Poll - Who Should be Coach of the Year | The Boneyard

Poll - Who Should be Coach of the Year

Who Should be Coach of the year

  • Total voters
    116
Status
Not open for further replies.
Wbbfan1

Wbbfan1

And That’s The Way It Is
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
9,172
Reaction Score
17,478
Who do you think should be coach of the Year. Multiple answers are allowed as many of this board will automatically vote for Geno

Agree about Wes Moore, I probably should have included him over Jeff Walz.
 
Last edited:
Very, very good question................Strong arguments can be made for Geno ( short handed all season with 2 walk-on's) ; Muffet running the table and winning regular season conference title in first year of ACC; Dawn Staley coming out of no where to win SEC . There are many good candidates. I voted for Geno because I have watched UConn the most , seen the injuries , watched as he has coached a short bench , and still has gone undefeated.

No matter who wins it , it won't be a runaway with so many worthy coaches this year.
 
I know my choice may not be popular here but who thought a HOF coach like CVS would/could change her philosophy about overly depending on D and finally allow her girls to take the shot when they had an opening w/o repercussions as long as its in the flow of the game? I hate to admit it but I started to wonder if the game had passed her by until this year after recent disappointing season's with top notch talent constantly "underachieving" on the offensive side of the ball. Its nice to finally see some offensive scoring not coming on turnovers or 13 passes before settling for a bad shot before the clock runs out. She's got to at least be in the "receiving votes" category? McGraw/Geno should be right there but Staley might be the leader IMO and I'm just no fan of Mulkey as a HC though I thought she was cute when she was a player LOL.
 
HoopsFan21 said:
Agreed. My vote is for McGraw. Yeah, Geno has played with a short bench, but give me a break he still starts a team with 3 All Americans and a 4th that might be the best point guard in the country.
Expand ...
I agree under the circumstances McGraw is working with much less IMO than Geno but Staley has to be right there.
 
.-.
HGN said:
Very, very good question......Strong arguments can be made for Geno ( short handed all season with 2 walk-on's) ; Muffet running the table and winning regular season conference title in first year of ACC; Dawn Staley coming out of no where to win SEC . There are many good candidates. I voted for Geno because I have watched UConn the most , seen the injuries , watched as he has coached a short bench , and still has gone undefeated.

No matter who wins it , it won't be a runaway with so many worthy coaches this year.
Expand ...
Yes their are a quite a few worthy candidates this yr but Muffet or Staley seems to have the momentum with Geno right behind but no doubt Geno is peerless as a WBB HC IMO and I'm an RUWBB fan.
 
Walz though is not getting enough credit for what he's done at L'ville recently and I needed to mention that.
 
vowelguy said:
The only debate should be Muffet or Dawn.
Expand ...

vowelguy, with all due respect, I believe Wes Moore at NC State should, at the very least, be part of the conversation.

In his first year at the helm of the program, his Wolfpack squad is 23-5 (10-4 in the ACC), after NC State went 17-17 (7-11 in the ACC), 19-16 (5-11 inthe ACC), and 14-17 (4-10 in the ACC) in the last three years of Kelly Jolly Harper's tenure. He did not inherit McDonald's All-American players; rather, he has maximized the talent he has available to him on the roster. His team is 3rd in the ACC, with an RPI of 19 by two ranking services, and is 20th in the Sagarin rankings.
 
Last edited:
.-.
Thanks for others for making the case for Coach Moore.

What I imagine will happen though: Dawn Staley will win national Coach of the Year, and McGraw will win ACC Coach of the Year if ND goes undefeated. If NC State somehow manages to pull the huge upset Sunday, the ACC Coach of the Year award should and will go to Coach Moore. And if he were to win the ACC Coach of the Year award, it will be the first time any WBB coach at State has won it.
 
Last edited:
NickyNewark said:
I know my choice may not be popular here but who thought a HOF coach like CVS would/could change her philosophy about overly depending on D and finally allow her girls to take the shot when they had an opening w/o repercussions as long as its in the flow of the game? I hate to admit it but I started to wonder if the game had passed her by until this year after recent disappointing season's with top notch talent constantly "underachieving" on the offensive side of the ball. Its nice to finally see some offensive scoring not coming on turnovers or 13 passes before settling for a bad shot before the clock runs out. She's got to at least be in the "receiving votes" category? McGraw/Geno should be right there but Staley might be the leader IMO and I'm just no fan of Mulkey as a HC though I thought she was cute when she was a player LOL.
Expand ...
I think results on the court must trump a change in philosophy.
 
RegisteredUconn said:
I think results on the court must trump a change in philosophy.
Expand ...
Her results on the court are my reason though I realize she don't have that "signature" win yet this year shes gone from a "not gonna be back/renewed coach" to a I figure a 25 win if the season shakes out like I expect. With so young a lineup I thought she was finished before the season started to excited for the future again. Everybody votes their own idea of who deserves it and like I mentioned she should be in the "receiving votes" category,otherwise why not just give it to the HC of the national champ? Geno's made expectations so high at UConn and the wins seem to come so easy many miss the beauty of it outside huskynation.Results or scores don't always tell the whole story like when the NY FB Giants won the SB after a 9-7 regular season!!
 
CamrnCrz1974 said:
vowelguy, with all due respect, I believe Wes Moore at NC State should, at the very least, be part of the conversation.
Expand ...

No question that Moore has done a great job. But it seems national coach of the year only goes to a top ~10 team. That's what I was thinking of.
For ACC coach of the year, I'd say it's a tight race between Moore and Muffet.
 
vowelguy said:
No question that Moore has done a great job. But it seems national coach of the year only goes to a top ~10 team. That's what I was thinking of.
For ACC coach of the year, I'd say it's a tight race between Moore and Muffet.
Expand ...
That'll cause them to split the votes that will probably favor the Tobacco Rd school at NC St? But I'm not familiar with ACC politics so I could be wrong.
 
.-.
Good chance Muffett will win national Coach of the Year but not ACC. Different voting block.
Don't the coaches pick their league awards? National writers will pick between Muffett & Staley.
 
Who should be Coach of the Last 30 Years? The answer is obvious.
 
NickyNewark said:
I know my choice may not be popular here but who thought a HOF coach like CVS would/could change her philosophy about overly depending on D and finally allow her girls to take the shot when they had an opening w/o repercussions as long as its in the flow of the game? I hate to admit it but I started to wonder if the game had passed her by until this year after recent disappointing season's with top notch talent constantly "underachieving" on the offensive side of the ball. Its nice to finally see some offensive scoring not coming on turnovers or 13 passes before settling for a bad shot before the clock runs out. She's got to at least be in the "receiving votes" category? McGraw/Geno should be right there but Staley might be the leader IMO and I'm just no fan of Mulkey as a HC though I thought she was cute when she was a player LOL.
Expand ...

today we learn the difference between "drinking" the kool-aid, and "filling the bathtub" with the kool-aid...
 
HoopsFan21 said:
Agreed. My vote is for McGraw. Yeah, Geno has played with a short bench, but give me a break he still starts a team with 3 All Americans and a 4th that might be the best point guard in the country.
Expand ...

Well ND has McBride (All American), Achonwa (All American), Lloyd (All American this year), Allen (arguably best freshman pg and future All American), and has not had any major injuries.
 
huskybill said:
I can't tell you their names, but there are 5 or 6 writing on the BoneYard who are certainly better than Geno.
Expand ...

Good point, I agree. UConn and ND coaches just simply do not have the dynamic fresh impact of the USC coach. Coupled with her U18 coach selection puts the highlite on her. I think the award should go to the NC champ team coach, but our country just puts too much emphasis on the "darling" factor.
 
.-.
Jeff, Geno & Muffet held up their respective reputations very well, but coach of the year would seem to imply a gain, a new standing out, a surprise season. If the season ended right now, I go with Dawn.
 
Geno's still the best coach, but I'd vote for Dawn based on this discussion because it qualifies the vote.
 
CLE802A said:
Is this really a hard question to answer?

In October, during the SEC's Media Days, the media voted based on paper - and not based on actual talent - what USC was bringing back for this season, and voted them to finish 7th - SEVENTH - in their conference. And while the media oftentimes displays a true ignorance in reviewing sports teams (and they certainly screwed the pooch here), it all shows how much BOTH Staley and USC were under-appreciated, as well as how improved as a program they were all in the same breadth.
Expand ...

Or it could just mean that the other teams in the SEC are overrated.
 
If Kim doesn't win COY she better damn well win Best Dressed and Most Congenial!
 
.-.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
167,930
Messages
4,545,423
Members
10,426
Latest member
kmbazz15


Top Bottom