For all of you that are making NBA success part of this discussion, please reconsider. The criteria should be solely what the player did during his COLLEGE career...NBA stardom is irrelevant. That is why Andre Drummond should never have his UConn number retired, because his one year here was only average (10.0 ppg, 7.6 reb). It is also why Kemba's NBA success shouldn't be an issue - his UConn career ended in 2011. And he would be a shoo-in if using the following standards.
So for having one's number retired, my criteria would be:
1. 1st or 2nd team All American
2. UConn all-time leader in scoring, rebounds, assists
That produces the following list:
AA's:
Marshall, Donyell
Allen
Hamilton
Butler
Okafor
Gay
Walker
Napier
Scoring: C Smith
Rebounds: Quimby
Assists: Brown, T
In scoring, Hamilton is #2 and already on the list. Hanson is #3 with 1,990 pts and warrants consideration.