Sometimes we use the word "athletic" to mean muscular, and on that meaning, Aaliyah is very athletic, and maybe only Ayanna compares to her, or Aubrey once she's fully recovered.
But a fuller sense of "athletic" can also include lots of other physical and mental dimensions, and if we think of it that way, a healthy Paige is pretty clearly the most athletic player in the country, and only Caitlin Clark, Aaliyah Boston and Haley Jones really compare. I predict we'll be adding Azzi and Caroline to this list by the end of this coming season. I also think this is what Geno means when he distinguishes between "kids who play basketball well" and basketball players.