I think he's a good coach, definitely not great. Certain attributes were well suited for getting us off the ground and those generally go unappreciated here. But the .500 record deserves context. Going .500 at at UConn while making the transition from D1AA to BCS football (a year early) is very different than going .500 at many, many other programs. I, and anyone else who has defended the accomplishments has never denied that the man is replaceable.You're taking this way too seriously. This is just a message board. I highly doubt the former players care at all about what we think.
Again, he was a little over .500 here and he's now a little under .500 for his career. Edsall is what he is, a decent coach. Nothing more, nothing less.
Whether or not they care is arguable. We know for a fact that some players have lurked here, parents have lurked/posted here, and former, current, (and likely future) recruits visit these boards as well to get a feel for the program and the fanbase. If they didn't care, they wouldn't be here.