OT: - Playoff Baseball Rainout Question | The Boneyard

OT: Playoff Baseball Rainout Question

XLCenterFan

CT, NE
Joined
Feb 25, 2018
Messages
3,539
Reaction Score
13,468
I have tickets to the Yankees game on Thursday. Forecast calls for a nice and steady rain all afternoon/evening.

What will they do and when will they decide by? Move game to Wednesday? Friday?
 
Joined
Mar 20, 2016
Messages
1,565
Reaction Score
13,704
I have tickets to the Yankees game on Thursday. Forecast calls for a nice and steady rain all afternoon/evening.

What will they do and when will they decide by? Move game to Wednesday? Friday?
They definitely won’t move a Thursday game to Wednesday. There is an off day on Friday, so that’s when the game would be made up. I’m not sure how last-minute the call would be made.
 
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
2,942
Reaction Score
10,263
While on the subject of the baseball playoffs. They are not using the "ghost" runner in extra innings, I am 100% in favor of not using it. But again, why change the rules from the regular season? As a traditionalist baseball fan this "ghost runner" stinks.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
16,307
Reaction Score
24,078
While on the subject of the baseball playoffs. They are not using the "ghost" runner in extra innings, I am 100% in favor of not using it. But again, why change the rules from the regular season? As a traditionalist baseball fan this "ghost runner" stinks.
I understand that in the regular season it saves pitching staffs from those 15 inning games. In the post season getting a run the traditional way makes the test truer and less up to chance by using the old way. I agree with the way they’re doing it. They went to the 3 game wild card for a fairer truer test than just a 1 game elimination.
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
10,506
Reaction Score
15,859
I understand that in the regular season it saves pitching staffs from those 15 inning games. In the post season getting a run the traditional way makes the test truer and less up to chance by using the old way. I agree with the way they’re doing it. They went to the 3 game wild card for a fairer truer test than just a 1 game elimination.
Was fine with ghost runner rule in the condensed pandemic season, don’t like it otherwise just expand the rosters.
 
Joined
May 30, 2018
Messages
2,137
Reaction Score
5,952
I understand that in the regular season it saves pitching staffs from those 15 inning games. In the post season getting a run the traditional way makes the test truer and less up to chance by using the old way. I agree with the way they’re doing it. They went to the 3 game wild card for a fairer truer test than just a 1 game elimination.
It may be fairer for the wild card round but the LDS round now favors the Divisional winners even more. This could be case of pitcher attrition in the Divisional Series' games. Especially tough for San Diego who had to play 3 games and use all those pitchers.
 
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
14,474
Reaction Score
79,859
It may be fairer for the wild card round but the LDS round now favors the Divisional winners even more. This could be case of pitcher attrition in the Divisional Series' games. Especially tough for San Diego who had to play 3 games and use all those pitchers.
Wasn't that the whole point? Make teams go for the first 2 spots to get an advantage.

Remember when there was just 1 Wild Card team and no real advantage except home field? Many teams would favor setting up their pitching and resting guys to winning their division.
 
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
13,283
Reaction Score
88,662
It may be fairer for the wild card round but the LDS round now favors the Divisional winners even more. This could be case of pitcher attrition in the Divisional Series' games. Especially tough for San Diego who had to play 3 games and use all those pitchers.
90 Day Fiance Mom GIF by TLC
 
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
2,942
Reaction Score
10,263
I understand that in the regular season it saves pitching staffs from those 15 inning games. In the post season getting a run the traditional way makes the test truer and less up to chance by using the old way. I agree with the way they’re doing it. They went to the 3 game wild card for a fairer truer test than just a 1 game elimination.
How about if managers could manage pitching staffs better. Or maybe relievers could go for more than one inning.
 
Joined
May 30, 2018
Messages
2,137
Reaction Score
5,952
I understand the point that it is fairer for divisional champs but as a fan I enjoyed the one game do or die format. I'm sure Saint Louis feels different about it that Cleveland fans however. It was already cold in some northern cities such as Cleveland so wondering how this extended season will affect the world series.
 

SubbaBub

Your stupidity is ruining my country.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
32,153
Reaction Score
24,760
How is any of this about rain delays?

They will try to play for the sake of TV but they will try not to get into a situation where the starting pitchers only go a couple innings or have long rain delays.

They will wait until the last possible second (when it's clear the forecast/radar) shows the game can not be completed easily. They will push the start time first if necessary.

If you are a ticket holder, be flexible and commit to going, going both days or not going with the knowledge that a refund isn't coming. Keep an eye on the forecast and make your own call.
 

Husky25

Dink & Dunk beat the Greatest Show on Turf.
Joined
Sep 10, 2012
Messages
18,511
Reaction Score
19,487
The Guardians have a day off after each game in New York. The second day is meant for travel, the first is for TV purposes. They would never pull a game up, which would cause significant interference with pitching staffs. MLB will wait until probably an hour or so before game time. They will not want the starters to begin their pre-game throwing routines, just to be shut down minutes before 1st pitch. If they do postpone, expect the game to be pushed to Friday at an odd hour in order to make an effort to not conflict with other scheduled games.

For reference, recall 2004. Game 3 in Boston vs. New York was rained out and became Game 5 on Monday. Those who originally had Game 4 and Game 5 tickets used them on their scheduled day, irrespective of what "game" they were for. "Game 3" tickets were honored on Monday. This way, only 35,000 people were inconvenienced vs. potentially 105,000 had they just pushed everyone back a day. First pitch was around 5:00. Of course as luck would have it, the Houston/St. Louis game, which started in the 8:00 hour, was or was nearly over before the Red Sox won that night.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Oct 15, 2013
Messages
594
Reaction Score
1,040
How about if managers could manage pitching staffs better. Or maybe relievers could go for more than one inning.
Or MLB not restrict roster makeup to limit number of pitchers.
 
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
14,474
Reaction Score
79,859
I have tickets to the Yankees game on Thursday. Forecast calls for a nice and steady rain all afternoon/evening.

What will they do and when will they decide by? Move game to Wednesday? Friday?
Friday 1:00 it is. Day baseball is better anyway.

 
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
2,942
Reaction Score
10,263
Or MLB not restrict roster makeup to limit number of pitchers.
You propose adding more pitchers to rosters? As it is now most teams carry 4 position players on their roster. One has to be a back up catcher. That might leave one or two position players on the bench. Get ready for pitchers playing the field.
 

Chin Diesel

Power of Love
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
32,576
Reaction Score
98,570
You propose adding more pitchers to rosters? As it is now most teams carry 4 position players on their roster. One has to be a back up catcher. That might leave one or two position players on the bench. Get ready for pitchers playing the field.

Lol. A pitcher who can double as a position player???

Babe Ruth isn't walking through rhe door again.

Any pitcher who could play on the field is worth $50m if they could hit .250
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
1,996
Reaction Score
6,415
Lol. A pitcher who can double as a position player???

Babe Ruth isn't walking through rhe door again.

Any pitcher who could play on the field is worth $50m if they could hit .250
I'm curious, why is that? I used to follow college baseball more, and have always just been a very casual Indians/Guardians fan, but there's certainly a fair amount of guys that do that in college. Obviously still not super common, but significantly more so than you see in the league.

My example here isn't helping my case since it's ~15 yrs ago, but Sean Doolittle at UVA immediately came to mind. He was 1st/2nd team AA in both pitching and 1B. However, in the league he's been just a pitcher. I'm assuming just the level of talent forces you to focus on one position?

edit: realize my question was ambiguous...not, why isn't babe ruth walking through the door. why isn't positional player pitchers not more common?
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
255
Reaction Score
1,474
I'm curious, why is that? I used to follow college baseball more, and have always just been a very casual Indians/Guardians fan, but there's certainly a fair amount of guys that do that in college. Obviously still not super common, but significantly more so than you see in the league.

My example here isn't helping my case since it's ~15 yrs ago, but Sean Doolittle at UVA immediately came to mind. He was 1st/2nd team AA in both pitching and 1B. However, in the league he's been just a pitcher. I'm assuming just the level of talent forces you to focus on one position?

edit: realize my question was ambiguous...not, why isn't babe ruth walking through the door. why isn't positional player pitchers not more common?
Really good question. I've always just assumed that it's a testament to how hard it is to succeed at the major league level. So much attention has to be paid to either fielding/hitting or pitching or else you won't last. I bet many guys could do both at a somewhat mediocre level but teams would rather have specialists that do one thing extremely well. Also, shows why baseball folks are so enamored with Ohtani who can do both at all-star levels.
 
Joined
Oct 15, 2013
Messages
594
Reaction Score
1,040
Really good question. I've always just assumed that it's a testament to how hard it is to succeed at the major league level. So much attention has to be paid to either fielding/hitting or pitching or else you won't last. I bet many guys could do both at a somewhat mediocre level but teams would rather have specialists that do one thing extremely well. Also, shows why baseball folks are so enamored with Ohtani who can do both at all-star levels.
You have a majority of major league catchers who are great defensively but struggle to even hit .220 so in some regards you already have a level of mediocrity in position players.
 

Online statistics

Members online
233
Guests online
3,046
Total visitors
3,279

Forum statistics

Threads
156,894
Messages
4,069,662
Members
9,951
Latest member
Woody69


Top Bottom