Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Excalibur, post: 1973081, member: 62"] [SPOILER]I think they got it right given the time constraints with Jyn and Galen. You got the basics -- he worked on the Death Star, apparently developed a moral objection, escaped, was found and captured and forced to return to complete the project while Jyn escaped. That's enough for most non-nerds to be invested in the connection and story. I thought that they could have done more to develop some relationship with Saw and Jyn. There is absolutely no connection there, and the story is kind of begging for it. [/SPOILER] All in all, however, I liked [I]Rogue One[/I] far more than [I]The Force Awakens[/I], which in hindsight seems like the equivalent of a Boneyard post looking for easy likes -- it was a giant nostalgia play but the more I watch it the more I see its flaws. [/QUOTE]