Here are whitmers stats for the game, and broken down by half.
15/22 227 yards 1 td 0 int
1st. half
9/12 154 yards 1 td
2nd Half,
6/10 73 yards 0 td
o.k. he had 4 incompletions in 2nd half. (three of which you highlighted with the ball almost picked and two balls batted at the line of scrimmage. But don't forget, whitmer won this game today. He should get alot of the credit for his performance(the first half especially ). You make it seem like the reason the offense struggled in the second half was because buffalo has a clever defense, and whitmer who is essentially freshman, was "befuddled" with their coverages. That is not completely accurate. The offense was very vanilla the second half cause the team was ahead.
Whitmer's second half was similar to the maryland game. Meaning when this coaching staff ( PP and his " Play not to lose the game mentality") has a lead, they are going to be extremely conservative, they will run the ball the first two downs, and then if its 3rd and long, call a conservative pass play, short of the chains, and hope that the receiver can pick up yards after the catch. They will not call vertical plays down the field, most of the routes will be short, ala, TE, RB, FB, quick crossing patterns to the WR,
Now when the defense, pushes the safeties up to the line of scrimmage, and they have 8 or 9 players in the box to stop the run, the coaching staff elected not to attempt to throw the ball over the top and attack like in the 1st half. PP was ahead, and GD and PP believe that the first thing a QB should do is not lose the game. That is central to the play not to lose strategy. They do not want to turnover the ball in those situations, so they call a very conservative play, and they have no problem with putting the defense back out there.
The only reason Whitmer got a chance to throw the ball downfield in the first half is because buffalo took the lead 7-3. When you play not to lose, u only get a sense of urgency when you're behind in the game. ( i.e. WMU game) Its unfortunate, because, I think that with this team, the pass opens up the running game, and not the other way around. The team has to be very aggressive with the pass to attack teams down field, which then softens up the run defense. Whitmer managed the game in the second half, because that's what the coaching staff wanted him to do. Is he still making mistakes? of course, does he need to improve his ball security? absolutely. Could he have torched this buffalo defense, if the offensive play calling was aggressive, of course he could. He's just gotta limit his mistakes.