-year Logan Johnson, easily the team’s best bucket getter and generator of his own offense. He’s not afraid to play downhill with the trees, but he is also the team’s smallest guard at 6’2 177. After taking just 26 3PAs across his first two seasons, now teams at least have to respect his three-point shot, but he is not an asset on the perimeter. Over the last three seasons, Johnson has averaged just 2.9 3PAs per game at 29.6%. Johnson was the WCC Defensive Player of the Year, whose scrappy, in-your-face style was on display last night.

Alex Ducas impressed me last night: he’s Saint Mary’s best perimeter weapon both in his shooting and distributing ability. He’s a low-mistake, efficient offensive wing with the team’s second best offensive rating (120.3) that also ranked 116th in the nation, but he is also no slouch on D with size, length, energy and sound fundamentals.

Mitchell Saxen is a classic, low-post big who was a capable passer in 5-out situations, but he is not a shooter. From my notes, none of his FGAs from last night were further than five feet from the basket but after the Gaels shot 36 FG% and 9 3p% at the half, Saxen’s offensive rebounding kept Saint Mary’s in the game.

I spent probably the most time focusing on Saxen, as I am very intrigued in how our 1-2 punch of Sanogo/Clingan will play against him, especially after he played 38 minutes last night. He’s strong, but has slower feet than most, if not, all of the bigs in the Big East.

Saxen was great last night (17 points on 8-11 shooting, 7 rebounds, 4 assists, 4 blocks) but VCU doesn’t play bigs: 6’9 215 Jalen DeLoach started and after Ace Baldwin went down with injury and VCU needed points, two of VCU’s best shooters, 6’8 240 Brandon Johns and 6’6 220 David Shriver, played the 5 and the 4, leaving Saxen in a juicy matchup taking advantage of their last of strength and defensive ability.

In keeping Sanogo and Clingan fresh, I see a huge advantage for UConn: either Saxen cannot play 38 minutes again, or if he does, no way he’ll be as dominant as he was against VCU.

Last but not least is Kyle Bowen, the Gaels’ best defensive forward and their glue guy. He’s not super athletic, but he always has his nose in on defense, with bullish strength and generally just takes up a lot of space. He’s got a really ugly one-handed outside shot, but somehow shoots 46.3% from three. I can see Bowen relish the opportunity to hound Karaban all night.

Yes, Saint Mary’s defense looked very impressive in person, but VCU’s offense is pretty ugly in itself, so it was hard to believe what was their style and what was a mirage due to the matchup.

In terms of matchups, there is an advantage to whoever is being guarded by Mahaney: he’s quick, but skinny and clearly the Gaels weakest defender, however, after he crapped the bed last night, I could see Bennett giving the stronger, less mistake-prone and bigger Marciulionis close to the same amount of PT tomorrow, especially since UConn is much bigger than VCU.

Personally, I think Saint Mary’s is underseeded as a 5 and UConn is underseeded as a 4, so it is a very good matchup. Like the VCU game, the team that gets to 60 first will probably win. Randy Bennett has really whittled down his rotation to six plus picking and choosing the other four players defending on matchups, so UConn has the clear advantage on depth.

KenPom’s prediction: UConn wins 66-63.
 
You say all that but IMO I'm not even sure SMC beats VCU without that injury. It was a four point game at that point.

Overall their starters match up decently with UConn's starters in terms of ability and role, not so sure they do in terms of size or athleticism.

UConn should kill them from the bench. They are very Creightonesque without Kalkbrenner to block shots, or someone as athletic as Kaluma.
 
If Gonzaga can boatrace this team then we can too. I was looking at the gameflows for SMU over the past 10 or so games, and they have a propensity to go scoreless for like 5-8 minutes at a time. We need to try to speed them up and tire them out. If we get a defensive rebound, run run run. Playing down to their tempo is countering our best advantage
 
.-.
This game seems like a classic example of making them play our game.

If we play their game (slow, grindy, halfcourt ), they probably win.

If we play our game (fast breaks, threes, up tempo), we probably win
 
VCU bothered them with their athleticism on defense and an intermittent press. We should be able to do the same.

If they are able to force us into isolation on the perimeter, it will be close. Hopefully the officials limit the grabbing and clutching of cutters coming off screens.
 
VCU bothered them with their athleticism on defense and an intermittent press. We should be able to do the same.

If they are able to force us into isolation on the perimeter, it will be close. Hopefully the officials limit the grabbing and clutching of cutters coming off screens.
That's what happened when Baldwin went out. Nunn was just unsuccessfully heaving up shots from straight up ISO.
 
.-.
Last but not least is Kyle Bowen, the Gaels’ best defensive forward and their glue guy. He’s not super athletic, but he always has his nose in on defense, with bullish strength and generally just takes up a lot of space. He’s got a really ugly one-handed outside shot, but somehow shoots 46.3% from three.
Thankfully he does not shoot 46% from 3.
 
If Gonzaga can boatrace this team then we can too. I was looking at the gameflows for SMU over the past 10 or so games, and they have a propensity to go scoreless for like 5-8 minutes at a time. We need to try to speed them up and tire them out. If we get a defensive rebound, run run run. Playing down to their tempo is countering our best advantage
I want the team to take high percentage shots. Not force things and have scoring droughts of our own necessitating us to speed them up. That won't work with SMC. Have a solid lead midway second period forcing them to speed up works better.

I'm hoping AJ gets a lot of back cuts for dunks.

This is the better way!
 
Right, but 38% is pretty good, on about as many 3s as Jackson.
Yeah he takes like 3 shots from 3 a game.. and maybe 1 attempt at the rim attacking a closeout or off a long offensive rebound. That's basically it. 10% usage rate is wildly low. He mostly just hides in the corner.

But a beast on defense. Very tough and strong. Karaban being a stretch big should neutralize him a bit at least.
 
Yeah he takes like 3 shots from 3 a game.. and maybe 1 attempt at the rim attacking a closeout or off a long offensive rebound. That's basically it. 10% usage rate is wildly low. He mostly just hides in the corner.

But a beast on defense. Very tough and strong. Karaban being a stretch big should neutralize him a bit at least.
Shaking Star Trek GIF
 
We will need to play defense without fouling, given those free throw numbers. Clingan's length can really alter or block the inside game, and Sanogo's strength will prevent being killed in the post when he's the guy. St. Mary's will have more trouble handling him on the other end, kind of like Timme.

And I agree. Run when you get any chance, but no turnovers and take good shots, don't just shoot quick to speed things up.
 
.-.
Sounds like we don't have a chance. Well, it's been a good season and something to build on for next year.........:(
 
Sounds like we don't have a chance. Well, it's been a good season and something to build on for next year.........:(
Just like we had no chance against Iona right?
 
.-.
Focus needs to be on rebounding. In their win vs the Zags, they out rebounded them. Houston, even in their win, got out rebounded. Same in their win against VCU.

Even with the lack of athletes as compared to some of their competition, it looks like almost everyone on the team has a nose for the ball. Its going to come down to our ability to team rebound. If we want to push the pace, we need to ensure we have the rebound instead of leaking early.
 
Last edited:
Just like Iona, Saint Mary's is made for Connecticut. They don't have the speed or the height to match up with UConn. Saxon is a traditional quality mid-major big man. He's way to show to guard Sanogo, and won't be about to get a shot off against Clingan.
In January, when you lost 4 of 5, I said you had the talent to make a Final Four run with the right matchups. The first two games have you halfway there.
I don't think it will be an early blowout, but more of a memorial pulling away, similar to Friday.
 
Thank you for your service.
Thank you. Which assistant coach should I email next, @husky429?
I don't like "4th best at forcing ISO attempts," since we don't really have a guy who can create scoring opportunities 1 on 1.
Alabama is 15th in the nation at forcing ISO attempts and has the 3rd best defense in the nation. We scored 82 points against them.

UConn has multiple distributors, basically all players except for our bigs. For me, a team that is 4th best at forcing ISO attempts feasts on teams with few distributors and a bunch of shooters and/or post guys. We aren't that type of team.
Sanogo is shifty enough to draw fouls on them. They will hack you.
Great point. If Saxen is in foul trouble, they are toast. That's why I love the matchup of our two excellent bigs vs their one very good big.
 
Thank you. Which assistant coach should I email next, @husky429?

Alabama is 15th in the nation at forcing ISO attempts and has the 3rd best defense in the nation. We scored 82 points against them.

UConn has multiple distributors, basically all players except for our bigs. For me, a team that is 4th best at forcing ISO attempts feasts on teams with few distributors and a bunch of shooters and/or post guys. We aren't that type of team.

Great point. If Saxen is in foul trouble, they are toast. That's why I love the matchup of our two excellent bigs vs their one very good big.
Indeed. The assists come from a mindset. Someone still has to beat the defense, either 1 on 1 or off of screens. But instead of getting a good shot, look for someone open for a GREAT shot instead. Defense plays a factor, but it isn't the only one
 
.-.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,169
Messages
4,555,607
Members
10,441
Latest member
Virginiafan


Top Bottom